If
you rely � as we usually must � on the major mass media to get
a picture of what�s going on in the world you probably think the
economic crisis in Greece came about because the irresponsible
Greeks are insisting on retiring at 50, are unwilling to give
up the �bonuses� to which they have become accustomed, and are
insisting that their European neighbors foot the bill. However,
most of what we read or hear is either distorted out of proportion
or simply isn�t true. The
economic crisis in the European Union wasn�t caused by Greek working
people and the threats they face these days are far greater than
are being portrayed.
The
Greek worker living high on the hog, getting paid for doing little
and retiring into the lap of luxury is as real as the proverbial
�welfare queen� driving her Cadillac downtown to pick up her check.
Yeah, there are moochers and con artists in every society but
that�s not the real issue here. The working people of Greece confront the same problems
most of the rest of us do. The world of capitalism has become
dysfunctional and those still profiting from it have come up with
a way to deal with it, by putting the cost right on our shoulders.
And, as with the unemployed single mother, the scapegoating is
tinged with racial/ethnic stereotyping. The same goes for the
Italians, Spanish and Portuguese � the southerners lining up for
dole from the frugal, hardworking people in the North.
The
working people of Greece
did not create the mess their economy is in any more than their
counterparts in the rest of Europe are responsible for the now continent-wide economic crisis.
�Want
to know exactly why public anger in Greece
is running at such explosive levels?� asked Tony Bonsignore last
week in the British financial investment advice service Citywire
. �Then take a look at the austerity measures currently being
debated by the Greek parliament.
�The
BBC reports that as part of the IMF/ EU bailout Greek leaders
are proposing the following measures:
�On
their own any one of these measures would probably be enough to
prompt significant political disquiet; taken together they represent
a catastrophic setback to the financial aspirations of the average
Greek,� wrote Bonsignore, formerly a reporter and editor for Financial
Times. �It certainly wasn�t what the Greek population voted
for when they entered the EU in 1981 and adopted the single currency
two decades later.�
Writing
from Athens, John Lichfield of The Independent (UK)
observed, �Whether pain can ever be spread evenly in a system
so endemically corrupt and perverse as the Levantine political
and economic system of Greece is open to question. How can anyone trust
a system in which large sections of the wealthiest members of
society � from ship owners to lawyers and doctors � have traditionally,
and quite legally, evaded almost all direct taxes?
�The
problem is that correcting the injustices in the tax system will
take years to harvest its fruit. The deeper, immediate, further
austerity measures VAT [value added tax] increases and pension
and public spending cuts � imposed on Athens last weekend will
produce an immediate cut in the state deficit. But they will fall
mostly on modestly-off Greeks, in the private and state sectors,
who do pay into the system and feel they have already made several
blood sacrifices already.�
The
significant difference between Greece,
Spain, Italy
and Ireland
is that they are economically less affluent countries than others
to the north. Therefore there are major imbalances in trade on
the continent. One result is that they are relatively uncompetitive
compared with the others, especially export powerhouse Germany.
The other result is that the countries sometime referred to as
�the periphery of the continent� were doubly undermined by the
current economic crisis that � you will recall � originated in
the United States.
Poverty
was increasing in Greece
before the present crisis hit. The Greek unemployment rate was
9.5 percent last year; it rose to 11.3 per cent in January. As
a consequence of steps now being undertaken, it will rise further.
The Financial Times says the EU - IMF-imposed measures
will deliver �a brutal amount of pain� to the country. As economist
Paul Krugman has said, the �severe austerity� now demanded of
Greece �will have a strong depressing effect on
an already depressed economy.�
In
some ways the economic situation in Britain
is of greater consequence than that in Greece. The other day someone described that country
as a heart patient in urgent need of a transplant. They just had
an election in the UK
and, on its eve, Andrew Wander wrote in Aljazeera, �Analysts
say that this election will mark the dawn of an era of austerity
unlike anything seen in the country for a generation, with higher
taxes and drastic cuts in public spending needed to fund efforts
to balance the nation�s books.� He went on, �If Britain is not
seen to be dealing with its mountain of debt, the country could
lose its triple-A credit rating and with it the trust of the financial
markets whose investment in government bonds keeps treasury coffers
full.
