This
time, Glenn Beck has managed to outdo even himself. Finally,
can we say enough is enough?
Recently, the Fox News host made some unacceptable comments
about George Soros, the Hungarian-American philanthropist and Holocaust survivor. On his radio
show, Beck claimed that Soros— who as a 13-year-old boy
was separated from his parents in Nazi-occupied Hungary—
“used to go around with this anti-Semite and deliver papers
to the Jews and confiscate their property and then ship
them off. … It was frightening. Here's a Jewish boy helping
send the Jews to the death camps.”
In order to escape the Nazi death camps, Soros posed as
a Christian, and was taken in by the Baumbachs, a righteous
Gentile family. His adopted father was ordered to take
the inventory of Mor Kornfeld, a wealthy Jewish aristocrat
who had since left for Lisbon with his family. Rather than
leave the boy behind in Budapest for three days, Baumbach
took Soros with him to the Kornfeld estate.
Those who monitor Beck on a regular basis know that his
rants are consistently offensive and over the top. He crafts
conspiracy theories involving left-leaning figures such
as Soros, whom Beck has dubbed the “progressive puppet master.”
He vilifies people such as Nancy Pelosi and Van Jones, and
progressive groups such as the Tides Foundation and ACLU.
Beck has compared people such as Simon Greer, executive director of Jewish Funds For Justice, to the Nazis. Beck equates
social justice with communism and, no surprise, Nazism. And apparently Beck’s rhetoric has
inspired some of his viewers, perhaps even more unstable
and unhinged than he, to threaten public officials and conspire to commit acts of violence against Beck’s targets, including murder.
Without question, Beck has a Nazi fetish. As Dana Milbank
of the Washington Post noted, from the time of Obama’s inauguration
through June of this year, Beck mentioned Nazi or Nazism
202 times, fascism or fascist 193 times, Hitler 147 times,
and Joseph Goebbels 24 times. Not unlike the virulently
homophobic politician or pastor who is caught with a male
escort, perhaps Beck’s obsession with Nazis reflects a hypocritical
admiration for them. After all, he has hosted white supremacists, secessionists and defenders of slavery on his program. On his Twitter page, he listed a white supremacist website as among his favorites.
Beck’s latest hit job on George Soros is classic anti-Semitism,
and is disturbing for a number of reasons. For one, he
chose the 72nd anniversary of Kristallnacht—the infamous pogrom against Jews
throughout Nazi Germany—to make his comments. During Kristallnacht,
which means “Night of Broken Glass,” mobs of storm trooper
thugs destroyed 7,000 Jewish businesses, burned over 900
synagogues to the ground, and murdered 91 Jews. 30,000
Jewish men were shipped to concentration camps. Announced
by Nazi Propaganda Minister Goebbels, this pogrom laid the
groundwork for Germany’s decision to remove Jews from public
life.
Further, Beck’s depiction of Soros as an enabler of Nazi
murder represents a classic example of anti-Semitism and
Holocaust revisionism. And the “puppet master” analogy
is a variation on the “Jewish conspiracy” theme, the Jew
as usurer and villain. In Beck’s twisted mind, Soros is
Shylock the ruthless moneylender in Shakespeare’s The
Merchant of Venice, or Fagin the Jew in Charles Dickens’
Oliver Twist, a man who deals in stolen goods and
leads a gang of pickpocketing young boys.
Elan Steinberg, vice president of the The American Gathering
of Jewish Holocaust Survivors and Their Descendants, said
that Beck’s charges are “monstrous,” and “go to the
heart of the instrumentalization and trivialization of the
Holocaust.” Abraham Foxman of the Anti-Defamation League (ADL)
said that Beck’s statement was “completely inappropriate
and offensive,” adding that “For a political commentator or entertainer to have the audacity to say, there's
a Jewish boy sending Jews to death camps, that's horrific.
It's totally off limits and over the top.”
But just weeks earlier on October 22, Foxman had written
a letter to Beck, calling him a “friend
of Israel,” and apologizing for an ADL mailer that “inadvertently
misidentified you on a list of celebrities who made anti-Semitic
statements over the past year.” And on October 13, the
ADL presented an award to Rupert Murdoch, Beck’s boss, “for his stalwart support of Israel and his commitment to promoting
respect and speaking out against anti-Semitism.” In his
acceptance speech, Murdoch announced that the most virulent forms of anti-Semitism come from the left, often dressed up as legitimate criticism
of Israel. That day, the ADL released its blacklist of the so-called top 10 anti-Israel
groups in America, all of whom are leftwing civil rights
and human rights groups critical of the occupation of the
Palestinians. On the list is Jewish Voice For Peace— a
progressive Jewish group whose advisors include respected
rabbis in the American Jewish community, and prominent Jewish
Americans such as actor Ed Asner and journalist Naomi Klein.
Old-guard Jewish organizations such as the ADL and AIPAC
have entered into a marriage of convenience with the American
conservative movement, thereby enabling anti-Semites like
Glenn Beck. That marriage has turned into a Faustian bargain.
The ADL and others court the Christian Right for their so-called
“pro-Israel” stand, although evangelical support for Israel
is based on the belief that all Jews will die when Jesus
Christ returns. Critics of Israel’s hard-right, ultra-Orthodox
coalition government— including anti-occupation and pro-Palestinian
rights groups— are branded as “anti-Semites.” Progressive
pro-Israel, pro-peace Jewish groups such as J Street are
branded as self-haters. Shutting down debate stalls the
peace process and undermines everyone, including American
Jews, the Israelis and the Palestinians.
Meanwhile, Fox News holds onto Beck as its useful idiot,
albeit a dangerous one. Fox is a wholly-owned subsidiary
of the Republican Party, or vice versa. It is no secret
that Murdoch has given truckloads of money to the GOP, and
that Fox is the official Tea Party network. And it is no
secret that as Beck pimped the legacy of Martin Luther King,
he also partnered with the Tea Party corporate front group
FreedomWorks to elect extremist-right candidates.
All of us should be concerned about Glenn Beck’s verbal
assault on George Soros and his mocking of the Holocaust.
Yet, this is more than a Jewish issue. We live in a time
of scapegoats, the “other,” including Muslims, Arabs, Latino
immigrants, and the LGBT community. Hard economic times
do that to “civilized” societies. People need someone,
anyone to blame for their misfortunes. And they delude
themselves into believing that once the “other” is eliminated,
their problems will disappear.
Kristallnacht was the culmination of a campaign
of racist rhetoric against a group of people. This led
to full-scale violence against that group, and laws designed
to bring about their civil and physical death. The Glenn
Becks in a given society are the propagandists that get
the process going. They soften up the public through media
manipulation, and make their audience receptive to the persecution
of others.
So, how long will Glenn Beck last? Certainly, he is important
to Fox News as their money-maker, their rising star. But
one should remember that when stars turn into black holes,
they can destroy everything in their path, even light.
With a successful boycott effort causing Beck’s sponsors to drop
like flies, we must ask if this latest chapter will prove
to be his undoing.
BlackCommentator.com Executive Editor, David A. Love, JD is a journalist and human rights
advocate based in Philadelphia, and a contributor to The Huffington Post, theGrio, The Progressive Media Project, McClatchy-Tribune News Service, In These Times and Philadelphia Independent Media Center. He
also blogs at davidalove.com, NewsOne, Daily Kos, and Open Salon. Click here to contact Mr. Love.
|