The
National Education Association (NEA), perhaps unwittingly or by
design, narrowed the field of 2020 Democratic presidential candidates
at its July 5th Strong Public
Schools 2020 Presidential Forum, in Houston, Texas. The ten
candidates who showed up are now the only ones likely to generate a
significant vote from teachers during the 2020 primaries and
caucuses. The fact that the other contenders could not fit the
assembly of representatives of the nation’s largest teacher
union into their campaign schedules is telling.
Notably
missing was the self-described “foremost advocate for public
education,” Sen. Cory Booker, who was apparently afraid to
face a group that he has regularly savaged throughout his political
career. The NEA’s Badass Teachers Caucus, that has been
consistently vocal against charter and voucher schools, was at the
ready to have Booker answer for his public education sins.
NEA
President Lily Eskelsen Garcia deftly managed the participants by
keeping them on a tight timeline, in sequential order, with three
questions each and not allowing them to exceed their scheduled time
allotment. The presidential attendees mostly gave boilerplate
responses for helping public school teachers—more funding for
students in need, higher teacher salaries, money for school
infrastructure, an end to high stakes testing, an increase in the
number of jobs for education personnel, legislation for gun-free
schools, appointment of a public school teacher and/or educator to
become U.S. Secretary of Education, and other bromides for currying
teachers’ favor. Several also stated that they came from a
teacher family.
Beto
O’ Rourke, a long-term charter school supporter, was courageous
enough to state that public but not corporate charter schools have a
place in the K-12 educational system. He neglected to mention that
his wife, Amy, is one of the leading Texas advocates of both types of
charters. Beto also pandered to black voters by stating that he
would address the opioid crisis in the Cashmere Garden neighborhood
of his former colleague, Houston, Texas African American
Congresswoman Sheila Jackson Lee.
New
York Mayor Bill de Blasio came out swinging against corporate efforts
to privatize public education and for federal de-funding of charter
schools. The most noticeable feature of the meeting was that Sen.
Kamala Harris, fresh off a kickass debate performance against the
favorite, former Vice President Joe Biden, was scheduled to speak
last, allegedly because she was caught up in traffic, a move some
interpreted as the NEA’s implicit endorsement.
The
remainder of the panelists, Sens. Bernie Sanders, Amy Klobuchar and
Elizabeth Warren, Congressman Tim Ryan, former HUD Secretary Julian
Castro, Joe Biden, and Gov. Jan Inslee left no specific impression.
Although Sen. Harris was given a prime opportunity to close out the
session on a high note, her remarks were not particularly inspiring.
Mayor
Pete Buttigieg and Sens. Kirsten Gillibrand and Michael Bennet, who
have previously supported charters, were also notably missing, along
with Congresspersons Tulsi Gabbard and Eric Swalwell (who quit the
race this week), former House member John Delaney, Gov. Steve
Bullock, the author Marianne Williamson, entrepreneur Andrew Yang,
former Congressman Joe Sestak, Miramar Mayor Wayne Messam, and former
Alaska Gov. Mike Gravel, the latter three who are presidential
candidates in name only.
In
the meantime, Biden has apologized for his positive statements about
working with his late segregationist Senate colleagues against busing
for school desegregation before a black audience in Sumter, South
Carolina last Saturday. The problem is that it is nearly two-and-a
half weeks too late. This marks the second time that he has
disavowed a position he has held for numerous years after reversing
his support of the Hyde amendment—which denied federal payment
for abortion services for poor women.
Another
recent gaffe was Biden’s absence at the week-long 25th
Anniversary Essence Festival in New Orleans, this year’s
largest gathering of African American women. Perhaps he was afraid
of a lackluster response after Sen. Harris knocked him out during the
first debate in June. Biden has shown a singularly inability to take
advice from his campaign staff on racial issues and from other black
leaders. The Rev. Al Sharpton earlier gave him numerous
opportunities to offer an apology for his relationships with rabid
Senate racists on his television show, Politics Nation, and
Biden refused.
He
doesn’t seem to be in the moment on racial and social issues
that animate the Democratic base as if he is awakening from a deep
sleep like Rip Van Winkle. So far, Biden doesn’t appear to be
a candidate for these political times. He is running for President
the same way that Hillary Clinton did as if he is owed the position,
especially since he served as Vice President for the nation’s
first African American President. But Biden’s continuing use
of President Obama as a campaign prop is beginning to grate on many
in the Democratic Party, blacks in particular.
In
addition, Democrats are still in disarray as they are increasingly
fighting within. Alexander Ocasio Cortez, Ayanna Pressley, Rashida
Tlaib, and Ilman Omar are at war with House Speaker Nancy Pelosi over
border funding legislation that has been overwhelmingly endorsed by
the Democratic caucus. They wanted more restrictions on use of the
funding by President Trump and her support for other element of their
aggressive, progressive agenda.
Their
agenda is well-intentioned, but they fail to recognize that their
unwillingness to compromise on some of their far left positions
places their more moderate colleagues, who defeated Republican
incumbents, at risk of defeat in 2020. They are the ones responsible
for the Democrats achieving their current majority. AOC, Pressley,
Tlaib, and Omar were elected from deep blue districts which makes
them safe at this point.
Moreover,
AOC’s office has accused moderate Democrats of acting like the
southern Democrats of the 1940s with regard to their treatment of
black and brown children. Their battle with Pelosi and other
Democrats is causing disunity between some of the Democrats’
base groups making it harder for them to unite.
This
is a continuing and growing advantage for Trump forces that, despite
his unorthodox approach to functioning as President, have seen his
overall approval rating rise to its highest level during his term of
office. Irrespective of the odiousness of his actions, when Trump
makes a move, his base and the Republican Party move with him in
lockstep. The Democrats have not demonstrated any such ability to
organize themselves in such a manner.
Trump
is still on track for reelection based on my composite analysis of
all the available quantitative and qualitative data, but Democrats
could change that if they get their political act together.
Billionaire Democratic activist Tom Steyer’s recent entry into
the 2020 presidential race does not help this process.
|