In light of the foregoing evidence,
Thomas Jefferson was either l
ying or deluding himself when he
told Congress in his Sixth Annual
Message in 1806 that Indians were
placing their interests under
the patronage of the United States
because they were inspired by
‘our justice and in the
sincere concern we feel for their welfare.’
Robert J. Miller, Native America, Discovered and Conquered:
Thomas Jefferson, Lewis and Clark, and Manifest Destiny
They
do not know how their slaves endured, nor how they
endure,
nor do they know what their slaves know about
them—they
do not dare to know it: and what they dare not
know
about Little Black Sambo is precisely what they do not
dare
to know about the world by which they are surrounded.
James
Baldwin, “Chapter Two,” The Devil Finds Work
Many
years ago, in one of my English composition classes, I taught
chapters from Barbara Ehrenreich’s Global Woman: Nannies, Maids, and Sex Workers in the New Economy, the
work she co-wrote with Arlie Russell Hochschild. Of course I read the
bestseller, Nicked and Dimed. In
fact, I’ve tried to keep up with any and everything this author
has written.
So Ehrenreich’s Natural Causes: An Epidemic of Wellness, the Certainty of Dying, and Killing Ourselves to Live Longer is a
bit of a depart for me. But not quite. Ehrenreich is a cancer
survivor, and I have cancer. Ehrenreich is a straight shooter, and I
don’t read self-help books. And Natural Causes, for
the most part, is informative. But while reading the next to the last
chapter, “The Invention of the Self,” I found myself
suddenly pushed off to the side of the book in hand. A seismic shift,
for sure. Here were passages no longer as gripping as previous
passages on macrophages. (Ehrenreich holds a PhD in immunology).
Macrophages,
Ehrenreich argues, were thought to be our friends, thought to be the
ones helping to save our lives. Until they were found out: discovered
to be working with the enemy within, actually “encouraging the
growth and spread of tumors.” Ultimately becoming the
“frontline killers in autoimmune diseases.” Macrophages
betrayed us, in other words.
But
then the discussion turns to death. Humans, animals, plants,
everything dies. So when an individual thinks of death, writes
Ehrenreich, she thinks of a world without her. In
fairness, Ehrenreich quotes philosopher Robert C. Solomon who writes,
“we approach death with the self-indulgent thought that my
death is a bad thing because it deprives the universe of
me.” Wow. Well, I’m
thrown back to many hours I have spent suffering through
philosophical texts written mostly by males, white males, who’s
“we” usually looks like them and the Founding Fathers
who’s “we” also looked like them: racialized and
gendered. White and male.
Deprives the universe of me! My
death!
Ehrenreich
writes that 55 million die yearly and the world continues on. “Quite
nicely,” she adds.
But
I still needed to pausing in the reading. Where am I, now? Does
Ehrenreich see me and the majority of the world—people of
color—who are so various. We don’t all think about death
or any subject as do white Westerners.
And
in the end, I don’t want to space out on psychedelic drugs
either. With all that is happening, people of color around the world,
need to be alert. Eyes wide open. See it all.
In
the meantime, so many white Americans prefer blind spots.
A
few months ago, National Public Radio (NPR) Scott Simon asks
Americans if they still believe America is what Ronald Reagan called
“a shining city on a hill.” Some of us could answer this
question, rather bluntly, but Simon’s not asking us.
I’ll catch the news at
NPR, however, I know I’m not a preferred audience
member. The audience Simon’s question identifies as faithful
listeners—those who identify with Reagan without being troubled
by where and why he announced his candidacy for president in
Philadelphia, Mississippi—probably miss the “great”
man today. His “law and order” agenda was good for
American. And that’s what made him “great.”
Apparently.
Yet,
today, most Americans still believe white supremacy refers to the KKK
or avowed white nationalists who announce themselves as such and
appear in the streets with tiki torches. Those are the bad guys!
White supremacists! Racist! CNN and MSNBC sponsor the appearance of
pundits to argue whether or not Trump is a racist. This late date! As
if the whole of the liberal corporate media is blind to Trump’s
past dismissive, racist comments about blacks, brown, and Indigenous
people since the Trump child became Donald J. Trump.
Racism
is an event: someone calling a black the N-word or the sudden
appearance of a noose at an office were a few blacks work. Racism is
something that is perpetuated by racists. Everyone knows this! Every
one! White supremacy then has nothing to do with the majority of good
Americans, who are not offended by “black” music or who
converse at lunchtime with a Latina co-worker or who accept the black
daughter-in-law.
