April 3, 2008 - Issue
271 |
||
Candidates’
Fear and Reporters’ Scripts: The DA Race in By Daniel N. White B |
||
It's
election season again, and campaign news stories time again, too. There's
one race in my parts I'm paying attention to, even if the news crowd isn't,
and that's the local DA race here in Travis County (Austin), Texas. The
previous DA of 30 years is retiring, and there was a four-way contest
of current I used to think that
bureaucracies existed in a world that was beyond influencing by ordinary
human beings, but I've since changed my mind some. I now think that most
but the giant bureaucracies are to a fair degree under the influence of
the personality of the person at the top, if that person is doing their
job right, and not just warming a chair. That's particularly true of an
office such as the DA, which isn't too big an agency in a town the size
of Political campaigns
and campaign events are, once the novelty of them wears off, pretty dull
and predictable. After watching them for a while mostly all follow the
same sort of predictable scripts as bad TV shows. There are no new plot
twists in sitcoms and there isn't much new in political campaign events
either. This set of facts goes a long way in explaining why political
reporting and coverage is as bad as it is. Reporters have seen it all
before, are bored and resent writing political coverage stories more than
Faulkner would have resented writing scripts for Gilligan's A case in point is
the DA's race candidate forums. The first one was held at Gene's Po-Boys,
and it had a lot of attendees from the courthouse crowd. Attendance ran
a little over a hundred. Close and upfront, all four candidates fielded
questions from the audience. The best questions came from ordinary citizens,
not the courthouse lounge lizards. Joe asked why the DA's office wouldn't
extradite from I shot the hard question at them all about the great Travis County Witch Trial of 1992, the Fran's Daycare case, one of the last and ugliest satanic child daycare molestation mania cases that hit this country in the 80's and early '90's. The daycare center's owners are still in the slammer, will be ‘til they die, and most everyone has forgotten them and that decade and a half long mania that put hundreds like them behind bars. We got to see Rosemary Lehmberg fumble the facts on this, her case, and see Gary Cobb's scorn and indifference toward it and me both. Those two obviously go through life without looking in their rearview mirrors. Stephanie asked about evidentiary problems in past cases, and got talked down to and patronized by Gary Cobb - comes with the territory of being female and less than five feet tall, I guess. Watching how the candidates fielded hot questions coming from out of the blue from knowledgeable and articulate citizens was really instructive and revealing of the character of the candidates. None of this was covered by any of the reporters there, and it really should have. But there was an even
better, more revealing event at the next candidate forum, this one at
the Mindy Montford's turn came, and she stood up and said that she'd already given her speech, but that there was a stack of citizen questions there on the desk that didn't get answered, and that she wanted to answer them because that was what's important, not another speech. Her first question was on Joe’s case, and she answered that she had tracked Joe down after the event, gone out to coffee with him later, and had promised him that she would get that criminal back from Atlanta if she had to drive him back from there herself. She was the only candidate who had bothered to meet with Joe on this. Her next question was on the Fran's Daycare case, and she promised to look into it, that the case was before her time at the DA's office but she thought it deserved another look. Mindy Montford stepped up to the plate and batted those questions out of the park. I was as proud as I've ever been for a politician, to see her real concern with ordinary citizens' problems and her deep-seated belief in the democratic process on display and in action. I only wish she had
had a bigger audience to see her presentation, and that the reporters
covering the event would have noted it. None of them did, dammit.
This was a real campaign event. This is what campaigns are supposed to
be about. This is what campaigns are supposed to do and show and tell
us. And if campaigns are hardly ever like that, well the reasons why are
pretty openly on display here. Just look at the [
There appears to be more concern with the length of a reader letter than there is with reporting important details about an important campaign. Candidates fear being blindsided, and reporters follow the script they know. It's a lot easier for both groups this way but it doesn't do the democratic process, or the American republic, any favors. But I'm voting for Mindy this go-round. I'm proud of her. BlackCommentator.com
Guest Commentator, Daniel N. White, has lived in |
||