When
the G20 Summit convened this week in London, there was a dearth
of coverage by UK media professionals of color, in particular Black
journalists. This was most apparent when considering mainstream
coverage, but in many cases it was also evident in the Black or
ethnic media. Lack of media platforms, numbers, resources and the
general state of the news business have all contributed to this
condition. Given the historic nature of President Obama's first
European visit since January's inauguration, this situation could
be considered a noteworthy oversight by some, to others, not really.
When I asked some journalists in the UK about all of this both prior
to the London Summit and immediately after, the responses were varied,
yet in many ways simpatico.
Deborah
Gabriel, founder and director of People With Voices, a new media
organization based in London, England, was not scheduled to cover
the event.
"I
have not received any official notification/press invite to the
event from any government sources, although I am press registered
on the News Distribution Network which manages all government communications
and have had previous contact/invites to press briefings."
she stated. "Personally I would have loved to cover the event,
especially since I am about to launch a journalism training and
news publishing company as a social enterprise to try to bridge
the gap between the mainstream and ethnic media to encourage and
support more in individuals from visible minorities into journalism."
UK
journalist Angela Foster, of the Guardian, tried to arrange an interview
with Michelle Obama, but was refused.
"I
did try to get an interview with her, as I did last time she was
over here, but was told the First Lady wasn't going to be doing
any interviews", she stated.
Yet,
as a Black journalist and citizen of the UK, the visit of the first
African American President of the United States was a special event.
"Obviously,
as a black journalist it is very exciting to have a black president,
particularly seeing him in Downing Street, meeting the Queen, etc."
she reflected.
Ms. Gabriel took it a step further.
"I
would go as far as saying that I have been partly inspired by President
Obama to create this business (People With Voices) as a means of
promoting unity across people from different ethnic and religious
backgrounds - so it is ironic that as a journalist that I won't
be at the event."
However, she issued a caveat when considering fair and balanced
coverage of this historic figure.
"My
view is that whilst on a personal level it is wonderful to have
a black president of the US, on a professional level he must be
held accountable like any other politician and held up to scrutiny."
The
view of Lester Holloway, independent journalist and most recently,
editor of the New Nation, Britain's top African and Caribbean weekly
newspaper, was somewhat similar.
"He's
(President Obama) coming not as an icon or personality, but to do
a job representing the interests of the United States at the G20
summit, so this is not a time for celebratory rallies, it's a time
for results." he stated emphatically.
Holloway
was very tuned into the overall historic nature of the election
of Barack Obama last November, his subsequent role as a world leader,
and the precedent set.
"The
election of President Obama is obviously hugely significant symbolically,
for the inspiration it gives to African people in Britain and worldwide,
and for the 'agenda' it sets regarding the urgency of removing barriers
to equality and justice." he said.
Although
all were in agreement that it was important for the black or ethnic
press to be involved, he was quick to add that there is a different
task for them to perform when providing coverage of President Obama.
"I
don't think its' the role of the black media to try and compete
with the national mainstream. We don't need to join the scrum to
report 'he did this, he said that'. The mainstream keep laboring
on the fact that Obama is black, but daren't take that any further
for fear of what it means to their own privileged position."
he pointed out.
He
further added:
"The
black media, by contrast, need to have a conversation about what
Obama means, and what we need to do in terms of organising, in terms
of reaching for the stars, in terms of educating ourselves about
the history we weren't taught and the links to today's power structures."
Richard
Prince, media expert and editor of Richard Prince's Journal-ISMs,
a diversity report issued from the prestigious Maynard Institute
in Oakland, CA was frank when asked about African American journalists
and black media covering the event.
"It
is important to remember that unless they are freelancing or going
as a columnist or commentator, those who will be covering the event
will be reflecting the priorities of their news organizations.
For
mainstream news organizations, for the most part those priorities
will not involve race. And I doubt that most black-oriented news
outlets in the States can afford the trip."
He
too saw this as a missed opportunity for the unique perspective
black reporters could bring to the overall.
"There
are racial overtones to this meeting, witness Lula's remark about
"blue-eyed greed," and there is a clear division along
north-south lines about proposed solutions to the global economic
crisis." Prince said. "It is the job of any good reporter
to reflect all that, and I would hope that black journalists, as
good reporters, will do so. It's part of providing the complete
picture, and one reason for having a diverse reporting and editing
team. "
The
presidency of Barack Obama and of other influential leaders such
as Lula have created a parallactic shift of conventional beliefs
concerning power, achievement and success in the world, as subtle
as it is apparent.
This fact is not lost on UK journalist Angela Foster, of
the Guardian.
"I
believe black reporters should be involved more in covering the
President and/or First Lady", she reflected. "There are
some things, particularly when covering Michelle Obama, that we
may be able to report differently; and with the President nuances
that the mainstream press might miss."
One
such occasion could be found on Thursday during the First Lady's
surprise visit to Elizabeth Garrett Anderson School in Islington,
North London, which has a largely Black student body. Mrs. Obama's
carefully chosen language during her personal and moving speech
was telling.
In
one of the few appearances of any Black professionals from the UK
during the entire week, Colleen Harris, the Commission for Racial
Equality's Director of Strategy and Communications and former press
secretary to HRH the Prince of Wales, did not hold back emotion
during an honest and heartfelt discussion of the event with Larry
King, host of the American syndicated show of the same name.
She
reflected with pride upon the First Lady's class, intelligence,
and importance as a role model, not only for those girls at the
school, but for Black women in London and around the world. She
also found it particularly refreshing to see an intelligent, successful
Black woman being held up as a role model rather than the usual
entertainment or sports figures.
Still,
Angela Foster, who is also frank when tackling this subject matter
on its own terms, is nonetheless concerned about a possible backlash
down the road when it comes to covering President Obama in general.
"I
do not feel any pressure not to refer to his race or the precedent
that has been set, but that may just be the paper I work for. It's
impossible to ignore it. But I do worry that everyone will turn
on him one day and all the favorable press will end."
BlackCommentator.com Guest Commentator, Amy V. Simmons
is a freelance writer and a member of the National Association
of Black Journalists, the Philadelphia Association of Black Journalists
and the Native American Journalists Association. Click here
to contact Ms. Simmons. |