profiling, in the security and criminal justice sense, is an effective
method to identify those who are likely to cause injury and death, where is the profile of the white, male geek?
Some justify the profiling of folks with Arab dress getting on
airplanes. And brown folks (Hispanics) are profiled on the highways of Arizona and other places as “illegal aliens” while undocumented folks from Canada have
no profile. And young, black males are constantly profiled every day
everywhere. Just watch eyes roll when a young black male walks into a
We constantly project our fears and our inner demons out onto others - in racists, sexist, homophobic, and other ways.
But after Timothy McVeigh, Andrew Kehoe, Jack Gilbert Graham, David Burke, Martin Bryant, James Oliver Huberty, Charles Witman, Thomas Hamilton, Michael Ryan, Ronald Gene Simmons Sr., Pat Sherill, Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold, George Banks, Howard Unruh, Mark O. Barton, James Rupert, James Edward Pough, Richard Speck, Anton Probst, Richard Durn, Ray Martin Deford, etc., etc., and NOW James Eagan Holmes…and still we have no security profile of the killer white, male geek. That tells me again how much racist BS profiling is.
urge to “profile” people you do not know when you first meet them is a
natural mental response that often does not rise to consciousness.
However, racism and all the other “isms” warp that mental process. When
this flawed - particularly in the US context
- process is institutionalized (when it is frozen into institutional
policies and frameworks), the power and weight of flawed institutional
pre-judgments come down hard in lethal, discriminatory and unjust ways.
Rather than being open to the fact that most often “the book is more
than its cover” and rather than being of open heart and welcoming of
those we do not know, agents of these profiling institutions act more
like diseased automatons. Let us not be mesmerized by who we are
psychologically as humans and how we are shaped by the institutions
with which we identify. Despite the protestations of some, who are
attempting to understand the whys of the Colorado Theater Shooting, it
was not an isolated phenomenon because human beings are not isolated
beings; we all are deeply embedded in family, institutions, and
Besides the racism on display in discussions about The Shooting, there are deeply buried US social-psychological, political fractures that
have surfaced and that will be obfuscated by the emotional “flack”
being tossed “into the air” by our corporate dominant media in the wake
of the event in Aurora. A natural individual and social response to
horror will be denial, confusion, segmentation into a conception of
mental illness, projection of our own deep horribleness on to an
“other,” paranoia and conspiracy theory-making, and comforting ritual in words and practices.
will be strongly attracted to persons or objects to blame other then
ourselves. But most of all, we will be blind to the ingrained nature of
this tragedy that is deeply rooted in our culture, our politics, and
our beings as participants in this Country. We will miss the fact that
there is no one set of policies or actions that can cure this. And we
will come too late to the ancient wisdom that shows the power of
forgiveness of self and forgiveness of “other” as eye opening and
mind-opening to eliminate the obscurations of the path to peaceful,
prosperous, REAL secure, sustainable life.
As individuals and as a country we have done some pretty horrendous things.
One of those serendipitously displayed cultural fractures has to do with the movie in that theater that night: The Dark Knight Rises. This
movie’s main character, Bruce Wayne, is a multimillionaire or
billionaire. He is supposedly the hero who uses his money and ‘cutting
edge’ technology to equip himself to save the people of his community
from consummately evil villains. The source of Bruce Wayne’s millions
is mostly opaque in the story. Wow! My mind kind of naturally jumps…in
an easy way…to that other multimillionaire in the news who
is hiding his money in mechanism out-of-sight overseas: Mitt Romney. It
is pretty obvious that he also thinks of himself as kind of a hero
the shooting obscure this comparison from most of us or expose it? Can
we find the forgiveness of self to dampen all of our “survivor’s
remorse?” Guilt is a most powerful mentally debilitating emotion.
Colorado Governor John Hickenlooper epitomized
the usual shallow response when he said, what Holmes did “…may not have
been political terrorism, but it was the act of a deranged, demonic
person.” Someone who spends months planning such an act has an
ideology. Can we forgive the perpetrator enough to see ourselves in him
- he is also human - rather than project what within ourselves we
refuse to project… on to him… to make ourselves feel more pure and more
righteous. As individuals and as a country we have done some pretty
horrendous things. Our political, imperialistic justifications do not
make our acts any less horrible. We need to own up to them rather than
project them on to others. That is what I think James Eagan Holmes
did…project his inner demons out on to others and then physically
killed those demons. That is a psycho-social disease of our time to
which we are all subject.
We will be strongly attracted to persons or objects to blame other then ourselves.
drama of Batman and most modern comic books and legendary stories does
this dynamic for some of us. This transference of our processes into
the drama, up on the screen, makes even more poignant the juxtaposition
of Bruce Wayne to Mitt Romney. The real multimillionaire is part of the
financial industry that crashed the economy, causing hardship and
(indirectly) death to innocent people. He was part of the company, Bain
Capital, which, both when Romney was there and afterward, fired lots of
people and ruined their dreams and lives. Who and where is the
multimillionaire hero in real life?
are devastating our community every damned day. We constantly project
our fears and our inner demons out onto others - in racists, sexist,
homophobic, and other ways. And often we shoot, cut, oppress, and
suppress those others onto whom we project. We do not see them as human
or we see them as irredeemably evil, mentally ill, or fundamentally
different because of what we have taken out of ourselves and put on
them. To some degree, we are all James Eagan Holmes. That is why
profiles do not work.
For Mr. Riles, the following is an explanation of the meaning of the Swahili term “Nafsi ya Jamii”:
Nafsi ya Jamii is
the Swahili phrase that translates in English to “The Soul Community”.
Real community is the next phase in the process of seeking individual
justice through social change. To be guided by the words of Howard
Thurman: “Don’t ask what the world needs; ask what makes you come
alive, and go do that. What the world needs is people
who have come alive.” Maintain a Seven Generations perspective in all
that is done; honoring the generations who’ve come before and mindful
that our actions will have an impact for the generations who come
after. Additionally, recognize that all of us are cultural beings; we
include deep cultural understanding and experience in all that is done.
BlackCommentator.com Columnist, Wilson Riles, is a former Oakland, CA City Council Member. Click here to contact Mr. Riles.