Betsy DeVos Is Scrapping
Civil Rights Enforcement,
Allowing Schools
to
Target Black Children
for
Punishment
"Betsy DeVos has provided financial support to
organizations opposed to affirmative action and
voting rights, such as the Center for Individual
Rights and the Southeastern Legal Foundation,
and other groups who work against women’s reproductive
freedom and LGBTQ rights, according to the ACLU."
U.S.
Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos is shutting down civil rights
investigations and dismissing hundreds of complaints in the name of
efficiency, reflecting a greater effort by the Trump administration
to dismantle civil rights enforcement designed to protect students.
Under
a new policy, the Department of Education’s Office
of Civil Rights
has begun the process of dismissing hundreds of civil rights cases
and allowing department investigators to discard complaints that are
deemed burdensome or are serial complaints.
Under
the department’s new case processing manual (pdf),
the OCR will dismiss a complaint that is “a continuation of a
pattern of complaints previously filed with OCR by an individual or
group against multiple recipients” or “is filed for the
first time against multiple recipients that, viewed as a whole,
places an unreasonable burden on OCR’s resources.” The
manual also eliminates any reference to investigating “systemic
issues,” and prohibits the processing of any complaints
containing “written information that relies exclusively on
statistical data, media reports, journals/studies, and/or other
published articles as the basis for the alleged discrimination.”
Under
the new guidelines, the Department of Education has thrown out more
than 500 cases.
As
ProPublica and Mother Jones reported,
this rollback in civil rights investigations allows school districts
to engage in racial discrimination in their discipline policies, in a
quiet but decisive departure from the Obama administration. Under
Obama, the Department of Education received 1,500 complaints
regarding racial discrimination in school disciplining from 2011 to
2017. During that period, the department engaged in broad
investigations into racial disparities in discipline — in small
and large school districts alike — employing the concept of
disparate impact.
Under
disparate impact, unequal treatment of people based on race amounts
to discrimination regardless of intentional or overt bias. DeVos and
her officials have asserted that the Obama-era rules on disparate
impact amount to “racial
quotas”
in school suspensions and “race-based decisions,” and
suggest disparate impact is legally problematic. The head of the
Office of Civil Rights, Candice Jackson, is a white woman who once
claimed she was discriminated against for being white. She has
praised an economist who called the Civil Rights Act of 1964
“monstrous” and “the source of all the rest of the
ills.”
DeVos
has faced criticism for the administration’s anti-civil rights
policies. In 2017 she was met with boos and turned backs from
graduating students at the historically Black Bethune-Cookman
University in Florida as she gave the school’s commencement
address:
The
Department of Education has closed at least 65 school discipline
cases initiated under Obama. One of those cases was in Bryan, Texas,
where Black students were nearly four times as likely to be suspended
as white children. A reflection of zero-tolerance policies, school
discipline
results in disproportionate punishment for Black children and serves
as part of the school-to-prison
pipeline through
increased dropouts and incarceration.
In
addition, DeVos has pulled back on enforcement of the Individuals
with Disabilities Education Act by rescinding
72 guidance documents outlining rights for disabled students, and has
retreated on the Obama-era crackdown on campus sexual assault. DeVos
has also promoted tax cuts for wealthy parents to send their children
to private schools and vouchers at the expense of public schools.
Also under DeVos, the Department of Education will provide more
autonomy to regional offices and lax oversight, as well as no longer
requiring three years of data to assess whether a school or district
is in compliance with civil rights law. This is part of a broader
effort to limit civil rights enforcement and examining systemic
patterns of discrimination, one
which has also encompassed the Department of Justice under U.S.
Attorney General Jeff Sessions.
Following
reports the DOJ would investigate affirmative action programs for
anti-white discrimination, the Trump administration threatened
to sue
Harvard University for violating civil rights law in its affirmative
action program, claiming the program discriminates against
Asian-Americans. Some experts regard this as a politically motivated
probe and an unprecedented investigation by the DOJ, in which the
department cites a 2015
administrative complaint
filed by 64 Asian-American associations. In that case — which
is being given a second look by DOJ after being dismissed by the
Department of Education due to a similar federal lawsuit that had
been filed — DOJ has claimed Harvard is out of compliance with
federal law. The administration also supports a parallel 2014 lawsuit
against Harvard filed by Students for Fair Admissions, an
organization which believes race-conscious admissions are
unconstitutional. The DOJ said it might formally enter the lawsuit as
a friend of the court. Harvard’s lawyers claim the department
is carrying water for Students for Fair Admissions. The agency’s
actions suggest an interest in waging a strong challenge to
affirmative action, presumably with one of these two cases.
“The
Justice Department clearly seems to be trying to tee up another case
for the Supreme Court. It looks like right now that they are looking
for a sympathetic, attractive group of plaintiffs — here it’s
Asian-Americans students who’ve been denied admission at
Harvard — and to try to drive a wedge among communities of
color by kind of pitting Asian-Americans against African-American and
Hispanic students,” Vanita
Gupta,
president and CEO of The Leadership Conference on Civil and Human
Rights and former head of the DOJ Civil Rights Division under Obama
told CBS News.
“Racial
discrimination in our nation’s educational systems persists and
both the Departments of Education and Justice are failing to protect
the civil rights and educational future of our Black and brown
students,” said Todd A. Cox,
director of policy at the NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund
following a recent meeting of civil rights organizations with DeVos
to express their frustration over her department’s anti-civil
rights actions. “This administration must stop endangering
students of color and instead ensure equal educational opportunities
and foster educational excellence by upholding the federal school
discipline guidance and promoting policies and programs that keep
students safe.”
“Any
attempts to rescind the 2014 school discipline guidance runs in
direct opposition to our commitment to the advancement of all women
and girls and to an education free of discrimination,” added
Deborah J. Vagins, senior vice president of public policy and
research at the American Association of University Women. “We
urge the Department of Education to stand by its commitment to
protect students’ civil rights by keeping the effective and
helpful guidance in place and by ensuring that no federal dollars are
being used to underwrite discrimination against children of color,
girls, children with disabilities, and LGBTQ youth,” she said.
DeVos
has provided financial support to organizations opposed to
affirmative action and voting rights, such as the Center for
Individual Rights and the Southeastern Legal Foundation, and other
groups who work against women’s reproductive freedom and LGBTQ
rights, according to the ACLU. Trump’s education chief
signifies a rejection of civil rights in education that encompasses
more than dismissing complaints by students facing racial
discrimination.
David
A. Love, JD - Serves
BlackCommentator.com as Executive Editor. He is a journalist,
commentator, human rights advocate and an adjunct instructor at the
Rutgers University School of Communication and Information based in
Philadelphia, and a
contributor to theGrio, AtlantaBlackStar, The
Progressive, CNN.com,
Morpheus, NewsWorks
and The
Huffington Post. He also blogs at davidalove.com.Contact Mr.
Love and BC.