Dear BC Reader,
Every few weeks, we will present email from the BC Readership, mostly
without editorial comment. This is the Readers’ Corner, where
you can share your views with other readers, whether they are views
of a commentary, general opinions of the site, general comments on the
state of things, or comments on another reader’s email.
We hope you enjoy this new feature.
Thank you for your readership,
Nancy Littlefield, BC Staffer
Regarding: "Crash"
and the Self-Indulgence of White America by Robert Jensen and Robert
Wosnitzer, Think Piece, Issue #176
You made a mistake in presenting the article, "Crash"
and the Self-Indulgence of White America," made worse because
the authors happen to be white. The article rests on faulty analysis,
as well as falsely being presented as a black perspective. Unquestionably,
the US is a (white) racist society but the authors skin the wrong
cat in trying to promote their polemic. In the end this article will
not advance racial understanding; rather it will impede it. – RD
This is just a note to say I gained knowledge, was inspired and
am enjoying reading the stories on your home page. Bravo! – IW
Read your new BC board...tell me, and I'm being VERY serious here,
do you have any idea where you want Black America to go? What if
our only fate in America is destruction as a people, are members
of your new board open to that possibility? If so, can they seriously
discuss that particular issue? And tell me, how many are Xtians?
Does that have a profound and direct bearing on their world view
and socialization? Black America..is there any hope in the White
man's culture? Or are we still stuck on whether this is a white
man's culture? – ST
Congratulations on your board forming best of luck... – JB
I am pleased and heartened by the Black Community's response to
BC's plea to acknowledge the ties of blood.. I knew the depth of
love was always there & will always be. It is so good to see
it out again. We are ONE people. When we forget that, we will die.
Those more aware have a duty to remind the sleepers of the precariousness
of our situation, globally. Another false start on a large scale
& we are finished. Truly! Not one of us has the right to be
self-satisfied. So I salute you. – JH
Congratulations on the new Board – CF
I agree that the role of the United States is pivotal. The administration
needs to exert as much influence in putting together an international
alliance with respect to human rights abuses and genocide in Africa
as we put together in going into Afghanistan and Iraq (but more
effective). On the other hand, I would like to read about China's
role in the Security Council in thwarting effective resolutions
of the Security Council in dealing with the Darfur genocide. A recent
issue of the New York Times magazine explored this role. – LW
I was looking for the quote from Walter White.
“...I was gripped by the knowledge of my identity, and in the depths
of my soul I was vaguely aware that I was glad of it. I was sick
with loathing for the hatred which had flared before me that night
and come so close to making me a killer; but I was glad I was not
one of those who hated; I was glad I was not one of those made sick
and murderous by pride.”
Thanks for being the great resource that you are.
– JL
Regarding: BC website design, and a comment on Harold Ford
I just wanted to let some one know I love the site. Very good article
content and layout. I am a Web Design major student right now so,
when I look at web sites now it's in a whole new light. Also, to
touch on Harold Ford, Jr. and as a Tennessee citizen I will NOT
be voting for him. Since, your site is political and social I thought
I'd throw one person's opinion to you. I will not be voting for
him on one fact and one fact only, I do not trust him one bit. He
comes from the longest line of crooked family of politicians I have
ever seen. Being a Tennessean my whole life and living in this beautiful
state, I have had to endure the nightly local news reporting every
year of some terrible, devious wrong doing of the Ford family. I
saw that your site's address was in NJ so, I thought I'd give you
a Tennessean's perspective. I love this site and will add it to
my favorites. – JF
I saw David Swanson finishing up his speech on C-Span. Thanks
for giving him a forum on BlackCommentator. Just makes the boat
a little bigger. If we let these crimes go on unchallenged, we
face the ultimate transformation of the USA into a population who
agrees with everything that the Bush Regime says. The rest of us
will be dead, imprisoned, in slave camps. Fighting the next was--part
of a state of perpetual war--or starving on the streets forming
marauding gangs fighting for the scraps that are tossed out the
windows of the ruling elite, ensconced in their barded wire redoubts.
I recall an episode of the old TV show, "From the Hill",
where a newspaper editor was asked how could the criminals possibly
take over this country, he replied simply" "How? That
is easy. We let them. We sell our country off bit by bit until
our normal state blurs into a state of complete and utter surrender!"
