President George
Bush deflects criticism of his war plans by claiming that his
critics have no plans of
their own. Vice President Dick Cheney, meanwhile, asserts
that matters of war must be left in the hands of the President
(presumably no matter how brilliant your alternative plan). Congressman Dennis Kucinich (D., Ohio) has
had an exit plan on his website for over three years. Congresswoman Lynn Woolsey
(D., Calif.) has held several hearings discussing exit plans over
the past year and a half. Peace activists, including Tom
Hayden, have published and promoted a variety of exit plans over
the past couple of years, and have even gone so far as to meet
and discuss them with members of the Iraqi Parliament.
More recently, former Senator George McGovern
and William Polk have published a detailed exit plan, one that
helped shape a bill
introduced on January 17th by a dozen Democrats led by Woolsey. It's
a comprehensive bill that lays out a plan to safely bring our troops
home, end the war, reconstruct Iraq, and take care of our veterans
for a change. The Woolsey bill is one of several new bills
in Congress that would end the war. At least two others,
sponsored by Congressmen Jim McGovern (D., Mass.) and Jerrold Nadler
(D., New York) include, as does Woolsey's, a key component that
shatters Cheney's vision of executive power: they cut off the funds
for the war. Of course, they do so while providing for the
safe return of our troops.
While the U.S. Constitution actually does not
give to any branch of our government the authority to launch
aggressive and endless
wars against other countries, that beleaguered document does give
the Congress the authority to declare war. When that authority
is neglected by Congress or overrun by the White House, Congress
can make use of another Constitutional power, the power of the
purse. While the President might argue that he has the legal
authority to continue or escalate a war once underway, even if
opposed by Congress, he cannot do so if Congress denies him the
necessary funding.
Of course, Congress must also provide the funding
to begin a war or to do anything else whatsoever. Bob Woodward's "Plan
of Attack" reports that in the summer of 2002 Bush took money
appropriated by Congress for Afghanistan and other programs and,
with no Congressional notification, used it to build airfields
in Qatar and secretly begin a war on Iraq. According to Woodward,
the amount was $700 million; the Congressional Research Service
later found it was actually $2.5 billion.
Meanwhile, Bush was marketing his proposed
(and secretly begun) war to Congress and the American public,
making claims that have
proven false in virtually every detail. Amazingly, four years
later, Congress has yet to investigate this apparently fraudulent
marketing campaign.
The Senate Select Committee on Intelligence and the so-called
WMD Commission have both done investigations and produced reports,
but both were barred from addressing the central question of whether
the Bush administration had presented the intelligence honestly.
There are some Democrats, newly in power, proposing
to investigate this war, just as there are some proposing to
cut off the funding
and end it. But both groups are currently small minorities
in Congress, even if they speak for the majority of Americans who
oppose this war and want the truth brought to light. The
only reason that even these moral leaders in Congress have begun
to act on this issue is the intensity of the public pressure they
are feeling. We are planning to dramatically increase that
pressure on every member of the House and Senate on January 27th
and 29th.
On February 15, 2003, we organized with our
allies around the world the single largest day of protest in
world history, a protest
aimed at preventing this war before it began. While we failed
to influence President Bush or the Republican Congress, our position
won out in nations around the world which refused to take part
in the war, and in the United Nations which refused to sanction
it. Had our government been more democratic, more open to
the concerns of its citizens, this war would not have happened.
We now have a Congress controlled by Democrats. Will they
be more responsive than the Republicans? There is one way
to find out. On January 27th we are organizing a massive
march in Washington, D.C., followed by a day of organized citizen
lobbying for peace on January 29th. We'll find out if the
change of party we voted for in November changed something more
than the names of committee chairs. Learn more at unitedforpeace.org.
David Swanson is the Washington Director of Democrats.com and
of ImpeachPAC.org.
He is co-founder of the AfterDowningStreet.org coalition,
creator of MeetWithCindy.org,
and a board member of Progressive
Democrats of America, and of the Backbone
Campaign. He was the organizer in 2006 of Camp
Democracy. He serves on the steering committee of the Charlottesville
Center for Peace and Justice and on a working group of United
for Peace and Justice. His website is www.davidswanson.org. |