In a moment
of candor, President Biden told Democratic
Party contributors the risk of nuclear
“Armageddon” is the highest since the 1962
Cuban Missile Crisis, when the Soviet Union
installed nuclear missiles in Cuba, 90 miles
from Florida. Referring to Russian President
Putin’s veiled threats to use short-range
nuclear weapons in Ukraine, the President
added it was the first time since the Cuban
Missile Crisis such a “direct threat” had
been issued.
Not true.
The US has
a history of nuclear extortion.
In
I950,
during the Korean War, President
Truman said launching nuclear
weapons was under “active
consideration”
against Chinese troops in North
Korea.
In
1953,
President Eisenhower–who later
denounced the military industrial
complex–threatened
to order a nuclear launch if the
Chinese refused to negotiate an
armistice in the Korean War.
In
1969,
during the Vietnam War, President
Nixon secretly ordered B-52 nuclear
bombers on high alert to pressure
the North Vietnamese to surrender.
Nixon subscribed to the “madman
theory”--make your enemy believe you
are mad enough to use nuclear
weapons and the enemy will fold. But
that theory proved ineffective, with
US troops fleeing Vietnam in 1973
after an estimated 2-million
Vietnamese
lay
dead, nearly 60,000 US soldiers in
body bags.
The
list
of US nuclear extortion threats
continues in 2007 with President
George W. Bush stating “All options
are on the table”
should Iran pursue a nuclear
program.
In
2017,
President Donald Trump–in the wake
of North Korean missile testing – threatened
North Korea with “fire and fury …
the likes of which the world has
never seen before.”
In
2020,
the US deployed
B-52s,
dual capable of conventional and
nuclear weapons, flying over the
Black and Baltic seas to simulate
attacks
on Russia’s military bases and
ports.
The
uncomfortable truth is that as long as there
are nuclear weapons, we are all hostage to
those few individuals who can order their
launch.
On the
anniversary of the Cuban Missile Crisis, the
answer is not to build more nuclear weapons,
but to return to the arms control treaties
Bush and Trump abandoned and to sign on to
the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear
Weapons to abolish nuclear weapons from the
face of the earth.
At the
Democratic Party fundraiser, President Biden
also said, “"We are trying to figure out
what is Putin’s off ramp? Where does he find
a way out?”
The way out
is for President Biden and every member of
Congress to immediately call for a
ceasefire, support peace negotiations and
end the weapons shipments that risk
Armageddon.
Skeptics
argue diplomacy would set a dangerous
precedent allowing any autocrat from a
nuclear-armed nation to hold the sword of
Damocles over our head.
In reality,
the stage for nuclear blackmail was set long
ago, in 1945, when at the close of WWII,
President Truman dropped atomic bombs on
Hiroshima and three days later Nagasaki to
irradiate and annihilate an estimated
200,000 people in an explosion of fire and a
rain of ash.
The
stage
for nuclear extortion was set when
President George W. Bush in 2002
abandoned the Anti-Ballistic
Missile
(ABM) Treaty
that capped the number of missile
systems the US and Russia could
deploy to destroy incoming missiles.
Both countries had recognized that
defensive missile systems could
escalate the arms race with the
development of new weapons to
overcome the defensive shields, and
that such shields–if promised
effective–might encourage a country
to launch a first strike without
fear of retaliation.
The
stage
for nuclear blackmail was set in
2019 when former President Donald
Trump ripped up the US-Russia Intermediate-Range
Nuclear
Forces (INF) Treaty.
Before this, the two superpowers had
destroyed almost 3,000 short and
intermediate range missiles.
As recently
as last year the US Congress, in violation
of its commitments under the Nuclear
Nonproliferation Treaty (NPT), voted to
continue funding a trillion-dollar nuclear
“modernization” program. As part of this
decades-long nuclear rearmament, the US will
replace 400 Minuteman Intercontinental
Ballistic Missiles (ICBM’s) on hair trigger
alert in the midwest with 600 new nuclear
missiles. These new missiles buried deep in
underground silos will pack nuclear warheads
that are each 20 times more powerful than
those the US dropped on Japan.
From
explicit threats to implicit threats, the US
has resorted to nuclear blackmail throughout
the years.
President
John F. Kennedy resolved the Cuban Missile
Crisis, not with weapons but diplomacy. The
US offered to remove nuclear weapons
installed in Turkey in exchange for the
Soviet Union’s removal of missiles from
Cuba.
President
Biden could follow in JFK’s footsteps by
offering to remove anti-ballistic missiles
from Poland and Romania. He could offer to
support neutrality for Ukraine. These are
off ramps.
On
the
anniversary of this 13-day Cuban
missile crisis in which the world
waited and prayed, the answer is not
to hurl more arms at Ukraine to risk
nuclear war but to support an
immediate ceasefire and pursue a
diplomatic settlement to bring us
back from the brink.
This
commentary
is also posed on CODEPINK
|