Only 12 years elapsed between the glorious military victory over the
Confederate Slave States in 1865 and the definitive defeat of Reconstruction
in 1877. In many important respects, the Reconstruction period was
even briefer than that. By 1870, when the last of the southern states
ratified the 15th Amendment to the Constitution, Tennessee
had already rejected biracial democracy and installed an all-white “Redeemer” government. “Redemption” then
swept through Georgia, North Carolina and Virginia.
For the next six years, much of the South experienced El Salvador-like
levels of political violence, including the 1873 massacre of as many
as 300 Blacks in Colfax, Louisiana – just one episode in the successful
campaign to “Redeem” that state for white supremacy. Although the last
Black congressman was not run out of the South until 1900 (Rep. George
Henry White, Wilmington, North Carolina), Reconstruction was politically
crushed with the 1877 Democrat-Republican agreement to withdraw federal
troops from South Carolina, Florida and Louisiana. The Hayes-Tilden
Compromise signaled that white southern “Redemption” from the threat
of full Black citizenship rights was all but complete. This mutual
understanding among the great majority of whites – North, South, East
and West – would remain intact for nearly a century. In the warped
religiosity of the white southern sense of the word, America as a nation
was “Redeemed.” A suffocating peace would reign among white men.
With the death of Reconstruction, the great American leap into social
modernity was aborted. What followed was not only a descent into Jim
Crow hell for Black folks, but the arrested development of the United
States as a civilized society. For the next 60 years, American politics
was dominated by a national corporate oligarchy and a one-party apartheid
political order in the South, armed with congressional veto power over
federal social legislation. For three generations, until the Great
Depression of the 1930s made the conversation unavoidable, American
rulers more or less successfully suppressed the mere discussion of
a social contract between capital and labor and among citizens. How
could it have been otherwise, since white America had rejected the
equality clause of Reconstruction’s proposed contract with Black America?
The social legislation of the New Deal and the post-World War II GI
Bill – tame by European standards – was received by most white Americans
as a gift of white privilege, a helping hand for the “good people” as
opposed to the undeserving – chiefly, but not exclusively, Negroes.
The U.S. became a global superpower without the bulk of its population
having ever wrestled with the broader meaning of the Rights of Man in
an industrial world. In the Fifties and Sixties this fundamentally
stunted society was beset by alien intrusions – the necessity to interact
with and impress a wider world and, most importantly, agitation by
the Black “others.” Kicking and screaming (and warring and lynching),
the white body politic was forced to reconsider its previous verdict
on Black citizenship rights.
The debate over the Black condition in America of necessity
led to a reexamination of the nature of U.S. society in general – just
as Reconstruction in the South had briefly introduced the notion of
public intervention in education and social development. In addition
to strictly “civil rights” measures, the Sixties produced a flurry
of social legislation (entitlements) that reinforced the New Deal rudiments
of a truly national social contract. The U.S. seemed poised to achieve
Western European levels of civilization.
“Redemptionists” despaired when Barry Goldwater’s 1964 GOP/Dixiecrat
counterattack flamed out in a landslide defeat. But only four years
later, in 1968, the Republicans’ “Southern Strategy” put Richard Nixon
in the White House. In the wake of Dr. Martin Luther King’s murder,
Black Americans either demobilized or, in the case of the most militant
elements, were crushed by the state. The heirs to Black leadership
all but abandoned mass political action – aside from electioneering.
For the newly upwardly mobile segment of Blacks, profit-taking became
the order of the day. Their anthem, courtesy of songwriters McFadden
and Whitehead: “Ain’t No Stoppin’ Us Now – We’re on the Move!”
However, true white “Redeemers” never accepted the tenuous new order,
and distrusted Richard Nixon as an appeaser of dark, anti-American
forces at home and abroad. Their hero was California Governor Ronald
Reagan (1967 – 1975), a Goldwaterite who opposed the Voting Rights
Act (“bad legislation…that infringed on the rights of citizens”), affirmative
action (“reverse discrimination”) and the entire menu of War on Poverty
programs.
Unable to pry incumbent Gerald Ford from the Republican nomination
in 1976, Reagan’s handlers led Goldwater’s resurgent forces to a pure “Redeemer” victory
in 1980, coached by none other than the young Mississippi Congressman
Trent Lott. As Time Magazine’s Jack White wrote in his December, 2002
article, “Lott,
Reagan and Republican Racism,” Lott “was among those
who urged Reagan to deliver his first major campaign speech in Philadelphia,
Mississippi, where three civil rights workers were murdered in one
of the 1960s' ugliest cases of racist violence.” Lest anyone mistake
the “Redemptionist” nature of his campaign, Reagan proudly waved his
Dixiecrat credentials: "I believe in states' rights
and I believe in people doing as much as they can for themselves at
the community level and at the private level."
Every white voter in the South – and most in the North, East and West – knew
what he meant. Black folks understood the language, too, but nonetheless
remained largely immobile outside the electoral arena.
”The gravy-train years of the 1970s, the golden age of the post-civil
rights era, led black Americans into a false sense of security and
did not prepare them for the Republican Risorgimento of the 1980s,” writes
Norman Kelly, in “The Head Negro In Charge Syndrome: The Dead End of
Black Politics” (2004, Nation Books):
As during the Reconstruction years, the modern period of progressive
victories was intense but tragically brief. Legislatively speaking,
most of the action occurred from 1964 to 1968 under President Lyndon
Johnson (although non-True “Redeemer” Nixon acquiesced in a number
of broadly progressive initiatives).
Having won as many “rights” as they actually wanted, but uninterested
in fundamentally altering power relationships in America, those African
Americans who perceived Jim Crow as the only problem disbanded
the “movement,” leaving poorer Blacks to their own devices. The pursuit
of individual wealth is not a mass activity, although the aggrandizers
never hesitate to invoke the plight of the Black masses when it is
to their advantage.
What the demobilized Black leadership failed to understand is that
the “Redeemers” never quit; they continue to demonize and campaign
against Black people even when African Americans represent no threat
to their rule. Such was the case in the Deep South in the more
than half-century in which the Black vote was virtually nonexistent.
No matter. Racist demagogues kept their lock on power by relentlessly
railing against helpless, unarmed, economically dependent, despised
Blacks. It’s still a winning formula.
A quarter century later, the Reaganite momentum shows no signs
of having exhausted itself. As journalist Joe
Davidson puts
it:
The Philadelphia Inquirer’s Acel
Moore phrases it succinctly
in his piece, “Left Out of Morning in America.” Reagan, said Moore, “presided and helped create an age in
which too many people felt free to express their bigotry. Ignorance
had a holiday.”
George Bush is ignorance personified. But he knows his people.
The first and second Reconstructions were too short to disconnect
white America from its founding, racist vision of Manifest Destiny.
As a consequence, the United States is fundamentally disconnected from
the modern world – to the world’s peril, and our own.
Persons not enthralled at the pageantry of Reagan’s sendoff wonder,
what is this national display really about?
It is white Americans deeply engaged in the rituals of self-worship – a
heresy and abomination that usually portends great violence in the
fires of “Redemption.”