Studying abroad
in a foreign country is often touted as an important part of
a student’s
college education. This past year, I did just that and for
three months, went to Beijing to study Chinese. But as is often
the case at my predominantly white college, I was the only
black student going.
When I was planning
for my trip to China, I didn’t know what to expect. I had never
been out of the country. To compound matters, I had no idea
what
it would be like over there, to be black.
I was aware, however, of some
of the tensions between Asian-Americans and blacks. In Los
Angeles and Washington DC, there have been well-publicized
incidents of blacks protesting Asian-owned stores for selling
substandard food items to black customers. Los Angeles even
saw riots about this in the early 1990s; some Korean merchants
went as far as taking up arms against blacks.
Meanwhile, it
made news when the leader of Japan’s Liberal Democratic Party declared that
in the United States, “where credit cards are much in use,
a lot of blacks, and so on, think, ‘We're bankrupt. We don't
have to pay anything starting tomorrow.’” For a brief spell
of time, Japanese department stores sold black sambo dolls
and black mannequins with oversized lips - something I thought
had disappeared with Sears and Roebuck magazines in the 1920s.
Against this backdrop I wondered
whether I would experience racism in China, and to what extent
racist stereotypes would influence how the Chinese would act
toward me. Would I be treated fairly?
As the only
black on the trip - and one of the few in Beijing - daily life
could certainly
be awkward. Walking down the streets, I attracted many stares – more,
I’m convinced, than my white classmates. But I do not attribute
this to racism. When I asked a Chinese acquaintance of mine
what their reactions to seeing blacks for the first time were
she admitted that “it’s a little weird, but it’s also weird
seeing white foreigners.”
Many Chinese
have simply never laid eyes on blacks. And since plenty don’t
own televisions, they would not have been exposed to us that
way either. I recall
the time I was on an island looking at Buddhist shrines when
a Chinese man approached me and held his arm out directly across
from mine. He was in my personal space and I felt not a little
uncomfortable. But his reason for this invasion of my privacy
was decidedly benign: he wanted to see if his skin tone was
as dark as mine.
Yet, I was not to escape stereotypes
either. One day, I was returning home with a couple of white
classmates, when a Chinese man solicited them, but not me,
to teach English in a school. He gave them flyers and information
about the job. The whole time, I was standing in plain sight.
He just ignored me. Why?
My mind ticked
through the possibilities. I am naturally predisposed to give
the benefit
of a doubt and not to jump to the most extreme conclusions.
Had he not seen me? That could not be, as I was there in plain
sight. Maybe he could have run out of flyers and had none to
give me? This too was not it; he had a stack in his hand. Perhaps
he thought he had recruited enough teachers after talking to
my white classmates. As it turns out, both rejected the offer,
so he should have been looking for at least two more teachers.
Or maybe he assumed I was from an African country and didn’t
speak English. But then there would be no guarantee that my
classmates knew English either. They certainly could have been
from Bulgaria or Finland. Furthermore, most Chinese I came
across just assumed that foreigners knew English. What would
make me different?
I was left only
to deduce that he assumed upon seeing me that I was not fit
to teach
English. Maybe he had something against people of my exact
weight and build, or maybe it was my hair. More likely though,
it was simply being black that disqualified me in his mind.
I take no joy in reaching this conclusion. Perhaps he thought
I was a thug who didn’t know correct English. Or maybe he worried
his clientele wouldn’t accept me as a teacher. Whatever the
reason, the result was the same. I would like nothing more
than to have judged the situation wrongly. But the evidence
speaks for itself.
Although it is true that many
Chinese have just never come into contact with foreigners,
stereotypes have a way of seeping in. The only images of blacks
on Chinese television I saw were of rappers and basketball
players. From my experience - which is in no way a scientific
poll - more Chinese have heard of Paul Pierce and 50 cent than
have heard of Martin Luther King. If these are the only images
of blacks the Chinese have, then it is not surprising that
some of them would assume for me to be an unsuitable English
teacher.
African students
have occasionally been the targets of much more serious discrimination.
In late
1988 through early 1989, some of the same students who would
end up demonstrating in Tiananmen Square were protesting African
students taking up too many spots at Chinese Universities.
But they were arguably most upset by Africans taking Chinese
women to University dances and reports of rape, that a veteran
observer of Chinese politics I know said were “based on complete
fabrications.” Nor were these aimed at foreigners in general.
The observer noted that white students dating Chinese women
was commonplace and that no such vitriol was visited upon them.
He concluded that the incidents were “irreducibly racist -
a very ugly form of racism.” With bake sales protesting affirmative
action at many American colleges and traditional white fears
of black sexuality - the idea that a black man might dare to
sully white womanhood - we can surely relate.
I should note
here that however bad racism against blacks is, it pales in
comparison to what
the Japanese face. This owes largely to Japanese imperialism
in the 20th century; in particular, many Chinese are understandably
bitter about how their country was torn up by Japanese soldiers
during World War II. Kids in school learn about the famous “rape
of Nanking.” Many Chinese I met on the trip flat-out admitted
they still harbored ill-will toward the Japanese. Every once
in a while, Chinese students storm the Japanese embassy, enraged
that the Japanese Prime Minister has visited the Yasukuni shrine
to Japanese soldiers, or that revisionist Japanese history
textbooks have omitted the atrocities Japanese soldiers committed
during the war.
While the focus of this piece
has been on racism, I would be remiss not to also share my
many good experiences in China. In comparison with the man
who would not consider me to teach English, there were many
Chinese who showed me nothing but kindness. From my professors,
to service people in restaurants, to taxi drivers and college
students, many were nice and approachable and made my time
much richer. I was welcomed into pickup soccer games, and allowed
to play ping pong with random Chinese players. I left the country
grateful for the friends I gained and anxious to return.
Race in China
is a complicated picture. There are racists who are inclined
to think the worst,
and plenty of others who will give anyone a fair hearing, no
matter what their skin color. Things are getting better in
China; yet there remains much more that needs to change. Come
to think of it, China’s evolving racial landscape is not so
very different from America’s.
Marcus Alexander Gadson is a freelance journalist and commentator
on political and social issues. His work on issues ranging
from race, politics, and the war on terrorism has appeared
in various publications. He is also a current student at Dartmouth
College double majoring in History and Asian and Middle Eastern
Studies. Click
here to contact Mr. Gadson.