Scholarship and
intellectual communities are only viable if they
are dynamic and contested spaces for critical
thinking and debate. Black studies began in
heated struggle. Here in Chicago, Malcolm X
College was founded with a Black studies
curriculum, and protests at Evanston’s
Northwestern University followed suit. At the
University of Illinois Chicago, then called
Circle Campus, theater and speech professor
Grace Holt became the founding director of Black
studies in 1974. Hundreds of departments now
exist around the country, and the field has had
a powerful impact on higher education.
Today, Black studies
is under assault. Unfounded criticisms of Black
studies and theories and paradigms emerging from
it, like intersectionality and critical race
theory, have made headlines. For example,
Florida’s governor, Ron DeSantis, with no
background or content expertise in these
subjects, famously and scurrilously targeted
so-called “woke” scholarship and teaching,
threatening to ban academic literature in his
state that did not meet his criteria for
legitimacy.
A number of states
have followed suit, imposing restrictions on the
teaching of various aspects of Black studies
curricula. Organized resistance to DeSantis’
attacks culminated in a “National Day of Action
for the Freedom To Learn” on May 3, led by
prominent Black studies professors.
As an
interdisciplinary field, it began in 1968 at San
Francisco State University, with rumblings at
other schools around the country resulting in
similar programs soon after. During the
tumultuous social movements of that era,
students demanded inclusion, correctives to
racist and exclusionary narratives and syllabi,
and a rethinking of how Black people had been
distorted and/or erased from larger histories
and canons.
Why Black studies?
Any serious student of U.S. history knows our
country’s long and violent history when it comes
to race. Slavery, Jim Crow segregation,
political disenfranchisement are all hallmarks
of our racial past. Mass incarceration, unequal
access to healthcare, housing and education, the
racial wealth gap and racial profiling are all
continued evidence of persistent racism. Higher
education is a part of that history. For most of
this nation’s history, Black scholars and
students were either excluded, openly
discriminated against or tokenized. The Black
freedom movement of the 1950s and ’60s forced
open the doors of public education and higher
education for Black scholars and students. And
so, with them came the demand for more inclusive
curricula and research opportunities. This was
the impetus for Black studies.
Black studies as a
field did more than meet the demands of Black
faculty and students. The creation of Black
studies was an impactful intervention in the
writing and teaching of American history,
culture and politics in general. The New York
Times' highly touted “1619 Project” created a
stir because it challenged the dominant and
sugar-coated narrative of the U.S. past.
As
Northwestern University historian Martha Biondi
points out in her book, “The Black Revolution on
Campus,” the establishment of Black studies
challenged universities to critically rethink
fundamental questions, insisting “that public
universities should reflect and serve the people
of their communities, that private universities
should rethink the mission of elite education,
and that historically Black colleges should
survive the era of integration.” All of those
goals have certainly not been fully achieved,
but Black studies’ initiatives have changed the
way we think of new knowledge production,
meritocracy, pedagogy, university governance and
even epistemology (our theories of knowledge).
Black
studies as a field has done a lot of
intellectual heavy lifting in the past 50-plus
years, producing award-winning scholarship, a
generation of critical thinking students and
models of institutional change. Still, there is
so much more ground-breaking work to do over the
next 50 years.
This
commentary is also posted on ChicagoBusiness.com
|
|