Kind of like the frog in water that is slowly raised to boiling
temperature one degree at a time--until the frog is ready to eat,
but with a smile on his face.
Curiously, "From the Hill", starring a well-known political
activist, Ed Asner, did not have a long run on prime time. It was
canceled shortly after that particular episode, as were other subsequent
programs that dared to probe and question the status quo.
How many now remember a short-lived show starring Josh Brolin that
delved into the "strange bedfellows" atmosphere that endures
in and around the Beltway? Good show---Long gone.
As millions can see, our democracy, touted as sui generis to the
Great Unwashed of the world, is hanging by a thread. Time to get
up off our asses, get active and start restoring our united States
of America. Maybe we will get it right this time. Or closer, anyway.
The Great Unwashed are looking down and wondering... – DG
A great essay by Professor Early. Right on target and historically
accurate about Castro’s role and support of Africa. – DS
Great article you featured as the cover story. Plus, I made you
'site of the week' @ www.afamreport.com
- SH
I find it interesting that an outspoken paper such as
yourselves had no comment in the Julian Bond article. Is this lack
of voice on your part fear or the fact that BC has no stand on homophobia
in the black community? If you are not standing up for a cause you
are sitting down twiddling your thumbs. – DM
I was saddened, shocked and dismayed at Anthony Samad's careless
and reckless accusations in his otherwise highly readable think
piece, "New Orleans a year after Katrina."
Samad's irresponsible characterization of Ray Nagin,
Kathleen Blanco and George Bush as the political equivalents of the
Three Stooges is highly insulting and a blemish on the sensibilities
of all true Americans. I think I speak for all forward thinking, good
hearted citizens of this great country when I call upon Anthony Samad
to issue an apology. Certainly Larry, Curly and Moe deserve better
than that. Whom did they ever harm to deserve such feckless treatment
from any upstanding journalist or journal, electronic or otherwise?
Ray Nagin, Kathleen Blanco and George Bush equate to the Three Stooges
only in their dreams. Come on Tony, cop to it. You went way over the
top on this one. The Three Stooges deserve an apology. – JD
In response to Jeff Cohen's guest article, "What's Wrong with
Calling Bush a Devil", I have a general question. Why is it
that so many of the so-called left in the US feel compelled to judge
Presidente Chavez's speech at the U.N.? Let us ponder, for a moment,
Mr. Cohen's patronizing declaration:
"Let me be clear: Those of us who use facts
instead of rant; reason and argument instead of name-calling and
personal attacks; evidence instead of intimidation and accusations
of disloyalty -- we have the moral authority to tell Hugo Chavez
that his comments were out of line."
His claim of moral authority is an issue for another day. My greater
concern is that Mr. Cohen, a resident, I assume, of the largest
and most harmful nation in the world, feels perfectly comfortable
lecturing the leader of a southern nation (not to mention that nation's
first president of color) about what is and is not "out of
line". Perhaps, it's time for us in the US. and supposed proponents
of progressive politics to not jump on this latest bandwagon of
American moral indignation and instead say, either in full voice
or in a whisper, "Well, if the shoe fits..."
All this makes me think of Malcolm X's analysis
of liberal, white Amerikkka. Something about wolves in sheep’s' clothing?
- TA
I read Jeff Cohen’s piece What’s Wrong with Calling Bush a Devil?
Along with many, many others outside your shores (and I’m sure a
good number within) I have enjoyed reading of Chavez’ denunciation
of your president at the UN, and thought “it’s about time someone
said that”. Don’t get me wrong – I have American friends, have
spent some time living there, and admire the people and the country
in a lot of ways, but there’s a helluva lot to not like, too. Bush
is packed on the top of the latter heap along with his puppetmasters
and corporate thugs.
So, having interpreted Jeff Cohen’s title to mean
there actually is something wrong with calling Bush a devil, I was
kind of expecting to find the question answered. Did I miss it?
It’s not a long piece, after all. No – just a lot of apparently good
reasons for the attack (since the shock jocks never miss a chance
from the other side), followed in the last paragraphs by a piss-weak
claim to the High Moral Ground (“Those of us who use facts instead
of rant; reason and argument instead of name-calling…”). Well, I’m
sorry Jeff, but I disagree. I don’t think Chavez was name-calling.
