In
searching through all the historical and media data at my disposal,
I can�t find one solitary example of a professional athlete suffering
two entirely disconnected accusations of sexual assault over one
eight month period.
Enter
Pittsburgh Steelers Quarterback Ben Roethlisberger, our very own
Jackie Robinson of misogyny, arrogance and entitlement. This
is a man who thought that a night of drunken nightclub bathroom
�encounters� in Milledgeville, Georgia, with a 20-year-old Georgia
college student � while his entourage blocked the door � was a solid
plan.
Ben
lawyered up only saying that sexual contact with the accuser �was
not consummated.� He declined to submit the DNA that the district
attorney�s office requested, and despite described �minor�
cuts and bruising on the young woman, the DA decided not to press
charges. Ocmulgee Circuit District Attorney Fred Bright, when announcing
this decision, said gruffly, �If he were my son, the best way I
could answer it is, Ben, grow up. Come on, you're supposed to stand
for something.�
That
was assumedly supposed to sound tough, but it came off like a paternal
scolding: the typical �boys will be boys� defense. That is, if the
boys are the right shade of pale. Georgia is the state after all
where in 2005 17-year-old Genarlow Wilson (also, incidentally, a
high school football star and not so incidentally, African American)
was given a mandatory 10-year prison sentence for consensual oral
sex with a 15 year old. After two years behind bars, he was released
following a 4-3 decision by the Georgia State Supreme Court. The
court did not overturn Wilson�s conviction, but ruled that his sentence
was �grossly disproportionate". In contrast, Roethlisberger
may never have to spend even two minutes in the maximum-security
prison that housed Wilson.
But
Big Ben�s drama is far from over. He still faces a civil suit
from the first round of sexual assault allegations and may possibly
in this case as well. It's this kind of behavior that has the Pro
Bowl quarterback wearing out his welcome in Pittsburgh. The Steelers
organization believes that they are more than just another franchise.
They are Steeler Nation and no player is more important than the
honor of the brand.
If
Coach Mike Tomlin had a hot young quarterback on the bench, Roethlisberger
might be trade bait. Without that option the Steelers chose instead
to make an example out of their best receiver, 2009 Super Bowl MVP
Santonio Holmes. Holmes was traded to the Jets for a pittance (a
fifth round draft pick). He was also no stranger to off-field trouble
and the fact that the Steelers dumped him to a conference rival
so unceremoniously is without question a shot across the bow at
Big Ben. But this action as well is raising ethical eyebrows.
As Jeffrey Chadiha wrote on ESPN.com, �If they go soft on Roethlisberger,
it will appear the organization dumped the black guy with issues
while the white guy got a slap on the wrist for his mistakes.�
In
addition to having to re-earn the respect of his teammates, coaches,
fans, and management, Roethlisberger will also have to sit down
with NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell later this week, which should
be about as pleasant as a switchblade-root canal. Goodell holds
the power of judge, jury, and executioner: he can suspend players
without appeal and even demand that they seek counseling (we can
imagine how effective counseling is when ordered by your boss.)
Goodell
will be under a microscope to see if he actually exercises this
power against Roethlisberger. There has been more than a little
rumbling to the effect that the Goodell�s unilateral brand of justice
is used exclusively against African American players to show a majority
white fan base that the Commish is keeping his �urban� charges in
line. Goodell will look like a rank hypocrite if he lets Big Ben
skate. In fact, he would look even worse if he does nothing, and
then the Rooney family - which owns the Steelers - decides to suspend
him on their own.
The
mainstream media has also been interrogated for how they've covered
Big Ben's year gone wild. Think about how often in the Tiger Woods
telenovela journalists and yipping heads said that Tiger �owed�
the public an explanation for his private life. Yet with two allegations
of sexual violence, the two-time Super Bowl winning quarterback
has never been hounded for dirty details in the same way.
The
�worldwide leader�, ESPN, in particular was criticized last year
for under-covering the first rape allegation, initially issuing
an infamous "do not report' memo to reporters. Apparently,
ESPN had correct word that there would be no criminal charges and
chose to show restraint. That�s all fine and good but it doesn�t
explain their absence of restraint as soon as other scandals gurgle
for oxygen in the sports world. It also points brazenly to the double
standards in sports when white and black athletes are under investigation.
White athletes are viewed, judged, dissected as individuals. Black athletes are individually vivisected but then
also portrayed as representative of an entire community. Therefore,
black athletes who had never seen a dog fight in their lives were
asked about Michael Vick as if they all had pit bull tournaments
happening in their backyards. No one will be asking Drew Brees if
he ever tries to have bodyguard protected sex with 20-year olds.
No one will press Peyton Manning on whether a culture of pick up
trucks, Kenny Chesney music, and white baseball caps may have led
Big Ben down this regrettable road. Such pop-sociological stupidity
is a burden white athletes never have to face. In Roethlisberger�s
case, criminal prosecution will be another.
BlackCommentator.com
Guest Commentator Dave Zirin is the author of the forthcoming �Bad
Sports: How Owners Are Ruining the Games We Love�
(Scribner. His website is edgeofsports.com
where you can subscribe to regular feeds of his column. Click
here
to contact Mr. Zirin. |