President-Elect
Donald Trump has inflamed the world of public education with his
appointment of Betsy DeVos, America’s foremost female voucher
and charter school advocate, as secretary of the U.S. Department of
Education (USDOE). Mark Thompson, radio journalist and public
intellectual, has stated that she may “… destroy
public education which has been the bedrock of American society.”
DeVos
and her husband, Richard, billionaire heirs of the Amway fortune,
have funded elected officials at the city, state, and federal levels
of government and school choice advocacy groups for more than three
decades, spending hundreds of millions of dollars to get voucher and
charter legislation passed and regulations implemented in all fifty
states. Working with billionaires, Eli Broad, Bill Gates, Suzy
Walton, the Koch Bros., and the wealthiest members of the education
reform Cartel, America’s public education system is being
transformed. Now she will have a free hand in shaping the voucher and
charter school policies that Trump vowed to execute during his
presidential campaign.
Using
her own American Federation of Children (AFC), which she established
in 2010, as a staging forum, DeVos has designed a diverse network of
politicians, privatization advocates, educators, and parents to push
her school choice agenda. I first encountered Betsy DeVos on
September 15, 2000 when I was invited to speak on a Michigan forum,
organized by the Detroit NACP, the National Education Association
(NEA), the American Federation of Teachers (AFT), and the American
Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), to speak against the voucher referendum
that she had lobbied and funded legislators to put on the November
2000 ballot. Held in Detroit at the Cobo Center, the four hour event
was broadcast statewide on cable TV. At that time, polls showed that
vouchers were being supported by voters, 55 percent to 45 percent.
However, when the election was held on November 7, 2000, the
anti-voucher group prevailed by a margin of 62 percent to 38 percent.
However,
after the unexpected defeat, DeVos returned, like Freddie Krueger in
the Friday the 13th movie series, reached deeper into her pocket and
was able to rapidly expand charter schools via more intense lobbying
and exponential political contributions. Although she has promoted
and increased voucher schools across the nation, most notably in
Louisiana, her focus of late has been on creating more corporate
charter schools and freeing them from public oversight (as they
receive more public dollars per student than vouchers). By means of
her wealth and the AFC, she has assembled a vast network of
politicians, educators, athletes, TV personalities, and parents to
advocate for her school choice agenda. She has a broader group of
federal legislators in her debt in the U.S. Congress than does
President-Elect Trump.
In
her strategic genius, she connected with many Democratic and
Republican politicians early in their careers with major financial
contributions. For example, she and her husband have funded U.S.
Senator Cory Booker since he first entered politics in a successful
run for the Newark, New Jersey City Council in 1998, sponsored his
two mayoral races in 2002 and 2006, and his two U.S. Senate campaigns
in 2013 and 2014; Sens. Lamar Alexander (R-TN) and Tim Scott (R-SC),
chair and member, respectively, of the Senate Committee on Health,
Education, Labor, and Pensions, which will vote on her confirmation;
and backed newly elected U.S. Representative Dwight Evans (D-PA),
whose charter school network she also financed. All have been major
beneficiaries of her financial largesse during their political
careers. In addition, DeVos continues to fund voucher and corporate
charter adherents in every state.
Among
educators, Dr. Howard Fuller, former Superintendent of the Milwaukee
Public Schools, currently distinguished professor of education at
Marquette University, and founding chair of the Black Alliance for
Educational Options (BAEO), which she also subsidizes, has been one
of her leading school choice surrogates for more than twenty years;
he also participated as a pro-voucher spokesman at the 2000 Detroit
forum. Michelle Rhee, previous chancellor of the Washington, D.C.
Public Schools, and founding president of Students First, a national
pro-privatization of public education association, who was considered
for the Secretary of Education position, along with DeVos, has also
been supported by DeVos.
Her
annual AFC National Policy Conference has drawn scores of school
choice proponents featuring politicians, Sen. Booker, Govs. Chris
Christie, Bobby Jindal, Jeb Bush, Scott Walker, etc.; ESPN analysts,
Stephen J. Smith, Lisa Leslie, and Jalen Rose; and DeVos’s
public school privatization plan is supported by Gen. Colin Powell,
former Congressmen Charlie Rangel and Andrew Young, and a host of
corporate CEOs throughout the nation. She will assume the mantle of
USDOE with a robust complement of school choice enthusiasts across
the political, racial/ethnic, occupational, and income spectrum.
But
more interesting is the fact that her proposed policy program is
nearly a replica of the one advanced by the Obama administration
through its two pro-privatization USDOE secretaries, Arne Duncan and
Dr. John King, who took office with the aggressive sponsorship of the
education reform Cartel. Obama’s Race to the Top (RTTT) bill,
which spearheaded a huge increase in voucher and corporate charter
schools, delivered substantially more than the $20 billion to the
private sector that Trump has proposed to allocate for voucher and
charter schools. During his eight-year term, Obama transferred and/or
facilitated (through the states) more than a $100 billion in
education funding to the sectarian and corporate education sector.
This
transference has occurred in the following ways: RTTT funding to the
states, which expedited privatization by requiring recipients to lift
the cap on charter schools, permits easier closing of low-performing
public schools, often using arbitrary criteria; teacher layoffs;
significant growth in federal funding for charter schools; and the
USDOE secretaries using their office as bully pulpits for public
school privatization. Thus, the major difference between the Obama
administration and the upcoming Trump administration is that Trump
and DeVos are directly and loudly proclaiming their intentions to
dismantle public education whereas Obama’s approach has been
largely a sleight of hand to achieve the same purpose.
When Cartel
representatives met with him and his staff in the Oval Office on
January 29, 2009, nine days after his inauguration, with a final copy
of RTTT for his perusal, Obama commented, “… this
is what I have been talking about, just don’t poke unions in
the eye.” He
promptly dispatched the legislation to the Congress where the
Democrats controlled both houses. Since that time, public education
has been under accelerated siege with no apparent end in sight.
Public education stakeholders and unions were lulled to sleep by the
sweet nothings about public education from the most eloquent and
charismatic U.S. president of the 21st century, and now they are up
against the privatization wall. USDOE Secretary-Elect, Betsy DeVos,
is just taking the hand-off from President Obama, and his education
staff, in the red zone, and attempting to cross the goal line for the
destruction of public education, creating a perfect storm of school
choice.
[Correction:
The Massachusetts Education Association (MTA) was mistakenly
referenced as an affiliate of the American Federation of Teachers
(AFT) in the 11-17-16 column. It is an affiliate of the National
Education Association (NEA). The Farrell Report regrets the error.]
|