Canadians are no better or no worse than any other
people. They have been on the right and wrong sides of history.
Like every other nation Canada has produced revolutionaries, working
class heroes, buffoons and idiots. Canadian Prime Minister Paul Martin was forced
to take the correct position on missile defense by refusing to
back U.S. President
George W. Bush. At the same time Canada has come up short on the
question of Haiti. According to a March 15, 2002 article in the
Canadian magazine “L ‘Actualite,“ by Michel Vastel,
President Jean Bertrand Aristide’s coup was planned in Ontario.
Many have said that singer/actor/director Harry
Belafonte is the closest we have to his idol, Paul Robeson. Belafonte
is known as
a risk taker. He was one of the first to openly question Colin
Powell’s role in international politics. While others were
saying things like, “Let’s give the brother a chance,” Belafonte
referred the former Secretary of State as a “House Negro.”
Belafonte called Powell out on the Larry King
Show on CNN. Said Belafonte, "There's an old saying. In the days of slavery,
there were those slaves who lived on the plantation and there were
those slaves that lived in the house. You got the privilege of
living in the house if you served the master ... exactly the way
the master intended to have you serve him." Belafonte continues
to make waves by supporting an effort to have U. S. President George
W. Bush, former CIA Director George Tenet; the former commander
in Iraq, Lt. Gen Richard Sanchez, Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld
and several other military leaders arrested for torture changes.
Gail Davidson, Co-Chair of Lawyers against the War (LAW) has laid
seven torture charges against U. S. President George W. Bush. If
Davidson, a Vancouver, Canada based-lawyer and her organization
have their way President Bush will be tried in Canada on these
charges. The charges were laid when President Bush visited Canada
on November 30, 2004. These charges concern the well-known abuses
at Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq, photos of which shocked the world
last year, as well as similar abuses at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba that
have emerged more recently.
The Canadian government used a claim of diplomatic
immunity to have the information charging Bush declared a nullity.
On behalf
of LAW, Davidson was seeking to set a date for a hearing into the
charges and came armed with evidence. Judge William Kitchen acceded
to the Attorney General’s objections and declared the charges “a
nullity.”
I recently interviewed Davidson on Saturday
Morning Live on CKLN-FM 88.1(Saturday’s 10:00am to 1pm)
about the case against President Bush.
Says Davidson:
“When Lawyers against the War learned about it we wrote
to the Prime Minister (Paul Martin), the Minister of Justice
(Irwin Cotler) and former Minister of Immigration (Judy Sgro)
telling them that he ought not to be invited to Canada. Because
he had been accused by many academics, lawyers, citizens and
various kinds of groups and organizations around the world of
committing war crimes in Afghanistan and Iraq. And as such wasn’t
admissible to Canada because we have laws saying that either
people accused of war crimes aren't admissible or if they come
into Canada we have to prosecute them. So the government naturally
turned a deaf ear to us. Under the Canadian criminal code there
is a provision where the Canadian courts can take jurisdiction
of allegations of torture if the person is on Canadian soil.
So we filed seven torture charges against Mr. Bush on November
30th .”
It must be mentioned that the movement only had two weeks to organize
the protest against President Bush. When LAW was unable to pin
down President Bush in Canada they joined the prosecution of Donald
Rumsfeld and 11 other high ranking individuals filed also on November
30th 2004, by the US group Center for Constitutional Rights. This
case was dismissed and CCR, LAW and the other complainants are
appealing. LAW has members in 14 countries: U.S., Kenya, the UK,
Syria, Sweden, Holland, Denmark, France, Germany, Australia, New
Zealand, India and Poland.
LAW had Bush charged in Germany. Says Davidson,”One thing
we will do for sure is pursue similar charges in Germany as Part
of the prosecution launched there by the American Center for Constitutional
Rights. There is reason to think that the German authorities will
show more backbone in the face of the Bush administration’s
trashing of international human right human rights law.”
The movement of international lawyers is a
good thing and should be supported. This is a people-to-people
action which is positive.
However, we should not be so naive as to believe that the governments
of the U.S. or Germany have good intentions for the world’s
people. Both are concerned about their bottom lines. German imperialists
are no different than American or Canadian imperialists. We must
always remember there is such an animal as inter-imperialist rivalry
that will cause the imperialists to fight among themselves for
a slice of the capitalist pie. While Canadian Prime Minister Paul
Martin refused to join the U.S. on the question of Missile Defense
he did so to save his politic life.
Gerald Horne, author of a new book Black and Brown: African
Americans and the Mexican revolution, 1910-1920 supports
Law’s international efforts. Horne feels that internationalist
has always aided African Americans. International support has
always helped African Americans and American working people.
There is a historic precedent for this. On Dec.17, 1951, Paul
Robeson and William L.Patterson, two giants of the international
African Liberation Struggle, delivered to the United Nations
a petition titled, “We
Charge Genocide: The Crime of Government Against the Negro
People.” Many feel that this act helped spark the modern
civil rights and black power movements. The great El-Hajj Malik
El-Shabazz (Malcolm X) was talking about an updated version of
what Robeson, Patterson, George Crockett, Dr. W.E.B. Dubois,
Claudia Jones and others had started in 1951.
There are more international bodies in 2005
then there were in the time of Robeson. Could this case be taken
up by the African
Union (Kenya has a chapter of LAW) or the European Union which
has several members? Says Davidson, “Many countries over
the last decade or so have expanded their criminal jurisdiction
as they joined international conventions. All countries that joined
the conventions against torture have to deal with the issue. The
US joined in 1994 and Canada joined in 1987. So all countries that
joined that convention had to change their criminal law so that
they had to expand their capacity to prosecute crimes of torture.
“I think that persecution of these crimes is particularly
important because the so-called torture memos have been put into
the public realm. It’s become pretty clear what the Bush
administration was trying to do in the follow-up to the invasion
of Afghanistan and prior to the invasion of Iraq was to create
a class of non-people whom international and national laws didn’t
apply. So Mr. Bush tries to create this class by calling them ‘enemy
combatants’ The US courts have just recently decided that
it didn’t really matter what the President called them – they
were prisoners of war and entitled to rights under various conventions
starting with the Geneva Convention going on until the convention
against torture and so on.”
As we go to press a Kamloops, B.C. Vietnam
War veteran wants to add U.S. Secretary of State Condoleezza
Rice to the most wanted
list. In a press release John McNamer says, “Neither U. S.
Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice nor President George W. Bush
should be allowed into Canada while the Iraq war continues.” McNamer,
57, began the campaign March 13, with large banners displayed on
the lawn in front of Kamloops Courthouse that read “No to
Rice/Bush”; “Iraq War Illegal” and “Canada
is a Peacekeeper.”
“The U.S. needs to be pressured to immediately ask the international
community through the United Nations to assume complete management
of the Iraq situation in ways that are consistent with international
law. Until then, let’s not pretend that we accept U.S. foreign
policy conducted at the point of a bomb,” says McNamer. “The
entire world should isolate and punish people who violate international
law – be it Osama bin Laden or Condoleezza Rice, not give
them shelter and support.”
Toronto-based journalist and radio producer Norman (Otis)
Richmond can be heard on Diasporic Music, Thursdays, 8-10 p.m.,
Saturday Morning Live, Saturdays, 10 a.m.-1 p.m. and From a Different
Perspective, Sundays, 6-6:30 p. m. on CKLN-FM 88.1 and on the
Internet at www.ckln.fm. He can be reached e-Mail at [email protected]. |