It’s worse than being
a lap-dog. No matter what station in life or educational degrees
or talents any American may have held before he or she fell
victim to the health care crisis in this nation, inclusion in
the national debate – the real national debate in which
the powerful speak to the powerful – is still closed to
all but the elite. And until the patients and families are truly
embraced in this fight and included in the debate about solutions,
they will remain second-class citizens, poster children at best,
with little true power.
Many in powerful positions
in government say they understand and they even fight for critical
change. The best and most genuine example is that of Rep. John
Conyers, D-MI, and chairman of the House Judiciary, who has
put forth a real reform plan with HR 676 and who truly does
embrace those who have suffered. At a recent break-out session
for the Black Caucus Legislative Conference in Washington, D.C.,
Rep. Conyers stayed in the Convention Center room long after
other celebrities had made their statements and slipped off
to their busy schedules. Conyers chatted with patients and with
families and with a steely yet loving eye-to-eye conversation,
let each person know the suffering matters, the pain is understood
by one of Congress’ most powerful men.
But what is up with the
rest of our policy groups and policy makers, media members and
conference planners that they remain too self-absorbed, too
busy and too important to stoop down and embrace those devastated
by this crisis? The real details of the health care crisis –
the truth about what happens in those doctors’ offices,
clinics and hospitals – really does rest in the minds
and hearts of those who have been crushed. And many of the best
solutions rest there too.
After I testified to a sub-committee
of the House Judiciary about the health care crisis and what
it is doing to well-educated, middle class citizens, I wanted
that testimony and that truth to bleed deep enough into the
health reform community to make the voices of the victims more
valid, more valued and more demanded. Yet, to date, that has
not materialized.
Oh, we victims are invited
to make brief remarks to open an event or sometimes make brief
nods in response to applause, but take a look at any major conference
planned on this issue, and I’ll bet you that no patient
or family member gets more than two or three minutes' time to
speak and certainly no time to discuss policy.
As an example, get a load
of this one: http://www.uninsuredcongress.com/
Here we have the announcement of a major conference in our nation’s
capital in early December. Now read the presenters list. PhDs,
Esquires, doctors, lawyers, CEOs and other high muckity-mucks
– oh, yes, they are there. But patients? Not one on the
agenda. Not one. Not even a break-out session. Not even a mention.
The only true experts on this crisis are not valued enough to
even be included.
A Congressional staffer
once told me, “It’s like running the civil rights
movement without African Americans.” Indeed.
That’s why statements
born of pain and suffering, like union man Steve Skvara, offered
at a Democratic candidates’ debate in Chicago in August,
stand out so much. His voice, his plea is but one of millions.
And he hurts so much that the tidbits of concerned head-tilting
and listening for a few weeks, by those with something to gain
from it (votes or ratings), will soothe him for a while. Then
those powerful few will march right on past him and on to the
next chance to look like they truly value the opinions of the
wretched masses.
I am so angry.
I have felt a sort of discrimination that is disgusting and
makes me distrust so very deeply. For I am the poor face of
what the for-profit health system has created. And now that
the system has squeezed all of my financial security away and
left me unable to buy the new clothes or dresses or cars or
hairdos or even the social interactions that would signal my
worth to those who have power, I don’t know what I can
do to reach my fellow Americans who are too tacky for inclusion
in the events where the value of our very lives will be decided.
So, you’ll keep hearing
from me as I pound my fists on the table and on the doors and
windows to power. The group I founded after I spoke my truth
to power in my Congressional testimony is called “American
Patients for Universal Health Care” (apuhc.com). And
though we’ve attended many functions and we are growing
in numbers, our power has yet to be fully realized and our group
is still invited to attend but not yet participate.
We held vigils across America
last week to call attention to health care justice issues. It
was our first national action but by no means our last. And
until the press takes note and the powers that be take heed,
we will raise our voices louder and louder.
But I was reminded once
again this week, “Freedom’s just another word for
nothing left to lose…” And baby, am I and millions
of others in this nation, free right now.
Hang on to your hats, those
of you in power. If you cannot hear the polite knocking and
the gentle requests for our seat at this fictional table you
keep talking about, that decides health care policy, we will
not be the servants dishing up your feast and cleaning up your
dishes on election day.
Donna Smith is one of the "stars" of Michael
Moore's documentary "SiCKO"
and Founder of American
Patients for Universal Health Care.
Click
here to contact Ms. Smith and Healthcare-NOW.
Click
here to read any of the articles in this special BC series on Single-Payer Healthcare.