Democrats in statewide political
races have much to learn from outcomes in
2022 midterm races. While the Democratic
Senatorial Campaign Committee (DSCC) has
been taking a victory lap for the retention
of all Senate Democratic incumbents up for
reelection, it had little to do with the
victory of Sen. Raphael Warnock’s triumph
over Herschel Walker, Trump’s handpicked
Republican candidate for the seat.
There are important lessons to be
learned from these recent political events
although they have been exaggerated in many
instances by Democrats and Republicans,
alike. Both groups claimed to have mobilized
their voters to come out in Georgia’s
December 6th runoff, but Sen. Warnock was
singularly excellent in rallying his base
voters and a respectful number of
Independents, Republican dissidents,
unaffiliated voters, and ethnic minorities
to support him.
His singular efforts (co-developed
by Stacey Abrams) were instrumental in his
win. He campaigned in all 159 Georgia
counties with a message tailored to their
policy interests and needs. As a result of
these efforts, he was able to reduce his
loss margins in red counties - between
November 9th and December 6th - by an
average of five points, thus increasing his
overall vote totals.
This strategy is reminiscent of the
campaign strategies implemented by Doug
Wilder (in his battle to become the first
African American Governor of Virginia in
1989), Deval Patrick (in his race to become
the first Black Governor of Massachusetts in
2006), and Barack Obama (in his quest to
become the first African American President
in 2008). They all pursued nearly identical
political tactics to accomplish their goals.
First,
a mistake that is routinely made by Black
candidates is that those who are embraced
by the Party’s power structure virtually
always surround themselves with
non-African American advisors and
strategists who are well-intentioned but
lack the necessary cultural understandings
and community connections to advance their
candidates. The more recent ones rely on
algorithms, analytics, etc. that have
limited utility to African American and
other ethnic-minority aspirants.
These
advisors
direct minimal dollars to minority field
generals, advertising agencies, and
get-out-the- vote (GOTV) leaders. And the
returns on these meager contributions reveal
these facts. But sadly, the Black contenders
are oblivious to this reality and keep
repeating the same dumb approaches and
expecting a different result.
Voters of color are keen observers
of their methods and have responded with
disinterest and lower turnout rates as
compared to those of their Republican
opponents which doom them to defeat. As
noted in earlier columns, Cheri Beasley, a
midterm Democratic contender for the U.S.
Senate in North Carolina and Mandela Barnes,
a Democrat who competed for the U.S. Senate
seat in Wisconsin both lost by narrow
margins in their respective contests against
right-wing Republicans who employed racial
dog whistles throughout their campaigns.
The disconcerting part of these
situations is that Cheri Beasley lost a
statewide race for Chief Justice in 2020
using the same failed strategy and
apparently learned nothing from it. And
Mandela Barnes who became Wisconsin’s first
Black Lt. Governor in 2018, on the strength
of the African American vote, largely
ignored his key constituency in 2022. They
both made strategic mistakes and suffered
from low turnout of their base voters.
Second,
Wilder, Patrick, and Obama organized their
respective natural bases of Blacks and
other ethnic minority voters (Hispanics,
Native Americans [whatever the population
size], and Asian and Pacific Islanders.)
They recognized that these are the fastest
growing American populations which are
driving the nation toward being a
non-majority country by 2040, and perhaps
earlier. Moreover, their combined growth
is significant in many states including
California, Georgia, Massachusetts, North
Carolina, Texas, Virginia, and many others
which are rapidly changing the voting
electorate.
Warnock, for example, developed
language and culturally-specific radio and
TV ads and literature to reach these
individuals. He also sent out multi-racial
and multi-cultural door-to-door teams to
canvass voters and to get them to the polls.
These approaches were modeled by Doug
Wilder, Deval Patrick, and Barack Obama.
They understood that voters need to be
respected, especially ethnic minorities, who
have been historically taken for granted by
both political parties, especially
Democrats.
These continuing oversights are
inexcusable as the voting demographics
continue to change moving forward. Political
contestants will have to be even more
attentive to the approximate projected
growth of ethnic minority Americans by 2050
or before:
-
Asian Americans and Pacific
Islanders by 420%,
-
Hispanic Americans by 250%,
-
Native Americans by 110% and
-
African Americans by 98%.
The aforementioned errors will have
to be corrected by those African American
and other ethnic minority nominees. It also
needs to be recognized that there are
multiple ethnic subgroups within ethnic
minority populations. Thoughtful, seasoned
politicians already know this and proceed
accordingly.
Former
Black
Congresswoman Karen Bass (D-CA), who was
recently elected Mayor of Los Angeles, was
outspent by her billionaire adversary, Rick
Caruso (a Republican before he announced for
mayor) 11:1 ($104 million to $9 million).
She organized Los Angeles’ diverse
demographic groups (comprised of Hispanics,
Blacks, Asians, and Native Americans) and
drove their turnout to the polls to vote her
into office.
Democrats and Blacks are urged to
reconsider and correct these political
miscues as they prepare for 2024. Otherwise,
they could be headed for disaster up and
down the ballot.