Note:
This is an address made to a gathering of more than 500 leaders
from American Federation of Government Employees local unions and
councils where policy issues are discussed.� Bill Fletcher, Jr.
is the Director of Field Services & Education for AFGE.� The
speech was delivered on Sunday, February 21st.
Good afternoon and thank you.� I am very honored to have
been asked to address this conference.
I want to begin by giving a very special thanks to the Creator
of all things on this, the 21st birthday of my little girl.�� So,
I hope to do her proud.
I am going to be brutally honest with you, so I ask your
forgiveness in advance if my remarks unsettle you.
The union movement is in a rut.� Too many of the leaders
of organized labor seem to have forgotten certain historical truths.�
Let me remind you of one such truth.
In 1857 a great leader in the struggle for justice offered
the following observations:
�Let me give you a word of the
philosophy of reform. The whole history of the progress of human
liberty shows that all concessions yet made to her august claims,
have been born of earnest struggle. The conflict has been exciting,
agitating, all-absorbing, and for the time being, putting all
other tumults to silence. It must do this or it does nothing.
If there is no struggle there is no progress. Those who profess
to favor freedom and yet depreciate agitation, are men who want
crops without plowing up the ground, they want rain without thunder
and lightning. They want the ocean without the awful roar of its
many waters."
He went on to say:
"This struggle may be
a moral one, or it may be a physical one, and it may be both moral
and physical, but it must be a struggle. Power concedes nothing
without a demand. It never did and it never will.� [from Frederick
Douglass]
We, in organized labor, seem to get confused as to the difference
between �requests� and �demands�.� We sometimes think that they
are the same.� THEY ARE NOT.
Let me give you an example of requests:� �Pass the jelly, please.��
OR, �May we meet with you, Mr. President.�
How about demands?� Let me pick one out of the air:� �MR. PRESIDENT:�
WE WANT TSOs TO HAVE COLLECTIVE BARGAINING RIGHTS NOW!� Not tomorrow�not
next week!�
A demand is straight forward.� It does not equivocate.� It may or
may not be your end point, but it is something in which you strongly
believe and it is your starting position.� The demand guides your
action.� One follows through on demands.
Let us be clear that we in the union movement made a big mistake
in how we understood the November 2008 elections.�� Yes, we were
sick of Bush.� Yes, we realized how dangerous the McCain/Palin ticket
was.� After all, had McCain/Palin won, they had not even the semblance
of an economic program and as many commentators have noted, we probably
would be in a barter economy at this point, not to mention, probably
involved in a military conflict with Iran.
But we made a particular mistake.� We engaged in magical thinking
and wishful thinking.�� Yes, Obama was the right person to elect,
but he was not a miracle maker.� He is an outstanding thinker and
speaker.� He was and is also someone who is very tied into
corporate America and he is someone who seems to have an irresistible
impulse to approach matters of controversy by jumping to the middle
position and believing that a consensus can be built.� Rather than
staking out a position that he believes in and fighting for it,
he moves quickly to a center piece assuming that we are all big
boys and girls and can agree midpoint.
Yet in today�s political situation, there is no real bi-partisanship,
and not because Obama has not tried.� The Republicans have made
it clear that they want to cut his legs off.� Not just cut his legs
off, but hang and guillotine him at the same time!!� Think about
the irrationalist attacks on him carried out by the so-called Birther
Movement, a movement claiming that President Obama is not actually
a citizen of the USA.�� 58% of the Republican Party actually believes
that he was either not born in the USA or that there is enough evidence
to raise doubts, this despite the fact that he has provided proof
again and again, and despite the obvious fact that every intelligence
agency in every country around the world would have been investigating
his background from the minute that he became a candidate for the
Presidency of the USA.� Consider that some people are using this
irrationalism as their organizing approach toward members of the
military to incite a coup d��tat against Obama.� Think about the
allegations that Obama is a socialist despite the fact that he surrounds
himself with economic advisers from Wall Street!� Added to this,
Republicans are being clear that there is NOTHING that Obama says,
including and not limited to THEIR own proposals, to which they
will agree.
Yet, Obama seems to feel more compelled to respond to that, than
to pay attention to the likes of us.� And his reluctance to lead
the charge on behalf of working people is as much driven by his
ties to corporate America as it is to something that will be very
uncomfortable for many of you to hear:� his fear of being
perceived by white Americans as an angry Black man.
Workers have been under attack since the early 1970s, and organized
labor in many countries�not just the USA�has been unable to alter
its approach as to how to respond.� Yet there are examples that
are noteworthy of people fighting back.
The little island of Guadeloupe has an unemployment rate of 23%.�
We complain�justifiably�about a 10% unemployment rate, but Guadeloupe
has a rate that is depression level.�� In addition they have a high
cost of living.� Yet, in this situation in early 2009, the workers
of this island, in response to continued attacks carried out a 44
day general strike against further cuts and against this economic
atrocity.�
THEY WON!!� Not only did they win, but they won and inspired workers
in France to resist.
In Greece, workers fought back against attacks.� They stood up and
resisted.
Here at home, our response to the economic crisis has been nothing
short of anemic�at best.� When the financial collapse took place
in the fall of 2008, organized labor did almost nothing.���
With the rise of this Administration organized labor was excited
about the possibility of passing the Employee Free Choice Act as
a way of increasing the right of workers to join or organize unions.�
Yet, instead of taking this issue to the public, organized labor
basically kept this within the Beltway and made little effort to
connect this to the issues that working people�whether union or
not�face every day; in other words, as crazy as it may sound, they
did not connect EFCA to economic justice.� Other movements have
also been very passive.� They AND WE have waited for the person
who far too many people have come to believe to be the greatest
magician on the planet�President Obama�to resolve everything.�
And, while we sit back and wait for the magic to unfold, the political
Right has been carrying out a full-scale assault, twisting recent
history to serve their objectives, conveniently forgetting how the
budget deficit came to be; and how we came to be in two wars.
