The
contest for the 2020 Democratic presidential nomination is rapidly
moving toward its first major test in the February 3rd Iowa
Democratic caucuses. With a dozen candidates still in the race, only
eight are actually running serious campaigns—former Vice
President Joe Biden; former South Bend Mayor Pete Buttigieg; Sens.
Bernie Sanders (D-VT), Amy Klobuchar (D-MN), and Elizabeth Warren
(D-MA); Andrew Yang (former tech executive); Tom Steyer (Billionaire
former hedge fund manager); and Michael Bloomberg (Billionaire media
executive and former Mayor of New York City) who is not participating
in the early primaries.
Several
others are running essentially vanity races: former Gov. Deval
Patrick (D-MA), Congresswoman Tulsi Gabbard (D-HI), former
Congressman John Delaney (D-MD), and Sen. Michael Bennet (D-CO).
Gabbard is also viewed by some as functioning as a troll for Russian
Premier Vladimir Putin as he continues his efforts to disrupt
American elections.
But
a major issue has emerged over the lack of racial diversity among the
remaining candidates after Sens. Kamala Harris (D-CA) and Cory Booker
(D-NJ) and former HUD Secretary Julian Castro exited the race.
Miramar, Florida Mayor Wayne Messam, an African American, was a
candidate on paper only. The diversity issue is important because of
the crucial roles that black, Hispanic, and Asian voters will play in
determining the Democratic nominee and in the presidential election.
There
have been numerous complaints that the lack of ethnic minority
representation is a continuing blind spot within the Democratic Party
which would be unable to prevail in most of its elections at the
local, state, and national levels without substantial support from
its minority base. Democrats were only able to flip the U.S. House
of Representatives in 2018 because of much larger than average
minority turnout.
While
greater minority representation would be significant, in addition to
Andrew Yang who did not qualify for the last Democratic debate, it
should be acknowledged that the ethnic minority candidates who
dropped out of the race never attracted consistently large following
from minority voters. Moreover, their own political records were
rife with anti-minority stances, policies, and practices.
Kamala
Harris was a cop’s cop while serving as San Francisco’s
City Attorney, championing legislation that led to the fining and
jailing of the parents of habitually truant students. In 2010, with
her staff, she knowingly withheld information from the defense
counsels for more than 1,000 defendants in drug and other criminal
cases. She also ignored allegations that crime lab technician,
Deborah Madden, in the police-run crime lab was “…
stealing cocaine that was used as criminal
evidence by prosecutors…”
Harris
also failed to disclose to defense attorneys that police officers
essential to hundreds of cases she had filed had been convicted of
crimes or had been investigated for misconduct.
She
launched her presidential campaign to a huge crowd and much fanfare
in her hometown of Oakland, CA on the MLK Holiday in 2019. After an
early bump in the polls, the aforementioned facts quietly made the
rounds across the country preventing her campaign from gaining
traction. She was never able to attract large numbers African
American women, who are the base of the Democratic Party, despite
being a member of Alpha Kappa Alpha, the largest African American
sorority in the world.
Furthermore,
field research has revealed that she was unable to effectively engage
with attendees at donor gatherings, the candidates’ forum held
by the National Education Association (NEA), or at the “She the
People Presidential Forum” which was tailor-made for her
candidacy. Overwhelmingly comprised of women of color, Elizabeth
Warren made a more compelling case to the group. Harris never caught
fire among blacks or any other Democratic group.
Cory
Booker experienced a similar fate. He began his political career in
1998 as a contender for a Newark, New Jersey City Council seat when
he upset a four-term incumbent, outspending him by10:1. He had the
financial backing of Wall Street financiers, the Koch Bros., Eli
Broad, the Walton family, Betsy DeVos, and their allies. They funded
him through three campaigns for Mayor of Newark and a successful run
for the U.S. Senate.
Booker
was an aggressive supporter of school vouchers and corporate charter
schools, turning Newark into one of the most charter-friendly school
districts in the nation. He savagely attacked teachers and
educational support personnel and worked with former New Jersey
Republican Gov. Chris Christie to substantially reduce their ranks in
Newark and throughout the state.
