A little less than four years ago, the
president tried to get Black votes with the question, "What do
you have to lose?" The coronavirus offers a bleak answer. Trump
was notified of the danger of the pandemic in January, but didn't
begin to address the issue until late February. Hospitals ran short
on supplies like gowns, masks and tests. Governors had to ask, then
plead with the president for ventilators and other supplies. And in
the beginning, the president dismissed the seriousness of the virus,
claiming it would "go away." And after weeks of "staying
in place" and wearing masks, the daily death toll has not yet
stabilized.
Of
course, the Black community, along with Native Americans and Latinos,
are hardest hit because of differences in spatial location, income,
and age. With some of the nonsense Trump has spouted, one might also
think that he is deliberately targeting the Black community for
damage. What do we have to lose? Our jobs or our lives.
Consider
the United States Postal Service (USPS), which has been a staple
employer in the African American community. Back in the day, my mom
used to talk about "Ph.D.s working at the post office,"
because academic employment was scarce and segregated, and the Post
Office paid decently. Many a Black family made it to the middle class
with postal wages. And now the president is declaring war on the
USPS.
Why?
45 has incorrectly said that fees for mailing packages are "too
low," that USPS is subsidizing internet companies (he means
Amazon) with low package fees. But studies have shown that the prices
paid for mailing packages more than cover their actual costs.
Twenty-one percent of the USPS’ roughly 625,000 employees are
African American, and nearly 17 percent are other people of color.
Might this be one of the reasons that 45 keeps lashing out at the
USPS? He says that unless the USPS raises its fees for package
delivery, he will deny the USPS any COVID-19 aid. I'm not suggesting
that his animus toward the USPS in general, and Jeff Bezos and Amazon
in particular, is precisely because so many people of color work for
the Post Office. Still, I do not think that his attitude toward Black
people is unrelated to his ire at the USPS.
What
do we have to lose? Some Black women have found their lives at risk
because of Trump's touting of hydroxychloroquine as a "game-changing"
coronavirus cure. People with lupus also need hydroxychloroquine for
their disease, but Trump's unseemly huckstering a drug that is not
likely to cure the coronavirus has created shortages for
hydroxychloroquine. Black women get lupus twice as frequently as
white women, and we get it younger and with more complications than
white women. Because lupus is more likely to hit Black women at an
earlier age, Black women also risk complications from pregnancy
because of lupus.
Did
Trump enthusiastically embrace hydroxychloroquine because Black women
are more likely to get the disease, and he wanted to punish us? Does
he have investments in hydroxychloroquine–producing companies?
You don't have to believe in conspiracies to recognize the
disproportional impact the shortages of hydroxychloroquine have had
on Black women.
These
impacts of disparate impact are one of the many reasons that race
matters and that data on health, income, employment, wealth, and
other factors must be collected and reported by race. At the same
time, there are too many who resist gathering and reporting data by
race, facetiously claiming we are all "one nation." And the
myth of "one nation" holds if data are not collected.
When
the threat of the coronavirus has receded, perhaps a year or so from
now, we will be able to measure who carried the higher burden of this
coronavirus. But we already know that Black folks are dying, losing
their jobs, or being exposed to the virus because of the jobs they
hold (as an example, Black women are 6 percent of the labor force but
20 percent of medical support staff). We don't need detailed
statistical analysis to conclude that poorer, urban, Black and brown
communities are hardest hit.
What do you have to lose? Your job, and
maybe even your life. The lack of leadership 45 has exhibited during
this pandemic disqualifies him for a second term. And those
disproportionately impacted who choose to vote for 45, choose to vote
against their own interest.
|