Note:
We are pleased to welcome brother Nathaniel
Turner as a member of the BlackCommentator.com
Editorial Board. His column �The Gambit� will appear on a regular basis.
Gambit: 1.
An
opening in chess in which a minor piece, or pieces, usually a pawn,
is offered in exchange for a favorable position 2. a remark intended to open a conversation.
I�ve
come to realize that I�m just a pawn on the chess board of life.
Not complaining or anything, and I don�t want you to feel sorry
for me. Pawns are not powerless. True, we can only move forward,
never backward, just one space at a time, and we don�t have the
same mobility as the big fancy pieces. Still, the pawn has its strengths.
We can impede the flow of an adversary. Carry out guerrilla attacks
with other pawns. Best of all, if we stay on the board long enough,
we can develop into a coveted Queen and change the whole game!
So
you see, low self-esteem isn�t my problem. My problem is: I�m trying
to figure out what my next move should be. I�m looking for a way
to get more engaged in The Movement, even while holding down a full-time
job, a wife, and three children. Here am I. Send me. There must
be something more I can do.
And
let�s be honest, it�s not like you don�t need me. You need as many
as pawns as you can get. Because the numbers just ain�t there. You
don�t have enough chess pieces to effect any real social change.
Now,
maybe you�re wondering: what�s with all the allusions to an idle
game of chess when so much is on the line? Universal health care.
Economic justice. War and Peace. Corporate media dominance. Environmental
degradation. Xenophobia and on and on.
Well
my answer to that is simple: �The game of Chess,� as Ben Franklin
wrote, �is not merely an idle amusement. Several very valuable qualities
of the mind, useful in the course of human life, are to be acquired
or strengthened by it, so as to become habits, ready on all occasions.�
This
ancient Persian war game, Franklin argued, was a tool that could
inculcate four indispensable habits of mind:
Foresight
,
which �considers the consequences that may attend an action.� I
call it vision or grand strategy. On the left, you can find deep
insights but very little foresight. In fact, The Movement right
now has about as much vision as Stevie Wonder. Actually, Stevie
is one up on the left because he�s figured out a way to sing to
the masses and not just perform for the choir. It�s not that there�s
a lack of clear values or goals being expressed. It�s precisely
that virtually no strategy is apparent, one that delineates a path
from here to there.
Circumspection
,
�which surveys the whole chess board or scene of action.� To be
circumspect literally means to look around. It also means to carefully
consider all circumstances and possible consequences, or at least
as many as you can manage. In my travels on the margins of the U.S.
left community, it�s hard not to be struck by how insulated groups
tend to be, often completely unaware of the initiatives of other
groups. It�s like every group organizing around an issue thinks
their issue is The Issue.
Moreover,
in terms of becoming more attractive to the disillusioned and disengaged,
progressives don�t talk like ordinary people. They often don�t look
like ordinary people, which violates a fundamental tenet of even
the most radical of radicals. Che Guevera�s writings on guerrilla
warfare noted the importance of blending in with the common people.
Caution
,
which is to �not make moves too hastily.� On this score, progressives
can be forgiven for being hastily reactive at times, given the urgency
of alleviating the suffering of people and the planet. But, when
the left does make a move, it is incautious to project a sense of
self-righteousness towards mainstream working people. Far too many
passionate agitators on the left give off a palpable vibe that
they despise ordinary folk - their religion, their entertainment,
their food and their unwillingness to fight in the absence of viable
and desirable alternative institutions, or at least a clear vision
of what that would look like. I once had an exchange with a leftist
blogger and asked him: If there was a magic button that could wipe
out corporate America and the government overnight, would you push
it? Without the slightest hesitation or caveat, he said: Yes! As
if it didn�t matter that millions of ordinary folk�s livelihoods
and sense of purpose would immediately evaporate without any means
or resources to survive. To say nothing of the historical fact that
revolution doesn�t happen overnight. Social change, even if it culminates
in a radical break from the past, takes generations to unfold.
And,
finally, the most important lesson chess offers is learning �the
habit of not being discouraged by present bad appearances in the
state of our affairs; the habit of hoping for a favorable change,
and that of persevering in the search of resources.�
That�s
where I fall short - in the hope and perseverance department. But
being the stubborn, faithful pawn that I am, I�m not content sitting
on the back row or the edge of the board. I must move forward.
So,
like I was saying: my problem is in figuring out what my next move
should be. I�m looking for a way to get more engaged in The Movement,
while holding down a full-time job, a wife, and three children.
And I�m here to tell ya: my problem is your problem.
Here�s
the problem (mine and yours), more specifically: despite the valiant
efforts and determined commitment of many activists, as Michael
Alpert has pointed out, �dissent has come to mean traveling long
distances, staying in difficult circumstances, taking to the streets
in militant actions that highlight civil disobedience and street
fighting, and even risking arrest and severe mistreatment. If we
just pause a minute and think about it, it is obvious that this
is a lot to ask of people at any time, much less as their first
entry into activism.�
If
you�re a college student, or single, or a tenured professor, or
independently wealthy, maybe this isn�t your personal problem. But,
if you think about hose with serious family obligations, I ask with
Alpert: �How many such folks are likely to join a demonstration
that seems to demand as a prerequisite great mobility and to involve
high risks as their initial step in becoming active?�
Another
thing to consider on the outreach front is the obsession progressives
seem to have with the Internet. The Internet is an amazing networking
tool and can play an important role in raising awareness. But, the
truth is: the only people reading progressive websites are other
progressives.
Addressing
these challenges are paramount because if our numbers don�t grow,
The Movement will have reached what Alpert calls �plateau-ed dissent,�
which poses no threat to elites. The threat comes only when elites
know that The Movement has the capacity to replenish and keep growing.
So
what does a married pawn who happens to be the father of two teenage
daughters and a five-year-old son do?
If
there�s one thing The Movement needs it�s more strategic thinkers.
In fact, it�s not clear to me how well progressives understand the
difference between strategy and tactics. For example, Saul Alinky�s
book Rules for Radicals has an entire chapter on tactics but nothing on strategy.
Randy Shaw�s insightful primer, The
Activist�s Handbook, has a chapter titled �Don�t Respond, Strategize� but then
goes on to discuss �tactical activism� and strategy as if they were
one and the same. Writing letters, protest marches, vigils, sit-ins,
teach-ins, fasts - those are all tactics, the effectiveness of which
are unclear.
But
because I�m not a believer in re-inventing the wheel, I�ll continue
to employ the usual tactics - when time and space allow. Meanwhile,
I�m going to teach my kids how to play chess so they can learn how
to think strategically and get in the practice of developing a long-term
vision. Maybe I�ll even start a local chess club that can serve
as way to draw more pawns to The Movement, engaging the uninitiated
face-to-face.
Chess
anyone?
BlackCommentator.com Editorial Board member Nathaniel
Turner is a pseudonym for a Gen X writer, newspaper editor and activist.
He is a news analyst who offers commentaries on contemporary issues
facing the progressive movements in the USA Click here to
contact brother Turner. |