�If
that happens, the results could be even more harmful than a recession
sparked by spending cuts; demand for UK
bonds could collapse and the UK
could end up facing a Greek-style cash flow crisis.�
Wander
reported that Mark Littlewood, the director of the Institute of Economic Affairs, �believes that British public sector strikes are
�quite likely� as the cuts kick in, and he is not alone in predicting
political problems for the next government.� Furthermore, �Mervyn
King, the governor of the Bank of England, is said to believe
that whoever wins this election will be out of power for a generation
because of how tough the austerity measures will need to be.�
�Innocent
Greeks are facing years of austerity,� Ruth Sunderland, business
editor of the Observer (UK)
wrote this last Sunday. �People will have their pay slashed, lose
their jobs and be forced to wait for years longer to draw the
pensions they were promised. Dreams and aspirations will be ground
into the dust.
�In
London and New York,
the plight of Greek families fails to stir the faintest compassion
in the cold-eyed speculators who have been feasting on their distress
before moving on to their next prey in Spain, Portugal
or Italy.
And despite the revision of views on Black Wednesday, there is
no guarantee that this bout of speculation will turn out to be
for Greece�s benefit in the end.
�In
the UK, we have good
reason to be afraid of the jackals stalking global markets. Our
situation is a long way from being as dire as that of Greece, but the election result
has left the markets nervous about more political turmoil and
whether there will be credible plans to reduce our deficit. If
and when the speculators turn their attentions our way, we can
be sure they will act mercilessly, with no regard for the human
misery of lost jobs, home repossessions or emptied-out pension
plans.�
Quiet
as it�s kept, there is a much bigger picture here and it contains
some sinister implications. Poul Nyrup Rasmussen, president of
the party of European Socialists (PES), which coordinates Europe�s
socialist, social democrat, progressive and labor parties, says
the EU�s conservative majority is, in fact, punishing Greece, subjecting it to �the nation-state equivalent
of waterboarding� and is out to �dismantle core social standards.�
Writing in the Britain�s
Guardian May 7, Rasmussen said the continent�s conservatives
are �trying to use these kinds of austerity measures to force
through social cutbacks across Europe.�
�This
is but a cynical attempt to roll back fundamental social standards.
It does not even make financial sense as it would force thousands
into the grey economy � one of the structural causes of the crisis
in the first place � or even worse, would force them into abject
poverty,� Rasmussen wrote.
In
most of the rest of the world the prescribed method for dealing
with the system�s crisis is referred to it by its proper name:
austerity. The media in our country seems to have an aversion
to using the term. But that�s what it is when, in order to deal
with the economic malfunctioning, you cut education budgets and
fire teachers, enact special taxes that hit working people hardest,
reduce services for the indigent and threaten to reduce or eliminate
retirement and medical programs for seniors. It comes down to
who, in a pinch, is going to be required to lower their living
standards, and which individuals and families are expected to
lead more austere lives. There is a political crisis in most of
the industrialized capitalist world because thing are getting
tough for the lower end of the economic ladder while vast fortunes
are being amassed at the top.
There
is nothing even remotely equal about the sacrifices people are
being asked to make at the present moment. The financial arrangements
being worked out for Greece don�t involve
aid for Greek workers and the middle classes being squeezed by
the economic crisis; its purpose is to rescue the banks � the
local ones and the other European banks that hold Greek debt.
This will seem familiar to anyone who has looked on as troubled
financial institutions on Wall Street have been bailed out and
are again raking in profits while the unemployment rate rises
and more and more people are evicted from their homes.
�In
truth, the very foundations of the global neo-liberal system,
which emerged from the Reagan-Thatcher inspired capitalist economic
blitzkrieg of the last 25 years, is now discredited,� wrote John
Palmer in the Guardian May 7. �The EU as a whole also needs
a new economic philosophy based on green and sustainable growth
and which encourages social cohesion and not short-term economic
growth, reduces excessive dependence on the financial and carbon
energy sectors, and which actively promotes greater social equality.
The time to strike out in a new direction is now � before it is
too late. Where Europe leads, the world may well now want to follow.�
Try
telling that to Thomas Friedman. The New York Times columnist
- of late earth fame who will never have to worry about where
his next meal is coming from or whether he will have a roof over
his head - is quick to endorse the idea that the task in our country
is, as he put it Sunday, to �cut public sector pay, freeze benefits,
slash jobs, abolish a range of welfare entitlements and take the
ax to programs such as school building and road maintenance.�
And
all the while, we can be sure new billionaires will arise, poverty
increase and economic inequality grow. Now that�s something to
look forward to.
BlackCommentator.com Editorial Board member
Carl Bloice is a writer in San
Francisco, a member of the National Coordinating Committee of
the Committees of Correspondence for Democracy and Socialism
and formerly worked for a healthcare union. Click here
to contact Mr. Bloice.