It’s been a
few weeks since the Pew Research Center released its “social
and demographic trends report” on Blacks’ perception
of black progress. More interesting than the usual feedback
on the pathology of “doom and gloom” rooted in black socio-economic
reality, is the virtual silence about the study’s multi-racial
analysis of the state of black decline. Whether that decline
is perceived or real (and it is more real than perception),
the study is just not a survey of Blacks’ assessment on
the State of Black America and the growing intra-race gaps
between the poor and middle class. It’s also a study on
the hidden attitudes about the state of Black America that
turn a blind eye to historical disparities.
Buried deep in the nearly 90 page report are perceptual realities that
have caused black optimism to wane. White attitudes (and
to a lesser degree, Latino attitudes) are diametrically opposite
those of Blacks, in their analysis of why the state of black
America has regressed. More than twice as many Blacks (as
Whites) surveyed, felt racial discrimination was the reason
Blacks could not get ahead. This refusal to acknowledge racism
in its various forms, overt and covert, continues to be a
dividing point in the nation. The pathology comes in when
asked, two-thirds of all the people surveyed, including 71%
of Whites, 59% of Latinos and even 53% of Blacks, felt that
Blacks themselves were responsible for their own condition
in not being able to get ahead.
The victimization
of Blacks and their socio-economic circumstance has been historic
and persistent over the past 140 years (since
the end of slavery). The reality is that 220 years after
the three-fifths compromise was effectuated at the Constitutional
Convention of 1787, the study affirmed that black median
income as a percentage of white median income has dropped
from 65% to 61% since 2000, back to three-fifths (actual
average income is 57% of whites, less than three-fifths).
Economic subjugation continues to be the prevailing discriminator
in our society that directly affects one’s quality of life.
The other
factor that uplifts quality of life is education, and again
where 56% of Blacks feel that it is more important to go
to racially mixed schools, only 23% of Whites feel that way.
Conversely, 65% of Whites feel it is more important to go
to local community schools, and only a third (33%) of Black
surveyed feel that way. The barrier then becomes de facto segregation
that creates the invisible lines of separatism and discriminates
according to where one lives.
In the battle for racial equality in America, many people forget that
while De Jure (separate by law) segregation lost in
the desegregation fight, De Facto (separation by social
norms and residential patterns) segregation WON. As long
as Whites could keep their neighborhoods separate, they could
advocate for local school rights and keep their schools separate.
That’s where housing discrimination (where 65% of Blacks
stated in the Pew study that they always face racial discrimination
in renting or buying a house) plays large. Yet, white attitudes
rarely (15%) acknowledge anti-black discrimination as a factor
in the black state of affairs. 71% of Whites say Blacks are
responsible for their own condition. Dismal as it is.
To further
feed this pathological mindset of black retrogression is how
the study plays the “immigrant card” against Blacks,
as if immigrant workers are really the problem in black unemployment.
The survey even indicts the black “work ethic” by suggesting
that everybody across the board (including Blacks) sees immigrants
as working harder in low wage jobs than Blacks. This is a
false indicator because employers use immigrants to undermine
livable wages, then once immigrants have the jobs-they unionize
and advocate for higher wages. If the jobs were offered at
higher wages, maybe the jobs would be more attractive to
Blacks. Wage suppression is the issue here, not the black
work ethic.
This brings
the black class conflict full circle, as one witnesses the
bifurcation of income within Black America - you also witness
the struggle to stay above the “class line,” while ignoring
the “race line.” In plain terms, Blacks are now fighting
the “effects” of racism instead of the “causes” of racism.
It’s misguided to even suggest that middle class Blacks would
be a cause of the circumstances of poorer Blacks, except
to infer that if middle class Blacks didn’t leave the community,
the quality of life of poor Blacks would be different. Again,
a false assumption but one created to take attention from
the real issues of lack of change in white attitudes over
the past twenty years or the retrogression in socio-economic
circumstances tied to hidden biases.
Whether or
not the study substantiates black optimism fading, or black
progress in regression, the state of Black America is really
the state of some harsh racial realities in America - realities
that Blacks see one way, Whites see another and everybody
sees somewhere in-between. To ignore that Blacks are still
disproportionately discriminated against, and to say the
victim is victimizing himself, is to look at the situation
through blinders. Where optimism once reflected the world
through “rose-colored” glasses, reality, even pessimism,
has framed this new world order through colorblind glasses.
With the Pew Study, society, through its researchers and
academicians, is preparing to validate colorblindness in
the same ways slavery and segregation were validated. Now
it’s up to the black community, the most conveniently studied
population, not to co-sign the pathology.
BC
Columnist Anthony
Asadullah Samad, Ph.D., is a national columnist, managing
director of the Urban
Issues Forum and author of the new book, Saving
The Race: Empowerment Through Wisdom.
He can be reached at www.AnthonySamad.com