We
just celebrated "Juneteenth" (the start of the end of slavery in the
U.S.) amid tumultuous and sometimes confusing politics and what appears
to be an increase in racist mobilization. For internet activists the
situation begs the question: what, at this moment in our history, is
the relationship between technology and black people?
It's a critical issue for us all.
Regular
readers of this site have read it many times: with expanding
globalization and the information economy, the internet has become a
major, if not the major, communications technology in today's world. In
the United States, it's the most popular tool for direct and group
communications, study, research, diversion, journalism, intellectual
collaboration and news consumption.
Most
people reading this would agree that black people must be a part of
that. But that truth is not a function only of a commitment to equality
or justice. It's a necessity if we are to preserve the Internet's
freedom and functionality and build a truly just and democratic society.
That
kind of society requires that Black people "sit at the table" of
equality in this country and, to do that, they must enjoy a full,
robust relationship with the internet that is equal to all other groups
of people.
That, today, is simply not the case.
While
the "digital divide" remains something of an issue, it is no longer the
main one. Black people in the United States enjoy open and fairly
robust use of internet technologies, particularly with the rise of the
cell phone and cable television as internet devices. Both of those
technologies are ubiquitous in Black communities of this country.
However, computer and internet access and use by African Americans remains far below that of Whites. The Pew Research Center study of device ownership found
that half of all households with annual incomes under $30,000 do not
have or use a computer at home, compared with 10% of households with
incomes over $50,000. The U.S. median Black household income in 2015
was $35,481, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics.
As
Lee Rainie, The Pew Research Center's Director of Internet, Science,
and Technology Research (and co-author of that study) explains, the
relationship of Black people to the internet is highly nuanced and
scaled. So while a Black college student (a population that has grown
enormously over the last 20 years) might use the internet freely and
openly for research and basic communications, a person who dropped out
of high school might use it primarily for quick "texting" and tweeting,
if at all. This makes sense, since the internet is a written
communications tool for the most part.
In
addition, as the Pew study points out, the difference in usage among
various age levels is particularly pronounced within the Black
community, with older people being significantly less likely to use the
internet.
Still,
Black people now have access to internet technology more than ever. But
access in the Black community is not about who uses the internet but
how they use it.
And that is the problem.
First,
the trend is toward greater use of social media. Twitter and Facebook
are undoubtedly the most popular internet functionalities among younger
Black people. While nobody can question the importance and usefulness
of these protocols, they are very limited in their ability to foster
effective communication. Facebook's scrapbook presentation and
Twitter's word limits make articles, papers and other longer written
forms difficult to read and virtually impossible to post.
This
is intellectually constraining for potential authors (which, in
internet culture, is anyone with an idea in his or her head) but it's
stultifying intellectually for those who might read this material. The
Black presence in larger intellectual culture of the internet is very
sparse as a result.
This
is particularly true with the social struggle movements led by Black
people such as Black Lives Matter. While this movement was organized
primarily on the internet, it used Twitter extensively with network
texting as a second, supportive technology. While these are powerful
mobilizing tools, they don't allow for more in-depth analysis and
collaborative thinking (one of the criticisms activists make of the
Black Lives Matter movement). In this case, technology moved Black
people forward in terms of the public spotlight but, due to the
protocols used, limited their ability to develop and project a shared
political analysis and strategy for addressing the systemic issues that
gave rise to the movement.
There
are, to be sure, websites that specialize in Black news and
social/political analysis and they are well-known and prominent. But
they are few and also highly ghettoized —seldom cited by other news
organizations or analysis websites, infrequently mentioned by speakers
talking about technology, and not visited much by anyone other than
Black people.
Second,
open and aggressive racism is alive and well on the internet. Even a
cursory look at the comments sections of any of the news sites (like
CNN or Fox) reveal a shocking racism that is more virulent and brazen
than what was prevalent 40 years. The anonymity of the internet,
combined with an increase in racist thinking and expression (as white
people face more frightening prospects in their lives and are enabled
to scapegoat people of color for that) have produced a culture of
racist expression so overwhelming that it is difficult to publicly
challenge.
It's
daunting to be a person of color in public situations and debates on
the internet and Black people take the brunt of that repressive
beating. As a result, Black people tend to congregate and participate
only on certain types of websites while not doing much more than
"surfing” the rest of the Net.
As a result, much of the internet has no Black presence in its information and analysis.
Third,
there are very few Black technologists and ever fewer Black people in
major positions in any technology organization or network. The problem
is fundamental to the culture and character of technology. The
functioning of the internet, its management, and (most importantly) its
development through software and protocols is all run by white men,
with the resulting biases and limited perspective that can be expected
to reflect any racially constrained process. Of all the
internet-related problems, this is the worst because it extends far
into the future, is a root problem that can't be solved without a major
revamping of the technologist population, and it is entrenched in the
power of white men over communications and the economics involved in
internet technology.
It walks hand in hand with racism and white supremacy.
Finally,
the explosive corporate use of the internet, particularly in retail
sales, has actually brought more and more Black people (particularly
younger Black people) into use of the technology but that use limits
Black people's communications experience to a contemporary version of a
shopping spree. Shopping on the internet is a major convenience, but
using the internet for that alone is an enormous social restriction and
detriment to the full participation of residents in the nation’s
political, social, and cultural life.
The
problem is huge and it affects everyone in this society and there are a
few things we can do...right now...during this United Nations’
International Decade of People of African Descent. These should be
demands by our movements and points of unity among them:
*
Train and empower Black technologists and technology users. This would
represent programs of real training and not some partial "training
program" designed to steer young people of color into stifling and
socially negative corporate jobs.
*
Actively discourage hate speech and cultivate online cultures of
tolerance and mutual respect. Free speech is a real right; racial abuse
isn't and the Internet doesn't have to accept that. All a chat provider
would have to do is to crisply and sharply answer hate speech
expressions -- they're pretty easy to see -- and make clear that this
is contrary to the provider's policy. There's much they can do in
addition but that alone would be powerful.
*
Organize to build more centers for Black thinking and a clearer
strategy for publicizing and popularizing content generated by people
of African descent. In short, stop "ghetto-izing" black thinking on the
Internet by funding and supporting Black-run research and thought
centers and facilitating the publication of their work.
*
Resist and reverse the privatization and corporate concentration of the
internet by defending net neutrality and developing and supporting free
and open source software and open access publishing. After all, that is
the essence of the free Internet.
In
a digital age, democracy and freedom depend on our ability to
communicate with one another in an equitable and fair manner. It is
clear that the long-term impacts of racism persist and indeed are
amplified through technology. Today’s struggle for emancipation relies
upon securing the right to free and equitable communication, which is
critical to the achievement of all other human rights.
This commentary originally appeared on This Can't Be Happening!
|