It�s as if we didn�t have the power and the technology to stop most
tragedies in the mines of America, but it�s obvious that we lack
the will to do so.
Monday�s mine disaster in southern
West Virginia killed 25 miners and left four
missing at a Massey coal mine in Montcoal,
W.Va. It was reported that the mine had a �spotty�
safety record. They likely were being generous.
Coal mining never was a safe
occupation. Just the idea of having so many workers so far down
in the belly of the earth where they could not be reached in case
of an emergency was enough to send many to find some other line
of work.
All anyone could do during the
rescue operation was mourn for the dead and pray for those missing
and give as much support to their families as possible. Those things
were being done this week and everyone not actively engaged in the
rescue just held hands, gathered at churches and public buildings
and private homes�and waited.
Despite the numbers of underground
coal mines in the eastern U.S.
and the numbers of miners, coal miners are a rather small fraternity
and they tend to stick together in their communities and, especially
in their own mines. They have a sense of solidarity that doesn�t
exist in too many other types of work.
In some ways, they don�t want
people commenting on a disaster such as that in the Upper Big Branch
mine Monday afternoon. That is, they don�t want comments from people
who are not miners themselves. They don�t believe that anyone else
can appreciate the dangers that underground miners confront every
day. They don�t think that anyone else can know the concern of the
family members who wait at the surface for the duration of every
shift - every day, throughout the year.
But there are many miners who
know that, to make the mines safer, there had to be someone demanding
that the government that regulates working conditions do something
about the mine disasters that occurred regularly for a century.
Unions
formed among miners and were some of the toughest and most unified
workers in the nation. Over time, despite the incredible power of
the coal and �energy� companies and their fight against sensible
regulations, the miners prevailed and, by degrees, mining became
somewhat safer.
Miners in the U.S. still suffer from black lung, an insidious
disease that takes its toll as a kind of wasting of the human body
and spirit. It�s not that those who suffer from it can�t work or
engage in physical exertion at the beginning, but it is a progressive
disease that gets worse, as long as the cause is still present.
As miners have said, over time,
�I�ve got the dust.�
They�re speaking of coal dust
and there have been some advances made in combating the conditions
that cause black lung in the U.S. However, there
are some places where it has been eliminated, or virtually so.
In Australia,
the pressure from the miners for the government regulators to do
something about black lung resulted in development of technology
that just about eliminated the disease years ago. But it cost money.
Here in America,
the coal companies did not want to put out that kind of money to
eliminate coal dust, because it came out of the profits to shareholders.
But because death by black lung is such a terrible way to go, there
was long, union-led, fight for legislation and regulation over the
past two generations, at both the state and federal level, to lessen
the load of dust in the mines and help miners who were suffering
the effects of black lung. The
idea was to provide some assistance, including treatment and regular
health check-ups.
There are ways to curb the disasters
in the mines from other causes too, such as the build-up of methane
or any other gas deep in the mines that, when they are touched off
by a spark or other cause, can result in a disaster like Monday�s.
These efforts also are hard-fought and it takes a long time to achieve
results.
The United Mine Workers of America
(UMWA) has fought for mine safety improvements for years, just as
hard as it has fought for better pay, health benefits, and pensions.
Although the union has not eliminated all of the dangers, it has
made progress. Whatever they have been able to achieve, it has been
in the face of fierce opposition by mine owners, politicians and
judges who have benefited from their relationships with corporate
mine owners, and even fellow miners and neighbors.
Comments on one website after
the explosion Monday indicated that anyone who pointed out that
mine safety needs to be improved and that this will be a tough struggle,
was engaged in �political� talk. Considering what happened to so
many families this week, there needs to be an increase in such �political
talk.�
Speaking from the headquarters
of the UMWA in Triangle, W.Va., Cecil E. Roberts, international union president,
issued the following statement, shortly after the explosion on Monday:
�The hearts and prayers of
all UMWA members are with the families of those lost today at
Performance Coal Company�s Upper Big Branch mine. We are also
praying for the safe rescue of those still missing, and for the
safety of the courageous mine rescue team members. They are putting
their lives on the line, entering a highly dangerous mine to bring
any survivors to safety.�
�As a mine operated by a subsidiary
of Massey Energy, the Upper Big Branch mine is a nonunion mine.
Nevertheless, I have dispatched highly trained and skilled UMWA
personnel to the immediate vicinity of the mine, and they stand
ready to offer any assistance they can to the families and the
rescuers at this terrible and anxious time. We are all brothers
and sisters in the coalfields at times like this.�
It would be unfortunate if Massey
Energy and the community of Montcoal were to reject the offer of
assistance from the UMWA, although corporations of great power have
exerted unrelenting pressure on communities of workers to ensure
that there is a divide between those communities.
Corporate
America
in the coalfields is no different from Corporate America in any
other workplace. Their public relations and propaganda is meant
to maintain disunity among workers, so they never realize the power
that comes from solidarity.
It�s that solidarity that gives
workers, their families, and their communities the strength to fight
for changes that will make their jobs safer and make their lives
a little better. No family should be apprehensive about a loved
one simply going to work, yet miners� families, even though they
have become accustomed to the feeling, can�t escape that apprehension
completely. Not on a single day.
It was said this week that �only�
34 were killed in mine accidents last year in the U.S. Contrasted
with the thousands who were killed (sometimes hundreds in a single
incident) in 20th Century mine disasters, that may not seem like
many, but that�s not good enough.
For
now, in Montcoal, W.Va., all people can do is what has been encouraged:
pray or send words of encouragement and condolence, then join the
union and fight like hell to see that it never happens again.
BlackCommentator.com
Columnist, John Funiciello, is a labor organizer and former union
organizer. His union work started when he became a local president
of The Newspaper Guild in the early 1970s. He was a reporter for
14 years for newspapers in New York State. In addition to labor work, he is
organizing family farmers as they struggle to stay on the land under
enormous pressure from factory food producers and land developers.
Click here
to contact Mr. Funiciello.
|