Such injustices aren’t supposed to happen to white males.I find it strange that white people are amazed when
they find out that someone spent four years in solitary confinement. We all
know and agree that the criminal justice system is pockmarked with injustice… like
unrestrained solitary confinement. That’s kind of what Guantanamo Bay
looks like. But of course it’s okay because that’s about national security.
Tell me why that’s not about
I bring “white people” to this conversation because
Shane Bauer was one of three Americans detained in 2009 while hiking in Iraq’s
Kurdish region near the Iranian border. He and Joshua Fattal
were held for 26 months, while Sarah Shourd - now
Bauer’s wife - was held for 13 months. The story Bauer is telling is about his
four months in solitary confinement. Bauer’s “Solitary in Iran Nearly Broke Me” is the most
recent cover story for Mother Jones.
What is so utterly insulting to me is that Bauer is
getting play for his four months in confinement. I am the first to say that
solitary confinement is no one’s friend, but Black men all over America
sit in solitary confinement or the SHU - for periods of six months while
detectives just investigate! That doesn’t even begin to count toward the months
- years - in solitary confinement, when they are found guilty after that investigation.
While I was awaiting trial during my five year
stint in the federal system, I sat in solitary confinement for a combined time
of over two years. Does anyone really want to hear my story? The advantage of
being white in America
seems to be a white person’s province in telling the story. I find it shameful
that the inhumane practice of SHUs is only given
validity when a white man tells the story. You know that old saying: The white
man’s ice is colder.
Now, Bauer’s new book, due for publication in 2014,
talks about the injustice exacted upon Mumia
Abu-Jamal, who spent decades in solitary confinement. Americans were made aware,
for years, of the injustices against Abu-Jamal - even in the face of obviously insufficient
and tainted evidence used to justify his conviction. As Americans, we should
find it strange that all of a sudden, Bauer is struck by the inhumanity of
solitary confinement. So much so that he’s now compelled to publicly speak out
These men have been in solitary confinement since April 17, 1972.
Consider the cases of Herman Wallace and Albert Woodfox; both of them have been held in solitary
confinement in Louisiana.
The state says they were guilty of murdering a guard at Angola Prison, but
Wallace, Woodfox and their network of supporters say
they were framed for their political activism as Black Panthers. Woodfox and Wallace founded the Angola chapter of the Black Panther
Party in 1971. These men have been in solitary confinement since April 17,
1972! Yes, you heard me right…since 1972, for 40 years of their lives!
I heard about Shane Bauer’s publicity tour and his article, I saw injustice
coming. Did you? If you didn’t, why didn’t you? So tell me what makes Shane
Bauer’s case more worthy of front-page attention? Is it the fact that was held
in solitary confinement? Is it the fact that he was held by a foreign
government unjustly? Is it that he didn’t deserve such inhumane treatment,
i.e., to be placed in isolation from other people? I dare say, “Bauer’s ordeal
only holds America’s
attention because he is a white male… And, such injustices aren’t supposed to
happen to white males.”
am always embittered at the site of injustice. I should hope you feel strongly
about injustice too. It is a matter of the human condition. It is a matter of
societal oppression. It is a matter of the heart that may one day visit your doorstep. You should care. Allowing
Shane Bauer to be the authoritative voice on solitary confinement is a slap in
the face to Black males. His elevation as spokesperson de
facto silences the voice of the majority of victims; that insults and assaults
justice [movements] around the world.
BlackCommentator.com Columnist, Perry Redd, is the former Executive Director of
the workers rights advocacy, Sincere Seven, and author of the on-line
commentary, “The Other Side of the Tracks.” He is the host of the internet-based
talk radio show, Socially Speaking in Washington, DC. Click here to contact Mr. Redd.