Homophobia
runs deep!
So deep that it also impinges on the animal world.
Toronto's
zoo is splitting up a pair of same-gender penguins. These
Happy Feet males, Pedro and Buddy, jokingly referred
to as "Brokeback Iceberg" have been
nesting with each other for a year.
The
reason for the boys split up, a zoo official says, is because
African penguins are an endangered species.
The pair has what's known as a "social bond," but it's
not necessarily a "sexual bond", Tom Mason, the
zoo's curator of birds and invertebrates told the Associated
Press.
"Penguins
are so social they need that ... company. And the group
they came from was a bachelor group waiting for a chance
to be paired up with females," Mason stated. "They
had paired up there, they came to us already paired, and
it's our job to be matchmakers to get them to go with some
females."
But Buddy, I opine, may have been involuntarily "on the down
low" for breeding purposes until he was able to express
his true penguin passion with Pedro.
According
to the zoo's curator, Buddy, who's 21, had a female partner
for 10 years and produced offspring, but his female partner
died. Pedro, on the other hand, who's 10, has yet to produce
offspring.
While we can banter and bicker about the heterosexist actions of
a zookeeper to our North, our actions of animal homophobia
isn't any better.
For example, who would have thought that the politics of same-sex
coupling of birds would a debatable topic in the marriage
equality state of Massachusetts?
But during the summer of 2005, more than a year after
same-sex marriage became legal in the state, Boston's beloved
pair of swans in the Public Garden - named Romeo and Juliet
- had been having a love affair that dares not speak its
name. And as Bay Staters bantered and bickered over whether
the two should be allowed to stay together or be separated,
these swans were being subjected to the same queries that
have plagued same-sex couples in heterosexist societies
for centuries.
Assuming that the swans were heterosexual until one of the
couple's eggs went unfertilized, Boston's Parks and Recreation
Department decided to conduct a "detailed gender test"
by examining the swans' reproductive organs. The findings
disclosed that Romeo and Juliet were really more like Juliet
and Juliet.
The city disclosed its findings, but very reluctantly, "for
fear of destroying the image of a Shakespearean love story
unfolding," as reported in The Boston Globe.
But some people thought like Laura Elsheimer of Hudson,
Mass., who told the Globe that the city "should have
a Romeo." And spokeswoman Mary Hines of the city's
Parks and Recreation Department told the Globe, "Each
year when the swans go in, the kids immediately come to
us and say, ˜Which one's Romeo and which one's Juliet?'"
Where the public might think a male is needed to make them
a complete or authentic couple, neither of the girls seems
to be lamenting, "O Romeo, Romeo! Wherefore art thou
Romeo?" Why? Because on any given day at the Public
Garden you saw them swimming happily together in the lagoon.
Moreover, the swans have been cohabiting for two years.
Animal scientists have observed the monogamous nature of
swans whether they are in opposite-sex or same-sex coupling
- they stay with their mates until death, which can last
anywhere from 20 to 30 years.
While there was also debate whether Romeo should be renamed
to reflect the swan's gender, I can imagine Juliet saying
about all this much ado, "What's in a name? That which
we call a rose by any other name would smell as sweet."
Same-sex coupling is not a new phenomenon in the animal
world. However, its disclosure and acceptance comes in a
homophobic society that will attempt to pathologize it.
But
in fact, scientists at Oregon Health & Science and the
U.S. Department of Agriculture's Sheep Experiment Station
are discovering that all sexualities may be biologically
driven. In a recent study on rams, researchers at OHS found
that 8 percent are gay, but with such a low percentage finding,
the Christian Right can still hold to its premise that homosexuality
is an aberrant behavior and found only in those lost few.
More controversial studies on animal homosexuality, being
denounced by Christian conservatives, are Bruce Bagemihl's
"Biological Exuberance: Animal Homosexuality and Natural
Diversity," and the findings of Deric Bownds, a University
of Wisconsin-Madison zoology professor. In fact, Bagemihl's
book was cited by the American Psychiatric Association in
a "friend of the court" brief submitted to the
U.S. Supreme Court in the Lawrence v. Texas case that lead
to state anti-sodomy laws being found unconstitutional.
According to Bagemihl, homosexual activity occurs in more
than 450 species of animals both in the wild and in captivity,
and same-sex couplings in animals are as enduring and life-long
as they are in humans.
For the religious fundamentalists, however, these findings are
discarded on the premise that man can fight such instincts
whereas animals cannot because God did not give them the
capacity to reason.
"Yes, animals can be forced to perform homosexual acts,
by depriving them from the possibility to perform their
reproductive function in the natural way," Shams Ali
wrote in "Homosexuality Among Animals and Humans."
"... All this means is that animals are not free -
they are driven by their instincts. ... But the difference
between a man and an animal is that Man has reason, which
he uses to control his instincts and urges."
And let's not forget how we have seen many religious
fundamentalists express their distain for same-sex coupling
in us humans with the well-known vitriolic protest
placard: Adam and Eve, not Adam and Steve.
The fate of Happy Feet males, Pedro and Buddy, being
allowed to stay together is swimming in a homophobic
tide.
But for us humans, the lesson here is that a heterosexual-only
view of love not only constrains and constricts our human
capacity to love one another, it also limits our capacity
to tell the whole story about the birds and the bees.
BlackCommentator.com
Editorial Board member, the Rev. Irene Monroe, is a religion
columnist, theologian, and public speaker. She is the Coordinator of
the African-American Roundtable of the Center for Lesbian and
Gay Studies in Religion and Ministry (CLGS) at the Pacific
School of Religion. A native of Brooklyn, Rev. Monroe is a
graduate from Wellesley College and Union Theological Seminary
at Columbia University, and served as a pastor at an African-American
church before coming to Harvard Divinity School for her
doctorate as a Ford Fellow. She was recently named to MSNBC’s
list of 10 Black Women You Should Know. Reverend Monroe is the author
of Let Your Light Shine Like a Rainbow Always: Meditations on Bible
Prayers for Not’So’Everyday Moments. As an African-American
feminist theologian, she speaks for a sector of society
that is frequently invisible. Her website is
irenemonroe.com.
Click here
to contact the Rev. Monroe.
|