He was telling it like it really is (admittedly using theatre to it’s
full). I don’t know how you define the devil. But if someone asked
me to, and GWB happened to walk by, I’m pretty sure I’d just say “There!
See that guy? That’s him”. And it wasn’t A devil, was it? Wasn’t
it THE devil he was referring to? – TT
General Comments from BC Readers:
Your propensity to continuously provoke and cajole the readers
of your columns in thinking of the true spirit of unity and community
improvement, calling to task all of the evil-doers (they seem to
multiply daily, don't they) who seek to tear down entire groups
of people based on whatever criteria they decide upon when they
open their black eyes, provides me a constant source of strength
and confidence in not only keeping hope alive but becoming an integral
participant in fighting the hegemonic machine of Amerikkka. I can
only hope the truth you continue to shine the light on is realized
by more of those who seem to resist it the most. Our faith has to
carry those who have none, our commitment has to bolster those who
do not want to work, our unwavering hope for better must be the
torch that burns longer than the enemies, I can only believe these
things can be real. Your words are a tonic, bold and unapologetic,
that more of our populace needs to wake them from the slumber of
brain-numbing TV and mindless Media. Once again thank you for your
incredible intellect, an insight that is fearlessly focused on the
Truth. May the Divine One keep your voice strong and your conscious
clear... – TD
I just heard President Bush give his reason for continuing to 'fight
terrorism.' One thing the President has forgotten is that the world
now knows exactly how compassionate America is concerning its own
people - they observed what our President did during Hurricane Katrina.
The world is watching the United States sanction killing innocent
men, women and children in America. The world responded to the disaster
faster than our own government. How can President Bush cite America
as promoting Freedom when we have demonstrated how we treat our
own citizens. We have terrorist in America (KKK, Ku Klux Klan) and
they are not being targeted--it appears that they are being supported.
In fact, being Black in America is a liability. Police feel justified
in killing Black Americans and in New Orleans, the world saw that
Law Enforcement personnel used guns to prevent people from escaping
the disaster caused by Hurricane Katrina. American people were not
allowed to save themselves. Americans died while the world watched.
Is this the protection the U.S. is offering to the rest of the world?
How can our President claim that the U.S. is the champion of FREEDOM
and FAIR PLAY when American citizens who built this country are
not being treated FAIRLY. All people in America are not being treated
with dignity. When will African Americans be treated with dignity?
When will our children be saved from death in American cities at
the hand of so called 'law enforcement'? When will President Bush
enforce working together in good faith to eliminate racism in America?
- JS"
I just stumbled upon your Website while looking for prison statistics
for black males in America. I have 4 sons, two of which are teens
and I am desperately trying to motivate them to make the most of
every opportunity and be all that they can be. I also want them
to be sober about the world in which we live. Thanks for the information
that you provide here. I will mark it as a favorite in my browser.
– SP
I feel you and other groups should sue and or attack CBS for attempting
to increase racial divides with their new "racially divided"
Survivor. It serves no purpose will only generate more hate. I ask
you and other rights groups to put pressure on CBS and sponsors
of Survivor to right this wrong! Please feel free to pass this on
to anyone you feel will act on it. I have NO PLANS to watch this
show! – DG
I get the emails you send, and I'd like to donate,
but I don't want to use a credit card. Why don't you have Paypal as
a payment option? - LS
(Maybe someone can help us out with this. While Paypal is certainly
convenient, and a fine company, etc., etc., we hesitate to offer Paypal
because of the huge volume of mail we get, supposedly from Paypal,
asking us to log in for one reason or another. Obviously, since we
don’t currently accept Paypal, these emails must be junk. Our problem
is, how will we know legitimate Paypal emails from the junk ones?
We don’t want to open up any of our BC Paid Subscriber data to spammers.
Incidentally, we receive no spam from anyone purporting to be the
company who does our credit card processing. Visit our BC Contributions
Page and BC
Sign-Up Page for other ways to support BC, that don’t involve
credit cards. –NL)
Please send your comments for possible inclusion in this feature
to: [email protected],
Subject: Readers’ Corner
|