America
has its own Nakba and it is living in the White House.
The
Nakba, among the Palestinian people is the ethnic cleansing of
Palestine when more than 700,000 Palestinian Arabs fled their homes
and villages in 1948 or were forced out at gunpoint, in preparation
for the founding of the State of Israel. People were told that the
displacement would be temporary and that they would be able to return
when it was “safe.”
During
the war of that year, 400-600 Palestinian villages were sacked and
urban Palestine was nearly erased from the earth. It is 70 years
later and generations of Palestinians have been born without ever
having seen their former homes, which they never relinquished.
Israel took the land and has been taking pieces of the land that was
to have been given back for a Palestinian homeland. In the worst
example of the taking is the West Bank, where Jewish settlements over
decades have inexorably taken land that was not theirs, piece by
piece.
Nakba
is Arabic for “catastrophe,” and that's what Palestinians
have suffered over the decades, near their homes and villages, but
not allowed to return as promised. In the recent Gaza massacre by
the Israel Defense Force, where dozens were purposefully killed by
Israeli snipers and hundreds were wounded by live ammunition, the
Palestinians were demonstrating by the thousands that they demand to
be able to return to their homes. They were carefully gunned down by
heavily armed snipers, often at a great distance, even though the
overwhelming majority reportedly were unarmed. Unless, of course,
one considered kites bearing Molotov cocktails that were flown over
Israeli territory from Gaza were weapons. The disparity in armaments
was laughable, if the result were not so deadly.
Gaza is
unique in the world, in that it is described by human rights experts,
foreign leaders, visitors, and experts in the field of incarceration
as “the world's largest open-air prison.” When it was
supposedly turned over to the Palestinians, there were so many
restrictions applied by Israel that the Gazans really cannot leave.
Palestinians everywhere in and around Israel must get permission from
the government for just about everything, including visits to doctors
and hospitals. Often, permission is given too late and people give
up trying. Prisons are like that.
The
ethnic cleansing was truly a catastrophe and it remains so...a nakba.
The Nakba in the White House is another matter. Trump has brought
the United States to such a low level that hardly anyone recognizes
it for what it once was. The so-called “light of freedom”
that it once was is not recognizable as the America of the Statue of
Liberty and its message. Donald Trump, as president, has done such
damage to the nation that it has become the laughing stock of
nations, especially its fellow “developed” nations. How
could such a person be elected president, they ask, and then they go
about the business of the world without its arguable leader, the most
powerful in the world.
The
Right of Return demonstrations and rallies at the fence that keeps
them in their prison resulted in 60 targeted deaths (including
medics, the press, and children) by snipers, Trump's White House
immediately said it was the fault of Hamas, without knowing if that
was true. One of the great lies involving Israel and the
Palestinians is that “Israel has the right to defend itself,”
as if thrown stones, firebombs thrown by hand, and kites on fire are
any match for Israel's weaponry, some of the most advanced in the
world.
When
the propaganda from the governments of Israel and the U.S. is so
relentless, it's easy for the average persons to believe that most,
if not all, Palestinians are terrorists. Some Israeli officials have
said as much, noting that Palestinian children will only grow up to
be terrorists themselves. So, what if some of them are killed in a
blanket attack. Members of the American press have asked Trump's
official spokespersons about the slaughter of Palestinians. To a
person, they do not answer the question, but simply say that Hamas is
to blame, attributing to Hamas much greater power to organize tens of
thousands to demand the right of return than it actually has.
In much
the same way, Trump's people have responded to questions about his
attack on National Football League (NFL) players, who have knelt
during the playing of the national anthem. Most of those who knelt
are black, exercising their First Amendment rights to protest the
brutality of police against black men and boys, and some women.
Even the American Conservative magazine in mid-May ran a piece by
Daniel Larison, in which he wrote under the headline “The
Trump Administration’s Despicable Response to the Gaza
Massacre”:
We
know that the Trump administration consistently indulges U.S. clients
and encourages them in their worst behavior, but the refusal to hold
Israel accountable for obvious, egregious crimes like this one is
nonetheless breathtaking and despicable. Hamas bears responsibility
for its own crimes and misrule, but it is ludicrous to hold them
responsible when Israeli forces shoot live ammunition into a crowd of
unarmed people. The administration’s attempt to shift the blame
from the government that killed nearly five dozen unarmed protesters
and wounded hundreds more to anyone else is similar to their
responses to Saudi coalition crimes in Yemen: ignore them for as long
as possible, absurdly claim that the client state is acting in
“self-defense,” and when all else fails find some other
group or government to blame for things that the client has done.
Refusing
to hold Israel responsible for its crimes guarantees that there will
be more of them in the weeks and months to come. As long as the
administration doesn’t object to this excessive and illegal
treatment of Palestinians, the Israeli government will assume that it
has Trump’s full support and will keep doing more of the same.
The Trump administration is giving Israel a green light to shoot
Palestinian protesters, and its determination to ensure that there is
“no daylight” between our two governments means that
there is practically nothing that the Israeli government can do that
this administration won’t tolerate.
Across
the political spectrum and across the world there has been
condemnation of the slaughter of Palestinians and the wounding of so
many hundreds more, but that will not stop future slaughters of
people who are demanding what is rightfully theirs, return to their
homes and what were once their villages. It will happen as long as
the likes of Trump officially condone and support such actions.
Like
other administrations, Trump and his top officials have essentially
washed their hands of any responsibility for what has happened and
what is happening in Israel-Gaza-Palestine. In fact, while unarmed
people were being shot by snipers, there was a celebration going on
not many miles away, to observe the move of the U.S. embassy to
Jerusalem, a unilateral decision by Trump, who cares little how his
actions disrupt ongoing diplomacy or whatever order there seems to be
in the world at large. He only knows to do what will bring him the
highest accolades at the moment.
Trump
has shown his contempt for black Americans in any number of ways (his
relentless attack on professional football players), his failure to
address the brutal treatment that has been suffered by black men,
boys, and women at the hands of the police, and the ban against
Muslims' entering the country, to name a few. He has presided over
the destruction of environmental laws and named to be heads of
agencies the very people who formerly pledged to reduce or eliminate
the agencies themselves. He has appointed as head of the Department
of Education a woman whose goal is to privatize as much of public
education as possible. Charter schools, vouchers, and other forms of
privatization have gone a long way toward the return to segregation
of black and white students. While it may be a reflection of
segregation and racism in other aspects of society, it is
particularly damaging in education. Not a word, however, from the
administration.
There
are so many ways Trump has continued the breakdown of democratic
norms that it is too much to list, but there is one thing that he has
done that makes him the Great Nakba in the White House: He has
succeeded in diminishing the credibility of most of the institutions
of society, including the government. He has damned the judiciary
and Congress, he has attacked the nation's own intelligence agencies
at home and abroad, and, probably most egregiously, he has attacked
the free press, which for all its faults, exists to explain to the
people what is being done to them.
While
there are indications that ever-growing numbers of Americans realize
what he has done and intends to continue doing in destroying
institutions, there is a core among voters that he can depend on to
support him, no matter what he does or when he does it. It's why he
resorts to campaign-style rallies of those supporters in various
parts of the country, at which he feeds them the raw meat of contempt
and hatred for “the other”: Immigrants, minorities,
women, wage-workers (particularly their unions), and so many others.
His lies have carried him far and the people generally have shown
that he can and will ignore their need for decent housing, living
wage jobs, and health care for all, and still be allowed to continue
to live in the White House. As ever, it's all about him and the
praise heaped on him by his staff and core supporters. He is truly
the great catastrophe that many feared he would be, after the votes
of 2016 were counted.
|