Congressman
Barney Frank has been for decades the iconic image of gay civil
rights advocacy on Capitol Hill.
For
many years he was the lone voice and only openly gay congressman.
And
as a Massachusetts resident I was once proud to say, “Barney Frank has got
my back.”
But
as one of the most vocal critics of the National Equality March
that took place in Washington this weekend, Frank has many LGBTQ Americans nationwide
wondering if he has become a bureaucratic gatekeeper.
And
for those under 40 many are also asking is Barney Frank now the
iconic image of the generational schism of our new gay rights movement?
Mocking
protesters efforts to put pressure on their elected officials on
Capitol Hill for full and equal protection, Frank told the Associated
Press that our demonstration was “a waste of time at best” and that
activists needed to concentrate on lobbying lawmakers. “The only
thing they’re going to be putting pressure on is the grass,” Frank
said.
For
many in the LGBTQ community - young and old - Frank has become too
much of a D.C. bureaucrat and not a relevant representative of even
the Massachusetts’s 4th
congressional district that he has been elected to since 1981.
“I
used to live in Massachusetts and respected Barney Frank. I was
also glad that a gay man was in Congress from my district,” George
of New Jersey wrote on DavidMixer.com. “Since
he pushed President Clinton to pass Don’t ask, Don’t tell, I lost
all respect for him. Now he is telling us not to march and let our
voices be heard. He sounds like he needs to move to the other side
of the aisle. I think it is time for the citizens of Massachusetts to vote him out. If he is telling
us not to waste our time speaking out because nobody listens to
us, what kind of a message does that send - that he doesn’t listen
to us? That’s what we have Republicans are for.”
Of
late, Frank’s record on LGBTQ issues has accommodated the status
quo.
For
example, in April Barney Frank agreed with his Democratic cronies
in not pushing to repeal “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” until 2010. However,
in June the Supreme Court agreed with the Obama administration in
refusing to review the Pentagon policy that prohibits LGBTQ service
members to serve openly in the military. And Frank never spoke up.
But
when he does speak up it’s against our efforts. Frank told the Associated
Press, “I literally don’t understand how this will do anything.
People are kidding themselves. I don’t want people patting themselves
on the back for doing something that is useless. Barack Obama does
not need pressure.”
But
the President has been an Obama-nation on LGBTQ issues since he’s
taken office. The political carrots Obama dangled before us as campaign
promises are now looking like merely empty rhetoric that was used
to court our votes and to collect our campaign dollars.
On
June 4 Jonathan Capehart, an African American gay journalist at
the Washington Post wrote the op-ed “Okay, Obama. Now Let’s Have
a Speech on Gay Rights,” stating “After last night’s airing of NBC’s
Inside the Obama White House interview, in which Obama provided
a tepid answer to a question about whether “gay and lesbian couples
who wish to marry in this country have a friend in the White House,”
the blogosphere is filling with cries of “shameful” and “no passion,
no heart, no real connection to our cause.”
On
June 12, the LGBTQ community got another blow: Obama defend (DOMA),
a law that prevents couples in the states that recognize same-sex
marriage from securing Social Security spousal benefits, filing
joint taxes and other federal rights of marriage. His reasons: DOMA
is not a valid exercise of Congress’s power, and it is not consistent
with Equal Protection or Due Process principles, and it would infringe
on the rights of taxpayers in states that fundamentally oppose same-sex
marriage.
The
purpose of the march was to motivate LGBTQ citizen and our allies
to be active locally. The strategy sessions, grassroots-organizing
workshops that took place over the weekend were to help prepare
activist to do the work at home to achieve full equality for LGBTQ
citizens.
One
of the organizers of the March, Kip Williams said, “We hear Congressman
Frank when he says this is about getting back into your district
and doing the work there. [This march] is about building community
and building a network who will go back and do that work.”
I
wonder if it is “old school” organizing versus “new school” organizing
that Frank missed in understanding the energy for the March. As
Michael Jones of change.org pointed out, “The bulk of the organizing for this
event seemed to take place online, from Facebook to Twitter, and
it has engaged a new generation of activists who aren’t tuned in
to the organizational politics or activism of groups like the Human
Rights Campaign or the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force.”
The
March was a success. Time Magazine reported that 200,000 attended.
But
frankly speaking, how would Barney know? He didn’t attend.
BlackCommentator.com
Editorial Board member, the Rev. Irene Monroe, is a religion columnist,
theologian, and public speaker. A native of Brooklyn, Rev. Monroe
is a graduate from Wellesley College and Union Theological Seminary
at Columbia University, and served as a pastor at an African-American
church before coming to Harvard Divinity School for her doctorate
as a Ford Fellow. Reverend Monroe is the author of Let Your Light Shine Like a Rainbow Always: Meditations on Bible
Prayers for Not-So-Everyday Moments .
As an African American feminist theologian, she speaks for a sector
of society that is frequently invisible. Her website is irenemonroe.com.
Click here
to contact the Rev. Monroe.
|