Heads
of state from the world’s wealthiest nations gathered for the
first time in person since the start of the COVID-19 pandemic at the
recent G20 summit meeting in Rome, Italy. The two-day meeting
culminated in a grand dinner at the Quirinale Palace, where the
evening’s menu
featured salmon with dill, pumpkin risotto, sea bass fillets, tomato
and celeriac puff pastry, and for dessert, a “delicate”
steamed mandarin cream. Guests sat around a large formal dining table
in a high-ceilinged palatial room with an impressive crystal
chandelier and window dressings of tasseled red drapes.
The
dinner was the modern-day equivalent of “let them eat cake,”
the phrase (inaccurately)
attributed to the epitome of frivolous luxury by the ruling class
(and the last queen of France before the French Revolution), Marie
Antoinette. The leaders of the G20 nations, who had gathered under
the banner of “People,
Planet, Prosperity,”
appear to have disproportionately focused on the third rung of their
agenda and limited its scope to the prosperity of elites like them.
On the three critical issues of climate change, global corporate
taxation, and COVID-19 vaccines, the world’s wealthiest nations
looked out for themselves at the expense of the rest of the world.
In
contrast to the United Nations General Assembly, which represents all
the world’s nations, the G20
is a self-selected private club of the top tier of global wealth,
only one step below the even-more-exclusive G7
club.
Its members are mostly economic powerhouses, with a handful of
exceptions of developing nations such as India, China, South Africa,
Mexico, and Argentina.
Proudly
proclaiming
that G20 nations “account for more than 80 percent of world
GDP” and “75 percent of global trade,” the club
sets the rules of global finance. Summit host Mario Draghi, the
Italian prime minister, said the 2021 gathering demonstrated that
multilateral decision-making is once more possible, declaring,
“We have succeeded, in the sense of keeping our dreams alive,”
with no mention of how self-serving the exclusive club really is.
Although
the 26th meeting of the United Nations Conference of Parties (COP) in
Glasgow, Scotland, is currently generating more news headlines than
this year’s G20 summit, wealthy nations made many of their
preliminary decisions on climate
change
at their club meeting before the global climate gathering. While they
came to agreement on a handful
of issues,
such as cutting off funding to coal plants, and getting to “net-zero”
emissions in a few decades, climate advocates slammed the pledges as
“the bare minimum.” Draghi admitted, “It’s
easy to suggest difficult things. It’s very very difficult to
actually execute them.”
Eric
LeCompte, executive director of Jubilee
USA Network,
explained to me in an interview
that developing countries are suffering from the fact that “their
natural resources were taken during the industrialization period that
took place in Europe and the United States in the 1800s and the
1900s, fueling the climate crisis.”
Most
of these same nations were left out of the recent climate discussions
by the G20, as they are too poor to be considered members of the
exclusive club. It remains to be seen if these nations will be able
to extract greater commitments at the COP26 meeting.
LeCompte
reflected, “it seems right now that there is a lot of despair
among countries in terms of if it’s going to be possible to
fulfill” pledges like a $100
billion financing pledge
to help poorer nations combat climate change. Indeed, UN
Secretary-General António Guterres declared on Twitter
as the summit ended, “While I welcome the #G20’s
recommitment to global solutions, I leave Rome with my hopes
unfulfilled.”
In
addition to their shamefully insufficient climate pledges, G20
leaders congratulated themselves on tackling the issue of corporate
tax evasion. The grand agreement they came to was a minimum 15
percent tax rate
for wealthy companies. Hailed as a historic deal, the goal was to
ensure reliable tax revenues from big corporations that chase tax
havens offering lucrative terms. U.S. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen
declared that the agreement would “end the damaging race to the
bottom on corporate taxation.”
LeCompte
commented that the 15 percent minimum rate was “certainly
progress but falls short of the more ambitious calls of the Biden
administration earlier on of 27-28 percent.” And, shockingly,
it exempts digital
technology corporations
largely based in the U.S., like Google, Facebook, Amazon, and Apple,
from being subject to this bare-bones rate. The U.S. essentially
lobbied the G20 on behalf of these major companies to carve out the
loophole.
LeCompte
explained that “this agreement really only supports and helps
the wealthy countries.” While the United States would raise an
additional $60
billion
in revenues if the agreement is actually adopted, developing nations
would not see much of an increase in revenues and are particularly
impacted by the tax exemptions for digital technology companies. Even
the Wall
Street Journal
admitted that the G20 tax deal “makes rich countries big
winners.”
The
G20 nations are also disproportionate beneficiaries of COVID-19
vaccine technology. Draghi
opened the summit’s proceedings by acknowledging that the
world’s wealthiest nations have vaccination rates of about 70
percent while only 3 percent of residents in poor nations have been
vaccinated. He called such a gap, “morally unacceptable.”
Indeed,
LeCompte shared that “the crisis in many developing countries
is really horrific,” and that “most countries are
experiencing economic loss because of not having access to vaccines.”
Ahead of the summit, he expected the G20 to offer a concrete plan for
financing and distributing vaccines to the world’s poorest
nations. And yet, at the summit, “they didn’t do that,”
said LeCompte. Instead, he said that “they put forward a
process in order to do it.”
That
process was essentially to create a task
force,
which, according to a statement signed by G20 leaders, is “aimed
at enhancing dialogue and global cooperation on issues relating to
pandemic prevention, preparedness and response.” One advocacy
group, Global Citizen, dismissed such demonstrations of lip service,
saying, “It’s no longer the time for statements of
intentions. Now is the time for our leaders to act.”
Among
the only pandemic-related achievements at the G20 was a deal that the
U.S. arranged for the African Union to buy
33 million doses of the Moderna vaccine
originally intended for sale to the U.S.—an embarrassingly low
bar for success on vaccine equity.
While
the G20 leaders and their spouses enjoyed their fine dining
experience at the culmination of their two-day meeting, it became
clear that the summit was little more than an exercise in grand
pontifications
of
multilateralism. Like the erstwhile top echelons of pre-revolutionary
French society, the world’s wealthy nations remain out of touch
with reality.
This
article was produced by Economy
for All,
a project of the Independent Media Institute.
|