Change does not come from one person.� But it also does not come
from patiently requesting change.� We have to realize that elected
leaders are bombarded by various forces, and particularly forces
that have far more money and other resources than do we.� This,
then, goes beyond the matter of good intentions, good speeches,
and good looks.� It goes to matters of power�who has it�who wants
it�and how it is used.
So, in the face of the fact that the Obama administration has not
delivered many of the changes that we have requested, there has
been both anger and despair, but what there has been so little of�particularly
from unions and pro-worker/pro-community organizations�has been
a mobilization to insist upon our demands.
There is a story that has been told since the election of President
Obama that sheds light on what we are doing and what we are not
doing.� Actually the story goes back to the administration of President
Franklin Roosevelt, around 1939/1940.� The story is that the great
trade union and African American movement leader A. Philip Randolph
met with FDR.�� Randolph met with him to lay out various reforms
that he wanted and felt that FDR should push through.� FDR listened
patiently and when Randolph was finished, he said to him:� �I agree
with you.� Now, go out there and ORGANIZE and make me do it.�
MAKE
�EM DO IT!!� That should be our slogan and that is precisely the direction that
we should be moving.� In fact, the story does not end there because
Randolph took FDR to task.� In early 1941 Randolph and many other
African American leaders�and their allies�were deeply concerned
that the growing war industry remained almost totally racially segregated.�
Randolph went to FDR and asked for an executive order to ban this
segregation.� FDR, deeply worried about conservatives within the
Democratic Party, balked.� He asked Randolph to be patient.� Randolph
came back at him and told him that he would organize a march of
10,000 people on Washington if something was not done.
Think about that.� This was 1941.� There were not a lot of marches
on DC.� And here was this labor leader threatening such a march�ON
HIS FRIEND.� Not only that, but it was 1941.� The Nazis were moving
into the former Yugoslavia and preparing to invade the USSR.� What
could have been a worst time to protest, to embarrass a standing
President, many people asked.
FDR asked his wife Eleanor to approach Randolph and appeal to him
to call off the demo.� Randolph listened patiently.� His response:�
Thank you.� We are now going to march 100,000 people on Washington.
FDR ultimately blinked and when he blinked he issued the famous executive
order that desegregated the war industry and laid the basis for
events that would unfold over the next thirty years.
This is not personal.� This is about power.� And it is about taking
on those whose legs wobble in the face of the goliath of corporate
America.� This is about saying to our so-called friends that we
are not interested in being taken for granted.� We are not interested
in being the shock troops for change, only to sit back and see our
hopes evaporate.
No, this does not put us on the same side as the likes of a Palin
or others who would take us back to the mythical 1950s�at best.�
But it means that we are not prepared to rest easy and to rest quietly.�
We will be heard.
You
know, there are those who say that the response of workers to inconsistencies
and unfulfilled promises from the Obama administration and from
the Congress will be that workers will stay at home in November.�
While that may be true, that is not a strategy.� It is also one
that makes no strategic sense.�� There is a lot at stake in November.
I fear the growth of movements that are based on irrationality,
and so should you.� I fear the election of those who would worsen
our economic and political situation and take our civil liberties
away.� No, sitting at home is no strategy.
But herein lies one more lesson from the administration of FDR.��
FDR�s first year was not so great.� He was not particularly visionary
and he basically did not shake the table.� But he ran into problems
that he did not expect.� Many of the great corporate leaders and
their political allies attacked FDR for even his minimal efforts
to address the Depression through some increased benefits.� In fact,
they attacked him as being a traitor to his class (because he was
from the wealthy) and there were right-wing papers and radio commentators
who regularly called him a Bolshevik, socialist, and everything
else but being a child of God, going so far as to conduct discussions
regarding a coup against FDR.
FDR was caught.� What could he do?� Well, by the second year of his
Administration workers were rebelling around the country.� The unemployed
were organizing and unionized workers carried out three major general
strikes plus a national textile strike.� You see, the workers did
not wait for FDR.� They helped to transform FDR.� They realized
that the change that they wanted�the change that they
believed in�would only happen through THEIR own actions.� They looked
to FDR to assist them, and they especially looked to FDR to not
oppose them�but they did NOT look to FDR to do it for them.
They made him do the right thing.
We must make our so-called friends do the right thing.� We must make
�em do it.� If we want genuine healthcare reform, make �em do it.�
If we want a jobs program, make �em do it.� And if we want collective
bargaining for TSOs, we must make �em do it.
We cannot let the obstructionism of the Republicans, or the complacency
of the Democrats, get in our way. We must let no one, and I mean
NO ONE, turn us around.
The lessons from history are there and they are clear.� It is now
up to us to seize the time and realize the hope that was expressed
in the 2008 elections.� Despair has no place in our present or our
future.� It never has�and never will
What should be our clarion call, AFGE?� MAKE �EM DO IT!!!!
Thank you.
BlackCommentator.com
Executive Editor, Bill Fletcher, Jr., is a Senior Scholar with the
Institute for Policy Studies,
the immediate past president of
TransAfrica Forum
and co-author of, Solidarity Divided: The Crisis in Organized Labor and a New Path
toward Social Justice (University
of California Press), which examines the crisis of organized labor
in the USA. Click here
to contact Mr. Fletcher. |