It’s
almost impossible to escape the assault on the left these
days. Most of it, oddly, is coming from the left or those
who describe themselves as “progressives” in one form or
another. The narrative goes like this: The left has no agenda.
The left has no plan for America. The left is standing around
while the right is running off with the country. Things
like that.
The
Washington Post, the New York Times, and virtually all of
the so-called left-leaning media outlets run think pieces,
analyses, and other reportage on the lack of any energy
on left. So what’s the deal?
Well, maybe they are right (no pun intended). Where in the
world are the ideas that will balance what is happening
in America? Is the progressive end of the political spectrum
really out of gas? Is Paul Krugman the only one left standing
who speaks to a broad audience? Is Dennis Kucinich the only
liberal in Congress?
Let’s take a look at the tax issue. Oklahoma Senator Tom
Coburn (R) was recently on Charlie Rose and lamented that
“twenty per cent of Americans pay eighty per cent of the
taxes.” He had the serious look of a man who knows unfairness
when he sees it. Disappointly, Rose did not point out that
these twenty per cent own eighty per cent of America’s wealth
and therefore such a tax burden is not at all unfair. Coburn
was justifying his and other Republicans’ refusal to even
consider raising the taxes on the super rich. When President
Obama forcefully made the case for raising the taxes on
these very wealthy people, Republicans responded by suggesting
that the President wants to raises taxes for “the American
people.”
From the left? Crickets.
The right has seized the narrative and has wound this side
of the argument into the fabric of the political discourse
so tightly that in some bizarre way even the people who
are being hurt the most by the shameful economic policies
of this country are buying into it. The low income, out
of work whites who stand to benefit from tighter regulations
on financial institutions, stronger unions, and income equality
are being lured into the myth that what conservative Republicans
are saying is true. The old racist, anti-black, anti-immigrant
spores are coming to life once again as poor – and newly
poor – whites looking for someone to blame for their lost
homes, jobs and dignity. And instead of taking to the streets
demanding change, they are being fed a diet of what comes
out of the back end of a horse. And liking it.
There is a kind of Stockholm Syndrome taking place here.
The oppressed are identifying with and supplying sympathy
for their oppressors. How else can you explain why a person
who is out of work and has lost his home will vote for someone
who vows to keep taxes low for billionaires? I believe there
is more going on here than simply the rants of right wing
radio and television. There is a lack of viable force from
the left.
By now we’re all tired of the argument that President Obama
is too passive. Maybe he is. Maybe what we need is another
Lyndon Johnson. (Okay, I know that some people of a certain
age are not eager to consider anything about Lyndon in a
positive way.) What he could do is get things done. He could
twist arms, charm, threaten, make it happen. Vietnam was
the negative. The Civil Rights Act and the Voting Rights
Act were nation-changing. The same conservative voices we’re
hearing today were in the air back in the sixties and were
even louder and more forceful, yet they were overcome.
Maybe the left is too passive all around. Possibly it is
too intellectual and theoretical. I suspect the left is
a bit intimidated by the forcefulness and the energy of
the right. They yell, we whisper. They issue a program and
jam it down our throats and we respond with the soft voice
of Harry Reid, the Mr. Peeper of the Senate.
It’s like the advice parents gave their children for generations:
Nobody takes you seriously if you don’t fight back. So,
let’s set an agenda and fight for it.
First, what do we want? The right has done a good job on
this score. Cut taxes, reduce government, and intolerance
of others. (That’s my take on it) We, on the other hand,
want fair taxes, government responsive to the needs
of the people, and social justice.
Those of us who remember the scent of teargas in the sixties
may not be in shape to take to the streets again but we
can do something. We can work the phones to call members
of Congress, our state legislators, our local council members,
and our neighborhood organizations. People who are subject
to the decisions of voters pay attention when voters sound
off. That requires, of course, that you vote!
Second, pass this message to young people. The older generation
experienced the power of social change through action. Many
young people today simply do not believe that things can
change. It would be hard to find anyone under thirty who
believes that she/he will receive any Social Security or
Medicare benefits. The greatest gift an older person can
pass on to a young person is the assurance that personal
commitment and action can change the course of their lives
and their country.
There were greybeards in the crowds of the great marches
and rallies of the past and we who are now the greybeards
can be in those crowds today to demand that our grandchildren
live in a better nation.
Click here to
read any commentary in this BC series.
Click here to
send a comment to all the participants in this BC series.
BlackCommentator.com Guest Commentator, Larry Matthews, is
a veteran broadcast journalist. He is the recipient of The
George Foster Peabody
Award for Excellence in Broadcast for his reporting on Vietnam veterans.
He is also the recipient of a Columbia/DuPont Citation,
Society of Professional Journalists, Associated Press, and
other awards for investigative reporting. He
is the author of I
Used to Be in Radio
, and two novels. Click here to
reach Mr. Matthews.
|