“Big Brother” looking over your shoulder is literally
in the here and now in the United States. Many are asking the
question, “Are there any privacy rights in America any more?”
When George Orwell wrote the book, Nineteen Eighty-Four,
in 1949, in the midst of the emerging McCarthyism (the purging
of Communist sympathizers in the U.S., in the midst of a dawning
Cold War’s second “Big Red Scare”), it seemed to be a far-reaching
fictitious misnomer that the American government would ever become
so obtrusive that no act would go unseen - no conversation would
go unheard - and no transaction would go unnoticed. Yet, 58 years
later, that appears to be where we are, if one were to accept
the Justice Department’s most recent Inspector General’s report
that the Federal Bureau of Investigation has abused their authority
under the Patriot Act. Ah, that explains why some of my checks
are missing.
While you must understand that this is the winking
part of the government, reporting on the run-away part of the
government, the report essentially confirms our biggest fears
- that the Patriot Act would one day be exploited - and that a
loosing of the people’s rights to shore up national security and
to pursue international terrorism, would one day be used to track
anyone the government designated as “domestic terrorists".
The winking part is the highly partisan, Attorney General, Alberto
R. Gonzales, in the midst of his own controversy (firing U.S.
Attorneys for not being “aggressive enough” on key Bush administration
priorities), pretending that the Justice Department is really
concerned about protecting citizens' rights. The run-away part
is the FBI improperly obtaining citizens’ phone, bank and credit
records through the use of a “national security letter",
an administrative subpoena form that allows them to get around
the court’s legal process. That’s on top of the FBI being able
to indiscriminately listen to your phone calls and monitor your
Internet activity. Historically, there was always a running joke
among activists during phone conversations, on the constant clicking,
that the “devil was on the line". No matter how much we try
to convince ourselves that (J. Edgar) Hoover is dead, knowing
the FBI’s history - it is no surprise that it would be the agency
called out for abusing the Patriot Act and citizens’ private information.
Yet, we’re there. We should assume that the devil is on the line
all the time now. Every line you have - your phone line, your
bank line, your credit line, your Internet line. Makes you feel
much safer from those ole' terrorists now, right? Well, who keeps
us safe from the FBI?
It’s not like we’ve never been violated before
by the FBI. Not when you know the history of the FBI, a continuing
one of pursuing so-called “subversive groups", and the tactics
used to destroy organizations and people. The FBI has always been
bi-polar, working to solve civil rights violations while, at the
same time, exploiting Americans’ civil rights. What started as
an effort to keep the nation safe from subversive Communist influences
in the 1940s (after World War II), became mostly a domestic counter-intelligence
program in the 1950s, 1960s and 1970s. The NAACP, SCLC, the Nation
of Islam, SNCC, the Black Panther Party, US, CORE, the ADL, NOW,
Anti-War Groups, Labor Unions and (some) Churches were all identified
as subversive groups during Hoover’s Era of “protecting national
interests” (Hoover always got permission from Presidents by justifying
that it was in the nation’s national interests). Even the FBI’s
more extreme initiatives, the infamous Counterintelligence Program
(COINTEL-Pro) that tapped the phones of every civil rights and
grassroots leader - even Attorney General, Bobby Kennedy - caused
disruption in every black organization and essentially caused
the fall of the Civil Rights movement. Then, there was the even
more controversial, King Alfred Plan (also called the “Final Solution
to the Negro Problem”), a plan for an eight hour round-up and
mass incarnation of African Americans in a time of national civil
disturbance (like which occurred after the King assassination)
to prevent what Hoover called “the rise of another Black Messiah".
While assailed and even dismissed - as largely “conspiratorial",
as far as we know - many are concerned, that the plan has never
been taken off the table and is still part of the government martial
law plan, should a martial law order ever have to be engaged.
And trust me, there is a martial law plan out there. Always has
been, as part of the nation’s national security planning to prevent
the destabilization of the Democracy (government). Now, the Patriot
Act has given the FBI a “green light” like never before.
So, understand that as the FBI has been a run-away
agency for a long time; there is no reason to believe that it
would suddenly check itself on this national security initiative.
Congress claims “it wants answers". Hell, the FBI didn’t
give Congress answers when Hoover was alive. It didn’t give Congress
answers when hearings were held to find out why their “intelligence”
didn’t know about 9/11. They didn’t even respond to Congress’
requests on its intelligence on why weapons of mass destruction
were never found (they knew better so why dance in the dog and
pony show). So what makes Congress think that the FBI is going
to tell them what they’re doing as part of their anti-terrorism
strategy? Particularly, when they take their lead from an administration
that believes in not telling “the enemy” what we (the U.S.) are
doing to combat terrorism. Only now, the American people have
become the enemy too (again), and the absence of accountability
only exacerbates the potential for exploitation. And as is always
the case, the public only finds out about the violations in the
aftermath of them occurring. In other words, “the people” are
shafted again.
The talk of putting limits on the Patriot Act
should be more than just talk. It’s not going to end for as long
as the nation is in Iraq (and probably not after that), there
needs to be a greater accountability to check the run-away aspects
of this privacy invasion. With the watchdogs being chased out
of government, how do you check it? That’s even a bigger question
for Congress to answer. In the meantime, I’ll guess we, “John
and Jane Q. Public", just have to resign ourselves to being
violated - at least until the people reclaims their government.
Just get used to the clinkin’, the missing checks and cookies
on your computer. Spyware doesn’t work - the government invented
it.
Don’t worry. I already know the devil’s on my
line and in my checkbook, etc, etc. Welcome to the new America
where “Big Brother” knows everything about the American people,
but knows little about how to find...well, you know. That might
explain why I don’t feel any safer.
BC
columnist Anthony Asadullah Samad is a national columnist, managing
director of the Urban
Issues Forum and author of the upcoming book, Saving The Race:
Empowerment Through Wisdom. His Website is www.AnthonySamad.com.
Click
here to contact Mr. Samad. |