Note:
BlackCommentator.com welcomes Syreeta McFadden as a columnist and
member of the Editorial Board.
At
last year�s Tax Day Rally in New Dorp, Staten Island, I did in fact,
meet ONE black Tea Party supporter and took his picture (above).
I�m not sure if he�s still kickin� it with them today. He was a
curious oddity to me. I don�t remember his name, but I do remember
that he was a Cuban immigrant, naturalized
American. And after a year of vitriol and obfuscation,
I wonder if he is still aligned with this movement. A movement that
at its heart invalidates his right to claim America as his home.
UPDATE:
So I got this comment on my rather benign commentary:
This
man integrated, joined America � as proven by his being a Tea
Partier � and no other Tea Party supporter would gainsay his status
as a right and proper American.
Get
over your racism and your hatred of all things White and all things
truly American and maybe, just maybe, you�ll earn the same privilege.
I
won�t hold my breath though.
I
can accept a critique, but if this commenter were a regular reader
of mine, he�d recognize that my supposed hatred of �all things White�
is unfounded. I mean, seriously, who blogs about Procul Harum, Foo
Fighters, and Bartleby, the Scrivener??? I don�t even need to unpack
all the things wrong with that premise. Perhaps I do? I don�t know.
Yet,
I had missed the findings of a recent poll from Quinnipiac University that breaks down
the demographics of the Tea Party Movement:
� 74 percent are Republicans or independent voters leaning
Republican;
� 16 percent are Democrats or independent voters leaning Democratic;
� 5 percent are solidly independent;
� 45 percent are men;
� 55 percent are women;
� 88 percent are white;
� 77 percent voted for Sen. John McCain in 2008
I
don�t doubt that there are people of color who are part of the conservative
movement, or the tea party movement. They�re entitled to their opinion
and have the right to associate with an organization that compliments
those beliefs. More power to them, even if it confuses me. However,
I do have to question a movement that argues that my right to claim
my American-ness is contingent upon my embracing white culture exclusively.
I do have a right to question the intentions of a movement that
failed to condone those who yelled racial and homophobic epithets
at elected officials. We can disagree on the policy, even the politics,
but again, from this commenter and the protesters, that�s not really
the conversation or debate they want to have with someone like me.
On
Meet the Press, Doris Kearns Goodwin said something that struck
me. �The tone of recent time is troubling� But in the last 30 years
or so to hear the racial epithets, the homophobia, when we thought
were becoming a more tolerant society shows we have far way to go�
People worrying the country is becoming un-homogeneous. There�s
a lot of minorities out there. And that whites are fearful something
going on.� She was referring also to Frank Rich�s column on March 27, 2010.
It
also reminded me of something Ta-Nehisi Coates wrote awhile back during his close reading of Civil
War history the following:
It
makes sense when you think on the deep promise of white supremacy.
Black equality is the promise of mortality for everyone. I ask
it again, what are you in a world where a black man is president?
Who knows what depths a man might go to cling to those last vestiges
of Godhood? He would claim Obama�s Muslim. He would claim he isn�t
a citizen. He would claim that Obama was not �really black� or
not black in the �usual way. Anything to differentiate themselves
from the teeming masses, anything to get away from he undying
fact that in the hearts of all men, there is a Harlem.
White
racism and fear have historically been used as wedge issues against
social and economic reformation. This is not a new tactic. It�s
old, trite even, like the cartoon circulating on the internet this
weekend suggesting Obama raped the Statue of Liberty by signing
health reform into law. A black man defiling Liberty; that pure,
and iconic image of white culture. Smarter bloggers than me have
written their analysis of that, so I don�t feel a need to rehash.
Still, I can�t clearly articulate the policy objection from these
people. There�s no entry point to find a middle ground. It�s all
or nothing. I�m holding my ground.
BlackCommentator.com
Editorial Board Member Syreeta McFadden
is a freelance writer and photographer living in Brooklyn, NY.
She is a graduate of Columbia University and Sarah Lawrence College. Her
blog is bellewetherstate.com. You
may find her photographs at syreetamcfadden.com. You
can also visit her on twitter and facebook. Click here to contact Ms.
McFadden. |