(CNN)
The
blackface scandal that has ensnared three of Virginia's top officials
provides an opportunity for America to address its long legacy of
racism. There's a danger, though, that this teachable moment will be
lost.
When
racism is rendered a historic artifact rather than a present-day
reality -- or becomes a matter of individual bad actors apologizing
for their racist behavior — society is let off the hook. As a
result, we are not forced to grapple with the systemic discrimination
in laws, policies and practices in which we all participate, and with
larger issues of institutional racism that exist in employment,
criminal justice and other aspects of American life.
For
example, the racial
wealth gap
is widening due to structural
racial inequities,
not because some people do not work as hard as others. Banks targeted
black and Latino homeowners with predatory
lending
and subprime mortgages, resulting in historic
losses
of black
wealth
with the Great
Recession.
In
a 2018 study, Duke
University researchers
suggest these economic inequities, which amount to a financial
penalty incurred against black people, require reparations
to overcome the gap. A bill
in Congress,
sponsored by Rep. Sheila Jackson Lee, D-Texas, would call on a
government study on reparations for slavery to determine the best way
to repair some of the damage to the African-American community from
slavery.
Yet
these are not the questions that come to mind when a blackface
scandal surfaces.
Bottom
of Form
Virginia
Gov.
Ralph Northam
has faced calls for his resignation after allegations he dressed in
blackface for a 1984 medical school yearbook photo, alongside someone
dressed in Ku Klux Klan attire. Northam apologized for the photo,
then later denied he posed for it -- but admitted to putting on
blackface on another occasion to imitate Michael Jackson.
Further
muddying the waters for himself, Northam, who refuses to resign,
said, in a CBS interview with Gayle King, that he had overreacted
with his initial apology. He said his advisers suggested he read Alex
Haley's novel "Roots"
to make amends, and he referred to African slaves as
"indentured servants."
Later, after a backlash, Northam released a statement
saying that a historian once told him it was more accurate to use the
term "indentured."
This,
as Virginia Attorney General Mark
Herring admitted
to putting on blackface in the 1980s in an homage
to rapper Kurtis Blow, and state Senate Majority Leader Tommy
Norment,
a Republican, was editor of a 1968 college yearbook featuring
blackface and confederate imagery, and racial slurs against blacks,
Jews and Asians.
The
news that Southern white politicians wore blackface in their college
yearbooks does
not particularly faze or startle black people
-- according to a recent Washington Post poll, nearly
60%
of African-Americans didn't think Northam should resign -- because
much of black people's experience has been connected to racially
charged events: police brutality, lynching, segregation, Jim Crow,
civil rights movement, the birther movement, etc.
And
after all, minstrel shows -- a display of racist imagery meant to
dehumanize black people -- where blackface originated, was viewed by
many whites as a form of all-American
fun.
Redemption,
as does resignation, has its place for Northam and other would-be
racial offenders.
Further,
the legacy of slavery and discrimination has cost black people their
lives, as whites and people of color have disparate health outcomes
as a result of a long history of racism in health
care
and bias in the medical
profession.
Doctors
used black people for harmful and unethical medical experimentation,
such as the use of enslaved
black women
for gynecological experiments without anesthesia, and the Tuskegee
syphilis study,
in which the federal government knowingly failed to treat hundreds of
black men with syphilis from 1932 to 1972.
Today,
according to several studies, systemic racism determines whether
doctors administer pain medications to patients based on the
false notion that black people are more resistant to pain.
Black women experience significant delays in cancer diagnosis and do
not receive the same quality of treatment as white women, according
to a 2012
study
from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, and the CDC also
found black mothers are three
to four times more
likely to die during pregnancy or childbirth.
Truly
dealing with these examples of systemic racism requires that many
white Americans have the skill set and tools to discuss and address
racism, discrimination and privilege. This requires an education on
how racism exposes the myth of American meritocracy and the
acknowledgment of the existence of white privilege and its benefits.
That's
not to say that there aren't some who are trying to have these
discussions. Robin
DiAngelo,
a white woman, and author of the book "White Fragility,"
argues that society is designed to protect white people from
discomfort over racism. She concludes white people, particularly
white progressives, are thin-skinned and become defensive when
accused of racism -- unable to face their complicity in white
supremacy, and seeking to attribute racism to evil, mean people who
hate black people.
Part
of avoiding discomfort is the idea of being colorblind
and not seeing race, a notion that is becoming more prevalent
in white America.
Former Starbucks CEO Howard
Schultz
even made the claim during his CNN Town Hall on Tuesday night.
Since
race cannot be "seen," there is very little meaningful
discussion about how it dictates one's experience in America.
And
even if we're going to use blackface as a metric for how far the
nation has come in terms of racism, consider that today, the
tradition continues
on college
campuses
into the present
day with
popular racist "ghetto"
themed parties
and Halloween
parties.
That's hardly being "colorblind."
This
colorblindness means the existing racial injustices and hierarchies
go unchallenged, and white people are seemingly left without racial
competency and a positive racial consciousness, unprepared to play a
role in a diverse and inclusive America.
Meanwhile,
there was the election of Donald Trump, whose message of nationalism
only served as salt in the festering, unaddressed putrid wounds.
Since his election, voting
rights and
civil rights have been increasingly under attack, hate
crimes
are on the rise, migrant children are separated
from their families and placed in detention centers, and white
nationalism
is mainstreamed.
Schools,
media and the greater society reinforce the problem. US history --
including the genocide
of millions of Native Americans and
the enslavement of millions of Africans -- is not
properly taught
in many schools, and civil rights and black
history
are seemingly viewed as matters for only black people to know about.
Yet black individuals such as Colin Kaepernick who shine a light on
injustice and engage in peaceful protests are vilified and
ostracized, and painted as troublemakers.
We
need more individuals like Liam
Holmes,
10, who took a knee against racial discrimination during the Pledge
of Allegiance at a Durham, North Carolina, City Council meeting. The
Cub Scout, who is white and comes from a Quaker family, said he
discussed racial inequality with his father before the meeting, and
made the decision to kneel with support and without pressure. "What
I did was took a knee against racial discrimination, which is
basically what (sic) people are mean to other people of different
colors," Holmes said.
Some
suggest America needs a national conversation for racial harmony to
move past the Confederate "lost cause"
narrative — a revisionist account that glorifies and justifies
the role of the South in the Civil War and downplays the role of
slavery -- and a truth
and reconciliation commission
similar to what South Africa used to address its own racist history.
Such a commission would involve public hearings that acknowledge the
racial abuses, violence and inequality that have taken place, address
the racial divisions and develop solutions to begin the process of
healing. "In a racist society it is not enough to be nonracist.
We must be anti-racist," as Angela
Davis
once said, providing a glimpse into where America must go.
Ali
Michael,
an anti-racism facilitator with the workshop Race Institute for K-12
Educators, suggests white people must begin to have hard
talks about racism
without people of color present, to have honest discussions among
themselves, to confront their privilege and become effective allies
against racism.
Until
this is done, apologies and resignations for racist misdeeds have
their place but are empty without a full-fledged attack on
institutional racism -- the policies and laws written in the spirit
of those offensive symbols.
This
commentary was originally published by CNN.com
|