This article earlier appeared
in Counterpunch.
If the president wasn't so forthright about
his disinterest in the world, it would have been hard to believe
him last Wednesday
when he said the abuse in Abu Ghraib prison "doesn't represent
the America I know." But who can doubt him? To represent
the America George W. Bush knows, there would have to be explosive
snapshots of Iraqi detainees lounging by the Abu Ghraib pool,
barbequing ribs and snorting primo Bolivian coke off empty
cases of Coors Light. There would have to be shocking reports
of prisoners with family members on the Iraqi Governing Council
being handed sweetheart deals on professional sports franchises
and energy firms.
But being stripped, hooded and urinated on while your friend
is forced to masturbate next to you? The only member of the
Bush clan who knows about that kind of thing is Jenna.
Of course, if the President were more of
a newspaper-reading sort of feller, he wouldn't have been
so shocked by the pictures.
As a tough-on-crime Texan, he would have recognized such treatment
immediately, perhaps even feeling a little swell of pride.
If he'd ever put down the Bible for a broadsheet after his
conversion, he'd know that "Texas prison" is one
of the most feared phrases in the language – and he'd know
why. When he sat down in front of Arab TV audiences on Wednesday
to explain the true American way, he could have pointed to
an October, 1999 story in the Austin American Statesman that
detailed how female prisoners there were regularly kept in
portable detention cells for hours at a time in summer heat
with no water. "In fear of more time in the cages," the
article explains, "many women submit sexually to their
oppressors and are raped, molested and forced to perform sodomy
on their captors."
And in 1996, if Bush hadn't been so busy
handling the transfer of $9 billion in public funds over
to the University of Texas
Investment Management Company, the governor might have had
time to read about the videotape that surfaced that year depicting
prison guards brutalizing inmates in the Brazoria County Detention
Center in Angleton, TX. The tape, which was originally shot
for use as a training video, showed riot-clad guards beating
prisoners (arrested on drug violations) and forcing them to
crawl while kicking them and poking them with electric prods.
Had Bush cleared a little time to watch this video, he would
had an easier time digesting the images out of Abu Ghraib,
and thus saved himself those few moments of humiliating supplication
in front of all those Arabs, based as they were on the faulty
assumption that those pictures "weren't America."
f only some governor's aide had told him
in 1999 about the hunger strike at the notorious Terrel Unit
facility in Livingston,
TX, where death-row prisoner Michael Sharp said before his
execution, many guards "think it is their patriotic duty
to torture and brutalize prisoners." If only he had not
been so busy reclining in box seats at Rangers home games,
the governor might have known that prisoners' attorney Donna
Brorby had described Texas' super-max prisons as "the
worst in the country," where guards reportedly gas prisoners
and throw them down on concrete floors while handcuffed. Then
the president might have been better equipped to recognize
his country in those pictures.
Considering all the downtime the President has spent in the
Lone Star State since 2000, he might have even heard about
the 2002 conclusion of the 30-year legal battle Ruiz v. Johnson.
In its write up of the case, the Austin
Chronicle reported the words of Texas Judge William Wayne
Justice, written after hearing lengthy expert and inmate testimony
on prison conditions:
Texas prison inmates continue to live in fear.
More vulnerable inmates are raped, beaten, owned, and sold by
more powerful ones. Despite their pleas to prison officials,
they are often refused protection. Instead, they pay for protection,
in money, services, or sex. Correctional officers continue to
rely on the physical control of excessive force to enforce order.
Those inmates locked away in administrative segregation, especially
those with mental illnesses, are subjected to extreme deprivations
and daily psychological harm.
But no, the abuse at Abu Ghraib does not represent any America
that George Bush could possibly have known about. The America
he knows never sets foot inside prisons. It just owns them and
fills them and builds them. Anything that happens after that,
well, it might as well be another country.
Alexander Zaitchik can be reached at [email protected]