Some
may wonder what the federal estate tax has to do with the
struggles of African-Americans and other people of color.
By curbing the transfer of unlimited wealth from generation
to generation, a strong estate tax is an important tool
in closing the racial wealth divide and ensuring every generation,
regardless of race and family background, has a fair chance
at creating a decent life for themselves.
Communities of color have fought hard
and made positive strides in closing the income gap, but
we still have a long way to go. African-Americans now earn
62 cents for every dollar of white income. Latinos earn
68 cents. Amidst the Great Recession, the unemployment rate
for African-Americans continues to hold above 15% compared
to an unemployment rate of under 9% for whites. Poverty
rates also vary widely.
Dismal as these numbers are, the disparities
of real net wealth are even more shocking. African-Americans
have only 10 cents of net wealth for every dollar of white
net wealth. Latinos have 12 cents. The gap widens at the
top where whites are 34 times as likely than African-Americans
to have enough wealth – $3.5 million or more – to pay the
federal estate tax under 2009 law. While the vast majority
of whites have nowhere near enough wealth to pay the estate
tax, those that do are part of a very white club.
It’s fairly clear why wealth disparities
are so much greater than disparities of income. Unlike income,
wealth transfers from generation to generation. As a result,
when we look at wealth disparities, we’re not only looking
at the injustices and inequalities of today, but we’re also
looking at the injustices and inequalities of previous generations
carried forward with interest.
Much
of the wealth held in white communities is wealth that was
accumulated over several generations, including periods
of time when African-Americans were still owned as slaves,
segregated under Jim Crow laws, redlined into poor neighborhoods,
or otherwise denied the opportunities that whites have.
In fact, this wealth was often times created on the backs
of African-Americans. Though many of these unjust structures
and policies are gone, the economic inequalities they helped
create are carried forward through the power of inheritance.
In struggles against oppression around
the globe, people have long recognized that political liberation
is only a part of the struggle. Political liberation must
be accompanied by economic liberation and the correcting
of past injustices. In nations across the Global South,
land redistribution and nationalization were used in the
years following colonial rule. When the Civil War came to
an end here in America, there was a promise of 40 acres
and a mule – a promise that was, of course, not kept. Many
advocates continue the struggle for African American Reparations.
African-Americans are not the only communities
of color suffering. Native Americans have had their land
taken from them, their populations decimated, and worse.
Latinos and new immigrants are driven across borders by
the structural adjustment policies of the World Bank, that
have enriched global corporations while creating massive
poverty across Latin America and other developing nations.
Before the end of the year, Congress will
be voting on whether or not to make the federal estate tax
permanent, and if so, how strong it will be. A strong estate
tax is essential to closing the persistent racial wealth
divide. It is the only thing curbing the transfer of yesterday’s
inequality to the next generation.
While
a strong estate tax helps to curb the extreme wealth at
the top, we must also fight to ensure that federal funds
are used in a way that lifts up struggling communities,
especially communities of color. Federal job creation programs
should be targeted to communities hardest hit by the Great
Recession. Adequate funding must be made available for foreclosure
prevention programs and assistance. These are essential
ingredients of a public policy program that will enable
communities of color, along with working class white allies,
to acquire and keep wealth.
Let us not miss the opportunity before
us. Congress is coming back into session soon, and near
the top of their agenda is action on the expiring Bush tax
cuts and the estate tax. We should ensure that the Bush
tax cuts for the wealthy are ended and that we have the
strongest estate tax we can get going forward. The time
to act is now.
BlackCommentator.com
Guest Commentators: Ajamu Dillahunt is a board member of
United for a Fair Economy (UFE) and an outreach coordinator
with the North
Carolina Justice Center. Brian Miller is executive director
of UFE. Dillahunt and Miller are co-authors of UFE’s State
of the Dream 2010 report entitled, “Drained – Jobless
and Foreclosed in Communities of Color”. Click here
to contact the authors.
|