According to the gospel of Matthew, it came to pass
that Pontius Pilate said to Jesus, "Do you not hear all this
evidence that is brought against you?" for even in those days
of rudimentary justice, a man had the right to hear the charges
of his accusers. Yet two thousand years later, under a bill urged
by President Bush, a compliant Congress may agree to allow a prisoner
of war to be tried without hearing all the evidence against him,
some being held back in the name of "national security."
For what is more important, the life of one individual or the security
of the State? Every totalitarian regime knows the answer to that.
And so prisoners may be put to death, perhaps on false charges,
without even knowing what wrong they are accused of.
According to the gospel of Matthew, not long before
his trial and while journeying to Jerusalem, Jesus took his disciples
aside and told them he would be arrested in the city where he would
be handed over to a foreign power, to be tried and crucified. And
so, too, today, there are more than 400 captives in Guantanamo prison,
removed from their homeland by a foreign power in defiance of Geneva,
men who have been made to suffer for years in a strange land half
a world away from their homes and families, without being charged,
without a lawyer, without trial, every one of the uncharged, denied
due process and thus every one of them innocent. And others, even
more unfortunate, have been abducted by the CIA against international
law, handed over to a foreign power to be imprisoned, tortured,
and, in some cases, crucified, with no trial, and the new bill urged
by Mr. Bush allows the CIA to continue its practices.
According to the gospel of Matthew, Jesus extolled
those who showed mercy, saying, "when I was naked ye clothed
me; when I was ill ye came to my help, and when I was in prison
ye visited me." By some strange reversal of New Testament teaching,
in the same way as Jesus was stripped of his clothing, captives
in U.S. prisons have been stripped of theirs and confined naked
in rooms of extreme temperature or threatened by dogs or stacked
naked in human pyramids or mocked and scorned or sexually abused
or beaten. Such actions, contradicting the words of Jesus, "That
which ye do to the least of my brethren ye do also to me,"
violate Common Article 3 of Geneva that forbids "outrages upon
personal dignity, in particular, humiliating and degrading treatment."
As for being visited in prison, many a captive in
U.S. custody, such as those in the CIA compound in Kabul, has been
denied visits by the International Red Cross, and some have been
held incognito, as the "ghost" prisoners of Guantanamo,
whose names are not even carried on the prison rolls, also a violation
of Geneva. Nor do their families have the opportunity to visit them,
a privilege that was commonly afforded even in the days of primitive
justice in the time of Jesus, who saw prison visits as a blessing.
But what is international law to President Bush, who
reportedly told aides, "the Constitution is just a damn scrap
of paper"? By contrast, Jesus said, "If any man therefore
sets aside even the least of the Law's demands, and teaches others
to do the same, he will have the lowest place in the kingdom of
Heaven…"
According
to the gospel of Matthew, Jesus went up to the hills, and "When
he was seated there, crowds flocked to him, bringing with them the
lame, blind, dumb, and crippled, and many other sufferers...and
he healed them...and they gave praise to the God of Israel."
Only in Bush's prisons, the sighted are put in darkness
for days at a time, whole men are beaten until they are crippled,
and sane men are driven mad and to suicide. Recall the words of
Matthew: "They (the chief priests) put him in chains and led
him away, to hand him over to Pilate, the Roman Governor."
Today, in America's prisons, men are being chained in stress positions
for days at a time or hung by chains suspended from the ceiling
for a week or longer.
According to the gospel of Matthew, Jesus told his
disciples, "Do not murder," an injunction not followed
by the Bush White House, as more than 100 prisoners have died in
U.S. custody, likely every one of them murdered, and several admittedly
murdered by their handlers. As for following the Lord's injunction,
"anyone who commits murder must be brought to judgment,"
not one administration official in an executive position responsible
for shaping the brutal torture policy has been put on trial.
According to the gospel of Matthew, in his Sermon
on the Mount, Jesus said, "How blest are those who show mercy;
mercy shall be shown to them." Yet, the world sees none of
it from the White House. Mercy, a gift within the reach of all humanity,
is also within the grasp of President Bush and a Congress that appears
liable to codify his inhumane bill on the trial and treatment of
prisoners. Any member of Congress who votes "aye" will
be guilty of condoning torture and subject to prosecution under
international law. Equally despicable, any member of Congress who
approves the bill will be voting in defiance of the highest moral
law ever preached on this planet.
The president's biographers write he is a regular
reader of the Bible. If so, he must be reading the King George version.
Sherwood Ross is an American reporter who has worked
for major American newspapers and magazines as well as international
wire services. To comment on this article or arrange for speaking
engagements: [email protected]. His
blog is The Smirking Chimp. |