In
2012, while operating as an Obama surrogate, Booker strongly defended
Mitt Romney and Bain Capital on Sunday’s NBC Meet the Press
news show. During the 2000s, until 2016, he traveled the country
with Betsy DeVos as her minority wingman, extolling the virtues of
school choice while serving on the Board of the American Federation
for Children a school choice advocacy group she founded and funded.
Booker did not pull back until she was appointed U.S. Secretary of
Education as he was preparing to launch a campaign for the 2020
Democratic presidential nomination.
Julian
Castro, the sole Latinx aspirant for the 2020 Democratic presidential
nomination, was never able to garner support from the Latinx or the
larger Democratic base. He also was unable to raise sufficient
funding to effectively introduce and ingratiate himself with his own
or the larger Democratic community. He, Harris, and Booker never
caught on with any part of Democratic base. They were not the best
representatives for ethnic minority diversity. Neither was close to
being Barack Obama, even in communities of their ethnicity.
The
Democratic front runners, Biden, Sanders, Warren, and Butttigieg,
although having led in different polls, have not, to date,
demonstrated the political skills and understanding of the electorate
necessary to defeat President Trump.
Biden
leads the field nationally primarily because of his heavy African
American support as a result of Him serving loyally as President
Obama’s Vice President and the inability of his adversaries to
attract any major support from this group. But any close observance
of his performance so far shows he has lost a step which could be
starkly revealed under the personal and political attacks sure to
come from Trump.
However,
a more troubling concern is his son Hunter, whose drug use, poor
business and life decisions could explode at any time and take down
the Biden campaign. The Trump forces are already preparing a bevy of
vicious attack ads to exploit Hunter’s personal vulnerabilities
of which there are many. But Biden could still win the nomination
but would have difficulty in the general election.
Bernie
Sanders’s socialist rigidity in his far-left positions (e.g.,
Medicare for All {MFA}) will likely keep him from winning the
nomination as he has not expanded his base since 2016. Moreover, his
recent scrum with Elizabeth Warren over whether a woman could win the
presidency hurt him and her almost equally. Warren has also been
wounded by MFA as she has not been able to adequately explain or
defend its costs and is revising her position on the fly.
The
public has become so disenchanted with her “plans for
everything” that she has taken the word—plan-- out of her
vocabulary during the past month. She does not want to explain the
price of any more of her initiatives.
Klobuchar,
like Harris, is a cop’s cop and if she ever rose to become a
serious challenger she would have to clarify her actions as a
prosecutor when minority males were killed in questionable
circumstances during her administration as Hennepin County, MN
Attorney from 1998 to 2006. She will likely be unable to overcome
these incidents and gain black and Latinx support. Former South Bend
Mayor Buttigieg’s dismissive response to a question about the
police killing of South Bend resident Earl Logan, a black male, last
July by an African American woman inflamed the black community.
Those realities doom the Democratic presidential nominations of both.
Billionaire
Tom Steyer, launched and funded a campaign calling for Trump’s
impeachment hoping that he would be propelled to the Democratic
presidential nomination (after stating he would not run for
president). Steyer is trying to make his case using climate change
which did not work for WA Gov. Jay Inslee. And Steyer is not rich
enough to go all in and spend the billions of dollars that would be
needed to have a chance of winning the nomination.
Having
examined the above candidates, the question is: who has the best
chance of defeating Trump in 2020? That individual is Michael
Bloomberg.
Bloomberg
is the most viable Democrat to beat Trump because he understands him,
has a killer instinct, is a moderate-centrist, and willing to make
the necessary political and long-term financial commitments to win
the presidency.
Next
week, we will present a detailed rationale as to why he is the only
announced Democrat who can win the 2020 presidential race.
Note:
This column is the opinion of Dr. Farrell and should not be
considered an endorsement by BlackCommentator.com.
|