For
most Americans, the dropping of a nuclear-sized, non-nuclear bomb in
Afghanistan was a ho-hum affair. Since the U.S. drops so many bombs
in so many places around the world, mention is restricted to a small
paragraph in a deep inside page of the major newspapers.
The
“mother of all bombs” (MOAB) certainly seemed like a
nuclear device when it hit the area near the frontier between
Pakistan and Afghanistan. At least, some farmers thought so. The
bomb, which was so big that it had to be dropped from the rear cargo
hatch of a giant transport plane, rather than a bomber designed
properly to rain death down on the earth.
The
bomb, the GBU-43B, or Massive Ordnance Air Blast, carried a payload
of some 20,000 pounds of explosives and took $314 million to develop,
with a unit cost of $16 million, according to The
Fiscal Times.
The drop, designed to kill ISIS fighters in their subterranean digs,
did its job, but it also traumatized those living in the area,
according to foreign researchers who have been working in that remote
area of the country, Nangarhar Province.
Farmers
in that region apparently were the last to know that a massive bomb
was going to be dropped in their vicinity. They found out about it
when they saw soldiers leaving the area and asked them what was going
on and, when they heard that a bombing was imminent, they too left
the area. Some see that the use of MOAB was less for military ends,
than to serve as a warning to others, who might be on the wrong end
of U.S. bombs in the future. Yes
magazine noted last week: “Adding evidence to that argument is
the relatively small scale of the local branch of ISIS, known
there as the Islamic State Khorosan Province, or ISKP. Andrea
Chiovenda, an anthropologist with Harvard Medical School who
conducted his research not far from the bomb site, said that ISKP has
only a few hundred fighters, most of them foreign. Even so, he said,
these fighters have brutalized the local population. ‘You might
tell me you want to cut it [the branch] down when it’s still
young,’ Chiovenda said. ‘But there’s plenty of
evidence that it’s not gaining traction among the people.’”
After
decades of war, the people of Afghanistan experience the daily stress
of not knowing from one day to the next whether they will be attacked
by either the local ISIS branch or the U.S. or some one of its
allies, if there are such things in the ongoing war, even though the
U.S. part in it (as far as we know) consists of the 8,400 troops,
with 5,000 coalition troops, that President Obama said would stay to
give support to that country’s army. Now, however, there is
talk inside the Trump Administration that more troops are needed to
end what has become America’s longest war. Trump’s
decision now, according to his generals, is whether to accept a
stalemate or increase the number of troops. Since he has declared
that the U.S. is through with nation-building, it’s hard to see
him increasing the number of troops, although he might be more averse
to setting himself up for being viewed as a loser. For him, either
choice is a path to potential disaster.
Under
any circumstances, there are people in Afghanistan who have been
born, grown to maturity, and are concerned for their grandchildren’s
well-being, who never have known anything but war. That relentless
condition is a stressor that can’t easily be calculated. Thus,
the small farmers and others who live in the remote regions of the
country can never be able to figure on a peaceful season of growing
crops on their small holdings. There are conflicting reports that the
giant MOAB strike did not hit any civilian land, but some observers,
viewing the video of the bombing released by the U.S. Department of
Defense said that it appeared that cultivated fields and terraces
were destroyed. This is an impoverished region whose tribal people
have suffered, since the late 1800s, when the British cut up the
region and left families on either side of the Pakistan-Afghanistan
frontier.
Spogmai
Akseer, an educator with a doctorate from the University of Toronto
and a native of the area of the bombing, told Yes
magazine: “Male members of my family I spoke with last month
said that, once the sun sets, they don’t like to leave their
homes for fears of ISIS and Taliban. They are very angry with the
government, for not looking after them.” She has been based in
Kabul for the past two years and thought immediately of her family
back home, when she heard of the bombing.
More
than one observer referred to the criticisms the local people express
about the expense of the bomb and what that money could do if it were
applied to hospitals, schools, housing, and other necessities of
life. Sixteen million dollars, the cost of one MOAB, would go a long
way to alleviate the suffering of so many in that region or other
regions, where some are said never to see a doctor in their entire
lives. Dropping bombs, especially one of that size, is not the way to
win the hearts and minds of the people, either in Afghanistan or any
other country.
If
large parts of the U.S. are considered “fly-over country,”
imagine what the country is like where the big bomb was dropped. It
would be like a moonscape or the surface of Mars for most Americans,
who would be shocked that people actually eke out a living in that
dry and hostile landscape. But, those Afghani farmers do, as do U.S.
farmers in a much less hostile part of the world. Imagine further,
the good that could come from the millions that are spent on bombs,
if they were spent on the people. If that had been done in the first
place, there might not be any reason for the presence of U.S. troops
at all and certainly would not be a reason for sending more troops
soon. The Afghani small farmers’ counterparts in the U.S. could
use some of that military money to make their lives easier, as they
grow food for the masses.
That
doesn’t appear in the offing, since Trump has asked for an
additional $54 billion for the already bloated military and defense
budget and he may get even more, considering the loud voices on the
right, demanding the use of the largest military on the planet
against every little impoverished and disorganized country in the
world. Hamid Karzai, the immediate past president of Afghanistan,
said a few days ago that he wants the U.S. out of the country and
charged that the current president is a traitor. Harsh words, but the
country is divided on the issue and it would be a surprise if Trump
would decide to pull out all troops. Trump recently said that he
thinks the U.S. needs to “start winning wars, again,” so
it’s not likely that he will declare a stalemate or bring the
troops home. We’re in for a bad time.
|