In
his new book, Potential on the Periphery: College Access from the Ground Up,
Omari Scott Simmons, Howard L. Oleck Professor of Business Law
Program at Wake Forest University, provides a unique look at higher
education access that examines key distinctions that often exist
between vulnerable students (e.g., low-income, underrepresented
minority, historically disenfranchised, first generation,
geographically isolated) and their more privileged counterparts when
they attempt to transition from secondary school to college. It
examines the complex challenges that impede higher education
attainment for vulnerable students, highlighting the existence of two
higher education systems: one for the vulnerable and the other for
the privileged.
Higher
education has always been an institution that has evolved over time
often expanding access to a broader portion of the populace. No one
who is astute to the dynamics in higher education can deny that
higher education has undergone
a dramatic change over that past 25 years. These transformations have
manifested themselves in form of:
changing
student demographics;
ongoing
innovation and technological advances;
decreased
state funding;
competition
from for profit colleges;
retention
issues;
continual
increase in cost; and
other
related issues.
While
some of the aforementioned issues affect students from all walks of
life, a number of them acutely impact vulnerable students,
particularly those from lower income backgrounds. This is largely due
to the fact that these students are less likely to receive quality
college selection counseling and more likely to be affected by
decreases in state funding, targeted by for profit institutions, and
sometime struggle to retain the grades and financial wherewithal to
remain in school. In short, they face a plethora of minefields that
can derail these highly talented students as they pursue a bachelor
degree and advanced degrees.
Simmons
makes the compelling case that many talented students from vulnerable
backgrounds flounder between secondary school and college in the
absence of attentive and competent intervention from advisors and
mentors who are aware of their needs and or potential. As a result of
years of witnessing and studying such patterns as co-founder and
director of the Simmons Memorial Foundation (SMF), a grassroots
organization that assists vulnerable students in the highly
competitive college admissions process to garner admission to
selective and resource-rich institutions. Moreover, he is able to
synthesize for a broader audience the larger realm of existing
academic practices, related theories, and public policy. He
skillfully and successfully demonstrates the frequent reasons that
derail vulnerable student academic success among them being a
deficient amount of information about college options, financial
pressures, limited opportunities for social capital acquisition, and
doubts concerning their ability to thrive in elite educational
environments among other challenges. This is discussed in more detail
in chapters two and four.
Throughout
the book, particularly in chapter three, the author provides some
fantastic perspectives gleaned from student interviews. These
perspectives, from both Delaware and North Carolina-based SMF
students, illustrate the complex challenges vulnerable students
navigate when pursuing higher education. For anyone who has a speck
of human compassion, you will cheer at the inspiring success stories
of SMF students, who demonstrate formidable strength as they tower
against considerable adversity, and empathize with them along their
journey.
In
the final chapter of the book, Simmons provides a number of
innovative reforms such as: enhancing the self-standing college
counseling function in public high schools nationwide to help the
most needy students; increasing federal, state, and institutional
need-based aid; establishing partnerships between college access
organizations, high schools, and selective colleges; exposing
vulnerable students to mentors and career opportunities; and creating
a national online course for college admissions.
One
particularly strong feature of Potential
at the Periphery,
is that Simmons is adept at assembling comprehensive and often
tedious research into lucid and accessible reading. The book is one
of a number that promote the standard (largely true) argument that
there are more than
a few diamonds in the rough
who, if given appropriate attention and resources, can flourish and
excel. Beyond identifying challenges, it offers provocative and
intelligent reforms that deserve serious thought and consideration,
if not immediate implementation.
Potential
on the Periphery: College Access from the Ground Up,
provides an impressive playbook for modern policy and practice
surrounding college access that is both traditional and avant-garde
in nature. It is a deeply informative, lucidly written book that is a
valuable and needed resource complimenting a growing collection of
books that discuss college access and its connection to the broader
issue of inequality.
|