Among
the many catastrophes that Donald Trump has foisted on the battered
people of the United States, he announced on Monday that he intends
to privatize the country’s air traffic control system.
It
could be that he didn’t think that Ronald Reagan went far
enough when he fired 11,500 air traffic controllers in 1981, and then
blacklisted them so that they never would be able to work in federal
service again. More on Reaganism later.
Trump
gathered a group of Republicans to back him up, as he signed a
“decision memo” that announced his plan to privatize air
traffic control. His back-ups included three transportation
secretaries who served under the Reagan and George W. Bush
Administrations, Elizabeth Dole, James Burnley, and Mary Peters. He
also had a few of his GOP primary opponents, including “Lying
Ted” (his nickname for the senator from Texas) Cruz.
He
stated, “We live in a modern age yet our
air traffic control system is stuck, painfully, in the past, but
after billions and billions of tax dollars spent and the many years
of delays, we’re still stuck with an ancient, broken,
antiquated, horrible system that doesn’t work.” He did
note that the Federal Aviation Administration has been trying to
“fix” the system for years, but has failed. Everyone
seems to be failing, but Trump, in his unique perspective on the
nation, the world, and reality.
To
most citizens, what he does with the air traffic control system is
minor, compared with his brash and ignorant decision to withdraw from
the Paris Accord on climate change, saying that he was elected
president to represent the people of Pittsburgh, not Paris. But,
considering the size of the U.S., its population of 320 million, and
the number of flights that take off and land every day, the system
that exists today is quite remarkable. That, however, never mattered
to a failed businessman who pretends to understand the workings of
any institution, including the federal government, which he is
supposed to guide in a positive way until he leaves office. That’s
why his utterance during his privatization announcement Monday can be
taken with the proverbial grain of salt. Modern systems will always
need work to improve them, but that only allows someone like Trump to
dissemble, if not lie, about them. We’re used to it.
A
quick look at the condition of the National Air Traffic Controllers
Association (NATCA), the successor to the Reagan-destroyed
Professional Air Traffic Controllers Organization (PATCO), will give
any inquiring person the necessary insight into the problems of air
traffic control and it does not rest with the controllers,
themselves. NATCA came into being a half-dozen years after PATCO was
rubbed out by the Republican president who famously proclaimed, “In
this present crisis, government is not the solution to our problem;
government is the problem.” Not that it did not happen before,
but from the time of Reagan, Republicans (with help from the
Democrats) have been systematically reducing government and its
programs to help real people and, in some cases, it has managed to
remove the government wholesale.
Trump,
the businessman who specializes in bailing himself out via
bankruptcies, has taken the nonsense of Reagan and is trying his best
to emulate the myths perpetrated by that president. However, he,
like Reagan, is starving programs that work, so that they appear not
to work, so they can either be eliminated, reduced in size and
effectiveness, or privatized. Without knowing much about it, Trump
has decided to privatize air traffic control.
Before
Reagan was elected in 1980, PATCO met with him and told him of the
stress and danger experienced by its members, that staffing needed to
be improved and the stress reduced. He promised to meet with them
after the election. After he won, he would not meet with the
controllers and they, even though they knew they were prohibited from
striking, struck. He fired them. In that campaign, PATCO and the
Teamsters were the only unions that endorsed Reagan.
The
air traffic control system continued after the firing and
blacklisting, using scab labor and anyone else who had any experience
in air traffic control. In 1987, NATCA was organized as a union and,
even in their founding papers, they themselves prohibited any strike
or work stoppage. They didn’t need management to curb their
rights. But, NATCA affiliated with the AFL-CIO, the nation’s
largest labor federation, which became 11,000 members larger in the
process.
Again,
though, the federal government, via the Federal Aviation
Administration (FAA), exercised its prerogative to keep staffing at
the same level or at a reduced level, supposedly to save money.
Where have the controllers wandered? Even though there are more
planes (maybe, fewer airlines) and more passengers, they are expected
to control the air lanes with the same or fewer staff. Sounds like
1981 all over again. In 2005-06, when negotiations got tough and
talks went on for many months, the FAA imposed conditions and
effectively removed the bargaining rights, without so much as a word
from the Cheney-Bush Administration.
NATCA
has tracked the number of controllers and said this in congressional
testimony in May 2017: “The number of fully certified air
traffic controllers has declined each year since 2012, reaching a
28-year low. Among its recommendations, NATCA is calling on the
Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) to continue to take a holistic,
collaborative approach to resolving the staffing crisis, and is
advocating for a stable, predictable funding stream for the FAA. That
includes ensuring that the FAA is not subject to future sequester
cuts, like what occurred in 2013 that had very negative consequences
for staffing and hiring. The FAA exceeded its air traffic controller
hiring goal for fiscal year 2016, but it missed its hiring mark each
of the previous seven years. That contributed to the total staffing
number falling nearly 10 percent since 2011. Additionally, 29 percent
of the total of fully certified controllers are eligible to retire
today.”
In
a chart tracking the decline of the number of controllers since 2011,
the situation is much more dramatic (down to 10,532 in March 2017).
Even Trump, if he had ever seen the numbers and viewed the graph,
would be able to understand the dire straits of the lives of air
traffic controllers and why they are asking that more controllers be
hired and more attention be paid to the stress on the job and the
danger to the flying public of ignoring the problems and blaming the
FAA and the controllers.
In
recent years, the FAA has even tried to convince veteran expert
controllers to stay on past their retirement dates, but who wouldn’t
want to leave a place with such a burden of responsibility for
thousands of lives and very little acknowledgment of their vital work
or its importance? But such a condition leaves the ignorant,
including the president, to make up their own speculation and to push
for privatization of that FAA function.
However much Trump
strutted and bragged that he was going to clean up “the swamp”
of Washington, he has done nothing to accomplish that. If anything,
he has proven himself to be just another cog in the rusty and creaky
Republican “party of no,” no to anything that provides
for the people who work for wages and for anyone they feel does not
deserve any assist or anything from their government—the poor,
elderly, disabled, and minorities. The rich and the corporations
deserve everything and he intends to get it for them. He’s
also one of them.
It
should not have come as a surprise to anyone that he is seeking to
privatize air traffic control, because it’s just one of the
functions of government that he and his GOP are trying to privatize.
For a few examples, they are privatizing education, the military,
municipal water systems, much basic scientific research (with
government money, of course), Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid,
and even the U.S. Postal Service. In the case of the USPS, Congress
has placed a fiscal burden on it that no corporation would be able to
carry. (The Post Office is being required by law to provide for
retirement benefits 75 years into the future, for workers who are not
even born yet.) And, since the service is “losing” so
much money, by making those multi-billion-dollar annual payments, the
GOP can say that it is failing and so, privatize it.
There
is no end to the methods that Republicans (and many Democrats) have
undertaken that would justify the destruction of the institutions of
government. Yet, that’s what is happening and for one reason:
Privatization of public wealth (the government, its resources, and
its institutions) allows the rich and the corporations, which control
most of national life, to put that wealth directly into their own
coffers. It could not be more blatant if there were a needle stuck
into a vein to directly withdraw the economic lifeblood of a nation.
It’s what has happened for several generations, but the ability
to do just that has become the overriding principle and goal of the
powers that be. Trump is just the latest figurehead in this effort.
|