The
only Americans who want to talk about white supremacy are those
Americans such as the one and only Rep. Steve King, recently posing a
question: what’s wrong with saying white supremacy? White
supremacy exist in the US, so what’s the problem with
identifying with white supremacy?
This
guy stands in for the president and his base shouting for a wall!
This guy flies the Nazi flags, stockpiles high-powered weaponry. This
guy is the only America invested in producing and distributing print
calling for the subordination of people of color, women, and
LGBTQ—again!
Make
America Great Again!
As
individuals or as active hate groups operating in the US such as the
one featured in a PBS
and ProPublica
documentary series, these Americans are to be taken seriously. The
loss of life at the Tree of Life synagogue was no allusion. Dylann
Roof was for real.
So
is former Chicago Police Officer Jason Van Dyke because Laquan
McDonald isn’t among us, is he? And why not?
And
there’s another video gone viral. See the young white high
school students, males, with Make America Great Again (MEGA) hats,
jumping about and shouting. The one sporting the smirky smile eyes
Nathan Phillips, the Indigenous elder,
if as if it’s the Indigenous who is the loser. MEGA suggests
America was great when whites wore blackface to the delight of the
ladies. MEGA suggests America was great when the land, covered as far
the eye could see, with native homes, was torched so inflamed homes
would burn to the ground only to rise once again with new occupants.
So
the white male student who passes a camera speaks about the loss of
land: You lost it! Yeah. That’s how it goes! Since then, he and
his fellow Covington Catholic high school students must have heard
and read the narratives within their curriculum: whites worked hard.
Cultivated the land, even. Civilized the “natives” and
the “Africans.”
The
smirk can’t see the humanity of the elder, the activist, who
has fought most of his life for this land, for mother Earth, for all
life. Did you see that?
National
Public Radio, (NPR), makes a decision to talk to an “expert”
about camera angles. The incident, in other words, has nothing to do
with racism, and so the expert” who never mentions the word
“racism,” asks that listeners listen carefully to the
spin on this latest rearing of racism’s head: It’s all
about angles. Where the camera is placed. In front of the student or
in front of the Indigenous protester. It’s about angles, folks.
Good folks! If you see it from this angle or from that angle…
And,
you know, for most of us people of color, who stand and have stood
where Phillips stood, and who are forced to hear the account of what
happened to us—it’s all about distraction. Talk about
“camera angles” and the listener will envision the
innocence of the young white man. Keep the listener, philanthropists,
and the advertisers happy. Change the subject so no one needs to
think, let alone ask questions. And the money continues to flow.
Truth be damned!
So
don’t wait for NPR to pose questions to listeners that would
prompt them to stop and think, critically. Do you know, listeners,
these students were brought to Washington D.C. on a bus not to
protest with the
Indigenous activist against the US abuse of land, no? They were
chaperoned by e-d-u-c-a-t-o-r-s! What were the students told in
advance of their arrival at the Lincoln Memorial Mall in Washington
D.C. from Kentucky? What were these young men told they would do once
at the Mall? Would they participate in protests against the
government shutdown affecting so many fellow American citizens?
No,
listeners. Few in the media engaged their audience in a discussion
about why it was considered useful to transport these young people,
in their MEGA hats, to Washington to oppose the right of grown
women to maintain autonomy over
their bodies. Because that is why these male students
were present at the Lincoln Memorial. One hundred plus strong, backed
by the authority of teachers, school administration, the political
organizing of the fundamental
evangelic and Catholic congregations were exercising their right
as whites and males to speak and
be heard, come hell or high water.
See
for a moment what the Indigenous elder Phillips
saw. Understand that the very real fear he felt as he sang and
drummed the prayer song has an historical precedence. Phillips
didn’t stand alone. And neither were these white students who
appeared to identify with America’s willful embrace of
ignorance—even if innocently.
The
young males are moneyed. Not Phillips, right? And Phillips’
prayer? Not a Catholic prayer
to the real deity,
right?
Of
course, the president of the US identifies with any expression of
white supremacy.
Ignore those hats. Ignore their
shouts and jeering. Ignore the smirk of privileged. To be American,
you can only identify with white identity!
I’m
convinced that the most obviously racist stereotype is, nonetheless,
believed by millions of Americans in this, the 21st
Century.
So
few permit themselves to see what Nathan
Phillips
saw that day. Any day.
America
is white, isn’t
it?
|