White Liberals Allies
Must Demonstrate
Genuine Commitment
This Time Around By Dr. Elwood Watson, PhD "To say that the relationship between Black Americans
and White liberals has been complex and fractious is
understatement. Rabid feelings of anger, glee, disillusion,
disgust, and more have been commonplace within the
frequently fragile and fractured discourse in both groups."
George
Floyd has finally been laid to rest. The brutal and inhumane manner
that he departed this earth was nothing short of abominable. May he
rest in peace. Although, Mr. Floyd is no longer with us, the problems
that led up to his death — racism, racial profiling, police
brutality, and other maladies still remain deeply entrenched in our
presence.
To
say that the relationship between Black Americans and White liberals
has been complex and fractious is an understatement. Rabid feelings
of anger, glee, disillusion, disgust, and more have been commonplace
within the frequently fragile and fractured discourse in both groups.
From
the shakers of colonial America to the abolitionists of the mid-19th
century to early 20th-century leftist radicals to mid-20th-century
progressives to the idealistic white liberals of the modern civil
rights movement of the 1960s to here and now in the year 2020, the
relationship between these two groups has been akin to a roller
coaster: sudden highs, abrupt lows, and occasional stops. This
relationship could best be described as one of political, social, and
cultural ambiguity.
If
there is one thing that can be said about the current moment in time,
it is that it is unquestionably surreal. There is an undeniably
distinctive feeling about the present environment — intensely
so. That is why it is so crucial that genuine White liberals make a
valiant effort to work with those they claim to support in an effort
to move this nation forward.
If
we are being honest, many White liberals have dedicated their time
and energy to issues that have directly impacted Black people (and
sometimes other non-Whites) only when it has personally, politically
and psychologically benefited them. To be sure, there have been a
number of White liberals who have genuinely “practiced what
they preached,” so to speak. These are the White progressives
who have risked their reputations, livelihoods, social status and
personal comfort in an effort to better the often desolate
circumstances that plague many Black and some other non-White
Americans. Unfortunately, however, these men and women have been in
the acute minority.
More
often than not, the rhetoric for racial justice and equality that has
flowed from the mouths of White liberals is just that: rhetorical
exercises in self-congratulations. A self-indulgent manner of priding
themselves on supposedly not harboring the same racially bigoted,
retrograde sentiments and values as their White right-wing
counterparts.
The
fact is that such self-congratulatory behavior is occasionally
misguided. The truthful reality is that many White people who
identify as liberal indeed harbor attitudes that are just as
primitive and condescending as their social and cultural
conservatives counterparts. The difference is that White liberals
tend to adopt a more sophisticated approach in exercising their true
sentiments.
Fractious
relationships between White leftists and Black America is nothing
new. Throughout American history, Black leaders and activists have
made no secret of their disappointment and outright disdain for what
they have perceived as liberal disingenuousness and hypocrisy. From
Martin Luther King Jr.
to Malcom X
to mid-20th-century Black intellectual extraordinaire James Baldwin
to modern CNN commentator Van Jones,
more than a few members of the Black intelligentsia have made their
feelings about White liberals well known and have taken no prisoners
in expressing their searingly, unfiltered critiques. Marcus Garvey
and W.E.B. DuBois made their occasional displeasure of White liberals
known as well.
It
is crucial to note that Black criticism of segments of the White left
by no means indicates that they were avid supporters of
conservatives. Their deep animus toward the political right was well
known. However, the Right made their disdain and hostility toward
Black people and other progressive causes clear, thus right-wing
resistance toward racial, political and social equality came as no
surprise. Rather, it was the transactional behavior of more than a
few White liberals that was so unnerving and disappointing to their
many marginalized and disenfranchised supporters of color.
It
has been the long-standing practice of White liberals to embrace
progressive attitudes and positions when it has been politically
expedient to do so. To put it plainly, if it is politically
advantageous (in the broadest sense of the term) to be liberal in a
given situation, then they act accordingly. Otherwise, they are more
inclined to revert to more socially centrist, conservative, or in
some cases, apolitical behavior. The truth is that some will quickly
align themselves with White Supremacy in a heartbeat. Their behavior
is unreliable to put it mildly.
The
majority usually forfeited the opportunity to be genuinely committed
allies to the disenfranchised and marginalized. As a result, when it
came time for real, demonstrative action, people of color and other
indigenous people were often left to fight arduous battles alone,
abandoned by their supposedly White liberal allies who claimed to
empathize and stand with them in solidarity. It is a sad commentary
to be sure.
History
has demonstrated all too often that when the going gets rough and the
white, right wing backlash monster fiercely flashes it sharply
pierced teeth, too often, so-called White liberal allies recoil in
fear, anxiety, panic, pack up, retreat, keep a low profile and ride
out the storm until things subside. Only managing to emerge when the
next seemingly monumental event arises. Such Houdini, phantom like
antics cannot happen this time around. We are in a moment of
electrifying levels of activism. Not since 1968 (some more dramatic
observers would argue that not since the Civil War) has our nation
been at such a crossroads.
This
time, the zeitgeist feels different. So many White people of so many
education levels, religions, regions of the nation, and walks of life
have taken to the streets with people of other racial and ethnic
groups, peacefully and bravely confronting law enforcement,
legislators, and others to demand that real and consequential
political, social, economic, and legal measures be enacted for the
betterment of all. It is nothing short of awe inspiring and has been
euphoric to say the least.
It
is imperative that this momentum, determination, and resilience
continue. We cannot allow the retrograde, sinister forces of White
backlash, neo-liberalism, White supremacy and other retrograde forces
abort such a grandiose opportunity. Many American citizens seem to be
adhering to the sagacious messages of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr, who
profoundly stated that “injustice anywhere is a threat to
justice everywhere,” and the late, often prophetic Black
feminist and activist Audre Lorde, who said, “The war against
dehumanization is ceaseless.” Indeed, too much is at stake this
time around.
BlackCommentator.com Guest Commentator, Dr. Elwood Watson, PhD is
a Professor of History, African American Studies and Gender Studies. He
is also an author and public speaker. His forthcoming book, Keepin' It Real: Essays on Race in Contemporary America will be published by the University of Chicago Press later this year. Contact Dr.Watson and BC.