Our deliberative intelligence can be integrated with our soaring emotions.That term, “the adult in
the room,” has a complex, sometimes biased meaning. I do not intend to imply
that there is not an obvious difference between adults and children. However, I
want to raise up to your consideration the false,
unvoiced assumption buried in that term: that the adult is always right.
I know that many people are able to quickly reject that buried assumption and
many are able to keep open a bit of their mental-ear to the possibility that
the child in the room might be the one who should be listened to in order to
reach the best result. The child is living with the circumstances of the
moment. Some cultures highlight and call for continuous attention
to the possibility of valuable truths from the mouths of children. In the
Judeo-Christian belief system we have the statement in the Hebrew Scripture (Psalms 8:2) and it’s reiteration in the
Gospels in Matthew
21:16: “And said
unto him, Hearest thou what these say? And Jesus saith unto them, Yea; have ye never read, Out of the mouth
of babes and sucklings thou hast perfected praise?”
In Buddhism there is the lesson of the “mind of a child.” It is considered
wisdom to understand that truth does not always come from the top of the
hierarchy of power and privilege. Wherever you are on any social comparison
scale - in terms of age, sex, gender, “race,” wealth, education, or
heritage - those on the top, those so-called “adults-in-the-room,” are not
always the ones who know best or those who should be followed.
It seems natural to give
more weight to what adults say because we assume their age gives them more
experience with the difficult decisions in life. Adults are also almost always festooned
with the power symbols that we expect those who have “successfully” navigated
difficulties to have and wear; these special clothes, marked up pieces of
identifying paper, habits of language, and other indices of social status
facilitate our quick identification of the right adult and our assumption of
the right subservient attitude (for younger, lesser status persons). Our
cultures “lull” us into certain mental postures while it, at the same time (but
mostly in wisdom stories) signals us to listen for the truth that is in
the words of subservient children. Which direction will
your mental processes flow - being
tugged in two different directions by your cultures?
Know that true democracy is not this game we play in the US.
Hold that question for a moment. Let me now play out the role of the
“adult in the room” as it concerns this election. Let me warn you that the
adult role slips too easily into haughtiness, condescension, disdain, and
assumed superiority. However,
relax. I am not going to lecture anyone on how they should vote. Neither am I
going to tell anyone how I am going to vote. Just know that I am going to vote.
As the adult in this room,
though, I must tell you that voting in the U.S. is a game. In many ways - ways
that you already know, I do not have to tell you - the voting game is bent and
often fixed. Your play (your vote) has been severely marginalized. The
original voting system upon which the current system is constructed was never
intended to give us (peons) a
voice! That the Electoral College is still the body that really
chooses the president is just one of the remaining, almost immovable
bedrocks of the original system. Such antidemocratic factors bend the
voting system so much that the candidates focus most of their resources and
their attention on a very small number of unrepresentative voters. Each of us
is marginalized both as individuals and collectively in how our vote is
As the adult in the room I
must tell you that campaigns are far from opportunities to give us information
so that we can more knowledgeably exercise our democratic right. Rather,
campaigns are opportunities for intense manipulation of our emotional
“buttons,” for the sowing of confusion, and for out-right lying. Campaigns
present an orgy in that otherwise most vile of things - propaganda.
It was the Nazis’ use of propaganda for political purposes that gave propaganda
its bad name. Before the Nazis it was associated with a kind of
religious proselytizing; it rose to recognition as a communications practice in
the tugging for European individuals’ faith commitments in the 1600s during the
Protestant Revolution. After the Nazis, the practice migrated to Madison Avenue
and it became the chief means for ‘pulling the wool over our eyes’ and feeding
corporations. Hitler and his people were very good at propaganda but they could
not hold-a-candle to the propagandist of today! A lot of earth’s
resources, a lot of the product of human muscle, and a lot of the ingenuity of
the human mind is being wasted to play this vile
game on us using precise pre-tested presentation-bombs that mostly
manipulate our emotions to high levels of stress.
The child is living with the circumstances of the moment.
This adult says, “know that this is a game being played on you.”
We may want to play the game. We may even believe that we have to play the game
to honor those who died so that we could when they could not when they were
alive. We have very few options to influence things to any degree. Almost all
of us do play in some way; if you stress about the election in any way, you are
playing the game even if you do not vote yourself. If you are stressed, then
the propagandists are getting to you. The propagandists have succeeded with
you. Know that you are in the midst of a game that is about pushing the lowest
common denominator to get you to do what somebody else wants you to do. It is
the height of corporate commercial manipulation: salesmanship, flimflam. Like
(electoral) cattle we have been run through the maze of mental fences until we
are faced with their well designed (over designed) decision forking point. For
more than 90% of us they have prodded, trained, and manipulated us until they
know exactly which choice we are going to make. And they are getting their last
hot-licks on the less predictable few.
knowing that this is a game means
knowing that we are in this but we do not have to be of this.
Propagandists target the juvenile aspect of us. No matter our age, we have a
juvenile aspect to our thinking. The organic brain connections that assist
adults to make “better” judgments develop in our mid 20s but they do not erase
our juvenile connections. It is those more emotionally responsive pathways that
propagandists target, not the deliberative faculties of our forebrains. And it
is the false trappings and false festooning with the symbols of potency and
power that are the most deceiving.
Many of us did not
sufficiently deliberate last time, not that we would have chosen McCain. We
responded emotionally to the symbolism that was Obama and now we are deeply
disappointed that he is not what we put on him. That is not Obama’s fault. That
is us for getting swept up in the game. We will not be using our marginalized
influence to choose an icon, a superhero, a king, or a mythological champion.
We will have simply a minor influence on the choosing of an “American”
politician who will be irretrievably stuck in an undemocratic, unjust
“American” political system. Obama does not rise above the game; he is a part
of it. This time know better who he is when you take your action. Romney is
clear to me…he has never failed to be who I know him to be. Regardless of whom
you vote for or even whether you choose to vote, know that true democracy is
not this game we play in the US.
We will still have an enormous amount of work to do to fundamentally change
our unjust systems and wake ourselves up so that we are not so easily
manipulated. That is the adult lesson.
Lastly, let’s get back to the question with which we began this column.
We do not have to choose between being the adult and being the child! We are
not stuck in an either/or paradigm foisted on us by some aspects of Western
Culture. Wisdom sayings and stories in many cultures encourage us to adopt
states of wholeness and integration. Our deliberative intelligence can be
integrated with our soaring emotions; we can find that place of emotional intelligence. When we hold our cultures deeply, knowing
that we are inseparable from cultural channeling, and knowing how our buttons
are pushed, we are less vulnerable to the manipulations of propagandists. Know
thy self. We can be inspired by lofty rhetoric without being carried away by
it. We can see and hear the “noise” symbolizing potency and power and know it
for what it is: noise. We can speak to ourselves as adults, without being condescending
or pedantic, being humble and accepting of the possibility that the child in us
might be right. And the adult in us is worthy of being heard.
[Note: Nafsi ya Jamii
is the Swahili phrase that translates in English to
“The Soul Community”]
BlackCommentator.com Columnist, Wilson Riles, is a former Oakland, CA City Council Member. Click here to contact Mr. Riles.