This
week, one of the biggest tragedies and crimes of a nation against an
oppressed people have been perpetrated by the Israel Defense Force in
recent days against overwhelmingly unarmed Palestinians and the
outcry against it from the mainstream American free press was largely
a moment of silence.
A
friend and former longtime newspaper reporter, like so many political
liberals, also was silent on the murders of the Gaza Palestinians who
were massed at the barrier fence between Gaza and Israel proper,
although he was in favor of President Trump's erratic missile
response in Syria to the film of the gassing of civilians in Syria,
even though many reasonable observers, reporters, and experts in
chemical warfare were unsure of the origin of the attacks.
In
Gaza, viewed widely as the world's largest open air prison, there was
no doubt about the identity of the perpetrators of the wanton killing
of people who, if they were armed, were in possession of rocks and
slings that launched stones at the Israeli troops, who are among the
most well-armed soldiers in the world. The Palestinians have massed
to observe the 70th anniversary of the “Nakba,”
(Arabic for “the catastrophe”), the ethnic cleansing of
their people of what was to become the State of Israel. At the time,
most were assured that they would be given the right of return after
the hostilities.
At
the same time, adding gasoline to an already inflamed situation,
Trump's order that the U.S. embassy be moved to Jerusalem, is his way
of recognizing the sovereignty of the government of Israel to most of
the territory between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea, as
right-wing Israelis contend. He conveniently ignored that Jerusalem
is also the capital of Palestine and is one of the most important
places in the world for Christians.
If
there were any hope for peace between Israel and the Palestinians
(and, for many years, there has been only dwindling hope), Trump and
his vice president, Mike Pence, have scuttled it. Pence by and large
has praised every move that Trump has made, including his dabbling in
Middle East diplomacy, of which he knows little or nothing. This
ignorance is sure to lead to even more turmoil in the region, which
has seen more turmoil than any developing nations need to see in many
lifetimes.
As
is generally known by those who follow the politics of the Middle
East even casually, Gaza was “given back” to the
Palestinians by Israel in 2003, when Ariel Sharon was prime minister,
the action was adopted by the Israeli government in June 2004, and
approved by the Knesset eight months later. In reality, though, it
never was “given back.” Israel and its military have
been virtual prison guards, controlling everything that goes in or
out of the strip. For example, a Palestinian takes his life in his
hands if he so much as goes offshore in a rowboat to fish to feed his
family.
There
is no freedom for Gaza itself and, every once in a while, Israel
finds a reason to “go to war” with Gaza Palestinians and
the result is an even further debasement of the systems that provide
for a minimal standard of living. Schools, hospitals, water and
electric infrastructure have been damaged or destroyed in these
“wars” and very little is reported about these things or
the razing of housing. There is no equivalency in the two sides of
the so-called wars. While it's true that Gazans have launched
rockets into Israel, but they usually are ineffective, although they
keep a small minority of Israelis in a state of fear.
On
the other side, there is one of the most powerful militaries in the
world, supplied by its own weapons industry along with that of the
U.S. There is no equivalence in any dispute or conflict. It's a
boot crushing a gnat. Israelis, referring to the Palestinians, have
said that, every once in a while, they have to “mow the
grass,” to keep Palestinians off guard and their capability of
a response to oppression to a minimum. Clearly, the implication, if
not overt sentiment, the Palestinians are not much more valuable than
blades of grass that need to be shorn regularly. That, they have
been doing.
Much
of the responsibility for Israel's attitude and that of its leaders
is because of the bi-partisan support of American presidents and the
major parties, Republican and Democrat alike. The U.S. carries a
very big stick, the most powerful military on earth capable of
bombing any nation back to the Stone Age. Every world leader knows
that and Trump has made it a regular public point, adding that he is
the one who can launch a strike or start a war as he wishes. In
this, he (and the Congress) is ignoring the constitutional
requirement that Congress is the power to debate and declare war, not
the president alone. For Trump, that's a mere formality and just
small stuff.
Right
now, however, Jewish peace activists are making every effort to stop
the mass killings of unarmed Palestinians. Of the two million
inhabitants of Gaza, tens of thousands are massed at Israel's fence,
demanding the right of return as was promised 70 years ago. Jewish
Voice for Peace, which is vociferously condemned by the Israeli
government and many Jewish leaders in the U.S., said this week,
“...(T)he
catalyst for this nightmare is...us. As Americans, the new embassy
in Jerusalem sends a clear message from the Trump administration: the
Israeli government can do whatever it wants. Snipers, blockades,
legal assaults on basic rights, ongoing expansion - there’s
evidently nothing this administration won’t sign off on. It’s
never been more clear that change in U.S. Israel/Palestine policy is
only going to come from the grassroots.”
While
Israel and U.S. governments of all stripes have called most
Palestinians terrorists, the right of oppressed peoples to attempt to
throw off their oppressors is recognized by the world community in
principles adopted by the United Nations. In the Syrian gas attacks,
there has been no concrete evidence that Assad (whatever kind of
dictator he is) and his government did it. Many experts have viewed
the evidence and declared it unlikely that he did. But, in the
murders of Palestinians who are demanding that they be free of their
oppressors, it is clear that the Israeli military has perpetrated the
massacres and it's likely that they will continue to do so. Don't
expect Trump to order the launch of missiles on strategic Israeli
targets. Neither he, nor any other American politician would so much
as utter a protest, let alone let missiles fly. Look for more
extrajudicial killings of Palestinians who demonstrate. Where's the
outrage?
|