A
report released last month shows that the gap in wages between white
workers and their black counterparts is larger today than it was
nearly four decades ago and, if the past is any indication of the gap
in next 35 years, it is bound to get worse, if no action is taken.
“We’ve
found that racial wage gaps are growing primarily due to
discrimination—and other unmeasured and unobserved
characteristics—along with rising inequality in general,”
said William M. Rodgers, a Rutgers University economist. “In
order to fully address racial wage gaps, direct action must be taken
to decrease discrimination and address the problem of stagnant wages
across the board.”
The
study was done by Rodgers and Valerie Wilson, director of the
Economic Policy Institute’s (EPI) Program on Race, Ethnicity,
and the Economy, and covers the period 1979-2015. It’s always
good to have the back-up of scholarship and study to prove what most
wage working men and women know when the bills come in to be paid at
the end of the month, or at the dinner table each night. It’s
especially true for black wageworkers, because the gap in their pay
is not only a blight for the 1979-2015 period, but it has been a
blight on the history of the nation for generations.
Repeatedly,
studies have shown that wages have virtually stagnated for millions
of workers over the past four decades and the wages of black and
other minorities have lagged even those numbers. The disparity in
wealth between black and white workers is a scandal for which there
is no excuse, except for rank discrimination and prejudice.
Proof
of that appears in the difference in the wages and income of black
college graduates and white high school graduates. It’s not
that a college education has not been a benefit to millions of black
wageworkers and professionals. It has, but when it comes to hiring a
qualified black applicant, too often a prospective employer will hire
a less-educated and possibly less-qualified white applicant. It
simply comes down to prejudice and discrimination.
The
EPI report by Rodgers and Wilson notes: “In 2015, black men’s
average hourly wages were 22.0 percent less than those of comparable
white men, whereas in 1979, the wage gap was only 16.9 percent.
Similarly, with an adjusted average hourly wage gap of only 4.5
percent, black and white women were near parity in 1979. In 2015,
however, black women experienced an 11.7 percent wage gap relative to
white women, while the wage gap between black women and white men was
34.2 percent.”
Black
and other minority workers are losing ground and have been losing
ground for nearly 40 years. It’s historic, yes, and goes back
to Reconstruction and Jim Crow, but the period covered by this EPI
study shows just how deeply and negatively the U.S. economy has been
affected by trade agreements that have favored transnational
corporations and the rising (or perhaps, previously hidden deep
racism) of the nation. If anything has brought that into the open,
it has been the current presidential-year election and, especially,
the Republican candidate, Donald Trump.
The
two authors of the study suggest a number of measures that will
somewhat mitigate the problem of the racial wage gap, such as
developing new measures of determining workplace discrimination,
ordering the governmental agencies that monitor such things to
enforce the anti-discrimination laws that are already on the books,
and taking action to raise the minimum wage, which currently stands
at $7.25 an hour. The nationwide fight for a $15 an hour minimum
wage has been going on for several years and individual states have
passed laws that will see the minimum rise over the next three or
four years. Not good enough, because too many states want the right
to keep the minimum wage low, in keeping with Corporate America’s
wishes and their efforts to make their states the low-wage centers
that will draw industries to locate in those states. They have
witnessed the flood of jobs and industry flow from the U.S., to
other, developing countries, and they want to emulate that philosophy
and that flow.
In
Trump, we have the philosophy of the billionaire class, which claims
that wages are “too high” in the U.S. and that makes the
nation uncompetitive in the global economy, even as he woos the
working class to support his effort to gain the White House. Many of
them have fallen for it, even though he cares little for workers,
given the way he has treated them in all of his enterprises,
including failure to pay them their just wages and stiffing untold
numbers of workers and contractors.
Let
us not give his Democratic opponent, Hillary Clinton, a free ride.
She would have been satisfied with a $2-3 increase in the minimum
wage, thus keeping the working poor poorer, until the pressure from
the Bernie Sanders campaign pushed her to $10.10, then to $12, and
finally, to the $15 that fast food workers and other low wage workers
have been rallying and striking for in the past few years. She has
been pushed into positions on the issues by Sanders and his
supporters that she never would have embraced without the pressures
of the primary campaign, since her instincts are with those of the
billionaire class, just as her opponents are.
Under
her watch as secretary of state, the State Department interfered in
Haiti, when it was proposed several years ago, to raise the minimum
wage to 61 cents an hour, foreign “investors” (read U.S.
textile, clothing, and other companies) fought vigorously to keep the
wages lower and succeeded. The wage was lowered from 61 cents to 31
cents and the working families were left struggling with a starvation
wage. It took an estimated $12.50 a day at that time for minimal
decent living, but the 31 cents brought a day’s pay to only
about $5. The wage was increased in 2014, but it was still far below
the amount needed for a family to live.
Because
of the confluence of many problems across the U.S. economy, there are
millions of workers who never will be able to really retire and that
goes double or triple for black workers and other minorities. There
are those who are working (low wage jobs) well into their eighties,
because the meager benefits of Social Security for poverty wage
workers is just not enough and the health care benefits of Medicare
and Medicaid are just not enough to live a decent life. Often,
failing health is the one thing that stops these millions from
working into advanced old age. In such a rich nation, that should
never be. Yet, whichever candidate wins the White House it does not
appear that there is much of a change possible, at least in overall
policy.
Although
Wilson and Rodgers include in their suggestions for change to benefit
low- wage workers “strengthening workers’ ability to
collectively bargain,” they stop just short of a full-throated
call for unionization of workers. That is really the only way that
black workers will be able to unite and fight for their rightful
place in the American economy and mainstream. After all of the
problems over all of the generations, it might be well for black
workers to begin to form black-led unions. No one else knows better
what is needed to improve the lives of workers in the community.
Unity is the key. Solidarity is the key. Imagine a 2-million-member
union of black workers, paying their dues and participating fully in
the economic, political, and social life of the country. It would be
a force to be reckoned with.
|