To
believe that racism has been eradicated from most of America,
one also would have to believe that Dick Cheney found weapons
of mass destruction in Iraq.
Unfortunately,
there are plenty who believe that discrimination, prejudice,
and racism have been eradicated from the nation, especially
since the American people elected a black man as their president
a couple of years ago.
Then
comes the case of Shirley Sherrod and her short tenure as
the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s point person in Georgia,
the first black Georgian to hold the position and a point
of pride for the organization she served for two decades,
the Federation of Southern Cooperatives/Land Assistance
Fund.
The
federation’s objective is to improve the lives and standard
of living of rural people all across the south. They do
this by finding markets for farmers’ goods, by improving
housing, by improving education, by guiding farmers through
the government credit maze, and by teaching and organizing
rural people to do for themselves the things that make life
better.
That’s
what Shirley Sherrod had been doing since 1985 for the federation,
and she did it well. Ralph Paige, the federation’s executive
director, said when Sherrod was appointed by the USDA a
year ago, “There is probably no one in the state who understands
the challenges faced by rural communities as well as Shirley.
In fact, under her leadership and creative initiatives she
has been instrumental in vastly increasing opportunities
and income for farmers and rural communities.”
By
now, everyone in America knows her story, but, just in case
there are a few who don’t: She made a speech before the
NAACP in which she described her near reluctance to help
white farmers as strongly as she helped black farmers. But
she came to realize that it was a question not of black
and white, but of poor rural people against the powers arrayed
against them - mostly for acquisition of the land they occupied.
Right-wing blogger Andrew Breitbart got hold of a video
of the speech, edited it to his liking, and put up only
the first part for Internet consumption, as if she were
making a confession about something of which she is still
guilty, instead of letting her reveal the epiphany that
she underwent in her work for the federation.
Breitbart has taken the credit for destroying
ACORN, when he doctored secretly-made video tapes of a fake
prostitute and her pimp, asking for advice about how to
conduct their business, as if that was the routine work
of ACORN, one of the most effective organizing groups in
minority and poor communities around the country.
That
video, too, went viral on the Internet and resulted in the
dissolution of the group into its constituent parts, when
it survived at all. The group was the victim of the powers-that-be
(even those masquerading as liberal), literally jumping
to the tune of America’s
right wing.
Sherrod’s
resignation was virtually immediately demanded by Secretary
of Agriculture Tom Vilsack and she complied. Then, when
it was discovered that the tape had been edited by Breitbart,
for whom the truth is a stranger, there were apologies all
around and there was talk of giving her, her job back, possibly
even a promotion. So far, there has been no return to the
USDA.
In
all of the coverage, there has been little mention of the
Federation of Southern Cooperatives and why they have to
do what they do. The federation and other similar groups
have been working for decades to try to fill in the gaps
created by the inability or unwillingness of the government
at various levels to ensure that poor farmers, engaged in
small-farm agriculture, can survive. This work has been
in the face of extreme pressure for them to sell their land
to developers and to food factories that raise chickens
by the millions and hogs by the tens of thousands.
For
the most part, big money won and hundreds of thousands of
black farmers and thousands of other farmers have been forced
to lose their farms. But, for black farmers, the failures
of government - including the judiciary - have been the
result of a culture of racism that existed all across the
south for decades or even generations. In the past two decades,
in an effort to remedy and compensate them for what was
clearly discrimination and bias at the local level (and
these were mostly white representatives of the USDA at the
county level), black farmers brought a massive lawsuit against
the USDA.
From
the early 1990s, an effort was made to get a settlement
and, in the late 1990s, the Clinton Administration, admitting
to USDA’s routine bias, reached a settlement, but it was
far from equitable, considering how much in debt many of
the farmers were and how many farmers were left out of any
settlement.
President
Obama added an additional $1.15 billion to the federal budget
to add to the settlement this year, but that money has been
stripped out of the budget by those who want to know first
where the feds will get the money. Once again, the remaining
black farmers (many are now deceased) are in financial limbo.
This
problem has been the result of what amounts to an extension
of Jim Crow across the south, at least in the rural areas
and it has continued right into the 1990s. A case could
be made that there has been an attempt by some to extend
the legacy of slavery and America’s
shameful, long period of apartheid well into the 21st Century.
It’s clear that this is not the case for most Americans,
but it is for some and, unfortunately, many of the latter
are not very powerful.
This
is the context of the Sherrod story and her work in Georgia. These issues are not resolved and they
won’t be solved so easily, despite the progress that has
been made since the last great civil rights movement in
the 1960s. Her
case is proof of that. The fear of the right wing by a centrist
president such as Obama is starkly clear. The Democrats
stand equally in fear of the right-wing propaganda machine.
Even
when the white farm couple, whose farm Shirley Sherrod saved,
spoke so strongly in her defense, there was not much comment
by Democrats in Congress or anywhere else in her defense
against the Republicans and their right-wing counterparts.
Roger Spooner, the white farmer, told CNN, there was “(n)o
way in the world” that Sherrod was a racist, as charged
by Brietbart and others.
The
fearfulness displayed by the center and center-left elements
of elected officialdom in the federal government was on
grand display in the case of Shirley Sherrod, and we’re
still waiting for the other shoe to drop - will another,
better job be offered by Vilsack and would she take such
an offer?
Village
loses its mayor
In
another recent case, the Village of Cobleskill in the Mohawk
Valley of New York saw its mayor resign in the past week
for a racially charged comment he made in reference to the
“Change” (He said it meant, “Come help a nigger get elected.”)
slogan President Barack Obama used during his election campaign.
Unfortunately
for Mayor Mark Nadeau, another official, highway superintendent
Tom Fissell, recorded the conversation and made it public.
Fissell also recorded a conversation with another official,
Cobleskill Town Supervisor, Tom Murray, and made that public.
Both used the word “nigger” and were caught on tape.
The
firestorm of protest and demands for resignations were surprising
to some of the (overwhelmingly white) residents of the rural
farming community. After several days, Nadeau resigned,
but, as of this week, Murray had not.
In
many ways, the outcry against the use of such language,
especially by elected officials who exert considerable power
even in a small community like Cobleskill, was heartening,
but it shows how far we have to go in discussing the issue
of race in America.
For
a long time, the north was referred to as “up south” by
many who actually experienced Jim Crow. And, those who live
in the north need to understand what “up south” means, before
taking a self-righteous attitude about race in America. No matter how much
progress the nation has made since the mid-1960s, discrimination
and racism continue to exist.
The
response of the people was justified, but they missed an
opportunity to bring the issue more clearly into focus.
They could have used the incident to set up a wide-ranging
village program to learn more about African-American history,
Native American history, and being more tolerant and accepting
of one another and our differences.
On
the other hand, maybe the resignation of the mayor was lesson
enough, for now.
BlackCommentator.com
Columnist, John Funiciello,
is a labor organizer and former union organizer. His union
work started when he became a local president of The Newspaper
Guild in the early 1970s. He was a reporter for 14 years
for newspapers in New York State. In
addition to labor work, he is organizing family farmers
as they struggle to stay on the land under enormous pressure
from factory food producers and land developers. Click here
to contact Mr. Funiciello. |